Footnote Number Eleven

Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part IV

[Continued from Part III]

It should be borne in mind here that the ideas based solely on reason suffer not only from the defect that they fall short of the stages of certainty and cannot comprehend the finer points of theological matters, but they also suffer from another defect; namely, that discourses based solely upon reason are largely ineffective and futile in persuading the heart. The explanation for their ineffectiveness is that for any discourse to impact the heart it is necessary that its truth should be so well established in the mind of the listener that he should not be left with any room for doubt, and he should believe from the depth of his heart that what he is being told is not susceptible to any possibility of error.

I have just demonstrated that reason alone can never lead to perfect certainty. It is thus obvious that the effects that are produced by perfect certainty and the impact made by a decisive word upon the hearts can never be expected from reason alone. This is confirmed by daily experience. For instance, when a person returns home from having sojourned in a distant land then all kith and kin and even strangers inquire from him about that foreign country and their hearts are deeply affected by what he relates out of his eyewitness accounts, provided that he is not suspected of telling lies. What he relates is fully accepted and considered to be the truth without any hesitation or doubt. This is especially the case when the informer commands the reputation of being a respectable and righteous person. Why is his discourse so deeply effective?

It is effective primarily because he is known to be an honourable and truthful person, and it is further believed that whatever he relates and whatever news he brings of the circumstances of those countries is his eyewitness account. His discourses create such a deep imprint on all listeners that the whole scene appears before their very eyes. Many a time when he recalls and relates a poignant story or an emotional event pertaining to a nation, his words grip the audience so completely that tears well up in their eyes as if they were physically present at the scene and witnessing the event themselves.

On the other hand, if a person—who has never journeyed beyond the four walls of his home and has never been to that country, nor has heard anyone describe its details—were to begin to narrate stories of that country out of his own imagination, his nonsense would produce no effect. On the contrary, people ask him, ‘Have you gone mad and insane that you have begun to relate things that you have never experienced nor observed, which are above and beyond your limited knowledge?’ It is like the story narrated by a wise old man about a foolish person who overly praised wheat bread, saying that it is very tasty. When he was asked whether he had ever eaten it, he replied that he had not eaten it, but his grandfather used to say that on one occasion he had seen someone eating it.

In short, unless someone, in the estimation of the listeners, has comprehensive knowledge of an event, his discourse would produce no effect upon their hearts and would, instead, make him a laughing stock. This is the reason why the unsubstantiated discourses of mere intellectuals have never attracted the attention of anyone to the Hereafter with certainty. Their listeners continued to think that, as the orator was speaking out of conjecture, they could oppose him with their own conjectures, as neither side had witnessed the reality at the site. This is the reason why, when some intellectuals expressed themselves in support of the existence of God, other intellectuals opposed them and wrote books in support of atheism. The reality is that even the group of intellectuals who admitted the existence of God to some extent was never free from the vein of atheism, nor is it free today. Just consider these Brahmu people. Do they ever regard God as possessing perfect attributes? Do they admit that God is not mute, but truly possesses the attribute of speech as should be possessed by a being who is alive and well? Do they truly regard Him as the Absolute Planner and Provider? Do they ever believe that God truly is Self-Subsisting and All-Sustaining and that He can convey His words to sincere hearts? On the contrary, they consider His existence to be fictitious, lifeless, and concocted by human reason merely out of its own imagination. Unlike living beings, no voice is ever heard from Him, as if He were not God, but a mere idol lying in a corner.

I am astonished by how these people remain content with such immature and flimsy ideas, and what fruits they hope to reap from their self-fabricated assumptions. Why do they not search, like true seekers, for that God who is Omnipotent, Powerful, and Ever-Living, who has the power to affirm His own existence, and who can revive the dead in an instant by the call

[Urdu or Persian text in the original, see the original page]

[‘Verily, I am Allah’]? When they themselves know that the light of reason is smoky, then why do they not aspire for the perfect light? How foolish they are that while acknowledging their illness, they care not for its remedy! Alas, why do their eyes not open so that they see the truth of the matter? Why does the veil not lift from their ears so that they hear the divine call? Why are their hearts so twisted and their understanding so perverted that they have begun to level the very objection against the followers of true revelation that, in reality, applies to themselves? Have I not yet proven to them that they are utterly deficient in divine cognition and are in a perilous condition? Have I not yet demonstrated to them that complete and perfect divine cognition can be attained only through the Noble Qur’an and nothing else? And when it has been proven in every way that they are liars and in the wrong, then what kind of honesty and integrity is this, that while being oblivious to the mourning within their own homes, they declare the followers of Islam to be ill and level wicked and mischievous allegations—all of which certainly indicates that they have no concern or connection with the right path whatsoever. These words are not their words; rather, they are the stench of the rubbish of their jealousy and prejudice.

A supplement to this very conjecture of the Brahmu Samaj is yet another conjecture: Revelation is a restriction, and we are free from every single restriction; therefore, we are better off because a free person is better than a prisoner. I admit this criticism and confess that revelation is undoubtedly a restriction. However, it is the kind of restriction, without which, true freedom cannot be achieved; as true freedom means that one should be delivered from every type of error, doubt, and suspicion, and should attain the stage of perfect certainty, and should behold his Benevolent God in this very world. As I have proven within this very footnote, such a true freedom is achieved in this world by perfect and God-loving Muslims through the Holy Qur’an and is not available to anyone besides them, such as any Brahmu. Yes indeed, there is one reason why the Brahmu Samajists can be called ‘free’ and ‘unrestricted’—and it was from this very perspective that I, too, have called them ‘libertines’ at certain places in this book, just as some lewd scoundrels, after guzzling some wine or intoxicating themselves with a bowl of hemp, or smoking marijuana or other drugs, declare themselves freed from every kind of shame and modesty, and even from God, and throw all concepts of decorum and social hierarchy out of the window—they simply let out whatever thoughts come to their minds, and simply blurt out whatever they desire. In much the same way, some of the Brahmu Samajists have proven to me that they are free in the very same manner and, in fact, having become unrestrained and libertine, they may have attained worldly comfort to their satisfaction by declaring with their own tongue what is halal and haram and by placing the key to religious axioms in their very own hands. Driven by the urges of nafs-e-ammarah [the self that incites to evil], they now feel free to open or close whichever door they please; for, they themselves are [so they think] the founders of all religion and moral conduct. But they will suffer the consequences of this ‘freedom’ the day when they will have to answer to Almighty God for their dishonesty.

Another supplement to this conjecture of the Brahmu Samaj is an assertion—by making which they have dressed up the disfigured body of their objection in another attire—which is: To be a follower of revelation is an act tantamount to deviating from the right approach and is contrary to the course of nature because the clear and straight path to discovering the reality of everything, which the inner voice of every human being inherently demands, is to explain its essence through rational arguments. For instance, the true reason—upon which spiritual satisfaction depends—for theft being a vile act is that it is cruel and oppressive, and is therefore improper and unjust according to reason, not that any revealed book has declared its commission as a sin. Again, for example, arsenic, a poison, is essentially prohibited from consumption because it is deadly and fatal, and not because its consumption is forbidden in divine revelation. Thus, it is proven [they argue] that the guide of certain and real truth is reason alone, and not revelation.

These gentlemen, however, are still unaware of the fact that their argument was completely shattered at the very instant when it was proven with strong and cogent arguments that their reason is imperfect and incomplete. Is it sensible to continue, like a shameless man, to harp on the same dead thought that has already been pulverized by the powerful onslaught of mighty arguments? What a pity! What a pity! My friends, have you not heard it many a time that, although the reality of things is discovered to some degree through rational arguments, it is not [true] that perfection of all stages of certainty is dependent upon reason alone? You can be refuted by the very example that you have presented because arsenic being deadly and fatal has not been established solely by reason. Rather, this quality was understood to be a certainty when reason joined hands with proper experimentation and observed the hidden quality of arsenic. This is precisely what I am explaining to you, that just as reason had to have recourse to a companion—that is, the need for proper experimentation—to truly comprehend the quality of arsenic, in the same way, in order to deem divine matters and the reality of life after death as certainty, reason needs divine revelation; and without this companion, reason cannot operate in matters pertaining to theology, just as reason is helpless, imperfect, and incomplete without other companions in the other sciences.

In short, reason cannot consistently conclude anything with certainty on its own unless it is paired with a companion. Without such a companion, it cannot remain safe and immune from mistake and error, especially in relation to knowledge of the Divine, because the essence of all of its discussions and the true nature of this realm are hidden behind veils and nothing similar to it exists in this world. In these matters, imperfect reason cannot escape human error, let alone lead one to perfect divine cognition. The most that can be achieved through reason is only this much: someone hypothesizes the need—be it true or false—for something internally within his own mind; however, he cannot prove that what he deems necessary actually exists externally as well.

From this point of view, such a one’s prima facie knowledge—since it is based on a hypothetical need about which one does not know whether or not it corresponds to an external fact—is regarded merely as an unfounded conjecture and is entirely bereft and deprived of the stage of perfect certainty. I have repeatedly stated that it is absolutely impossible that reason should be able to attain the stage of perfect certainty by just piling up hypothetical needs and mere conjectures. Rather, to attain this perfect certainty, all matters whether secular or religious operate in accordance with only one irrevocable law, meaning that, every single matter, whether religious or secular, can attain the stage of perfect certainty only when the knowledge of the true nature of things is not confined merely to the needs perceived by conjectures, and when the basis for the proof of something’s existence is not simply that conjecture demands it, but its actual existence comes to be known in some other way as well, so that frail reason does not continue to drown in the whirlpool of mere ideas, but rather, it becomes truly aware of the existence of something which it had only hypothesized to exist.

Moreover, the attainment of certainty depends on the knowledge of actual events, and it is obviously not the function and responsibility of reason to report external events; rather, it is the responsibility of historians, reporters, and experts who have themselves observed these events or who have heard them from those who have observed them. Under these circumstances, man’s defective reason requires reporters, historians, and skilled persons. This is why one may go on endlessly scrutinizing something [theoretically], but mere conjectures can never demonstrate the true dignity and rank of something the way it is manifested [practically] with the aid of experience and history.

10 of 10 left today