Footnote Number Eleven

Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part IV, Part 2

Mere conjectural opinions cannot serve any purpose where an eyewitness testimony is needed, and one who simply shoots in the dark and fabricates stories cannot take the place of a historian who is acquainted with the facts or a person who has made a specific observation or experiment. Had that been the case, there would not have been any need for historians, reporters, and experienced persons; and people would have come to know through their conjectures alone about various world events, the understanding of which depends on history, experience, and the factual knowledge. As such, they could have run all affairs of the world merely through conjectural speculations. The need for historians, reporters, and experienced people arose only when unassisted reason and mere conjectures were not able to work, and it was feared that by boarding the ark of mere conjectures all enterprises of the world would sink, and it was realized that by the spinning wheels of reason alone the entire operation of this world would be ruined.

In fact, the matters pertaining to the world are not so complicated; rather, they are so evident and clear as if they are right in front of our eyes and within our view. The intricacies that are encountered in the phenomena of the unseen world—and the perplexities which are confronted while contemplating the world that is concealed and hidden beyond hidden—presents an unlimited ocean transcending observation and imagination. This world does not have even a thousandth part of such intricacies. Therefore, under these circumstances, unless we clearly and deliberately choose to deviate from the right path, we would undoubtedly be forced to admit that in order to precisely understand the circumstances and facts of that world and to attain perfect belief in them, the need for historians, reporters, and experienced people is hundreds of times greater in comparison to this world.

Now, when the historian and reporter of that world can be none other than the Word of God, and the ship of our certainty may wellnigh be destroyed in the absence of a reporter, and the tempestuous winds of doubt continue to hurl the ark of faith into the whirlpool of destruction; given these circumstances, what wise person would rely entirely upon the guidance of defective reason and turn away from the need of such a word upon which the security of his life depends, and the contents of which are not limited to conjectural speculations alone? Rather, in addition to providing rational arguments, it informs us of the true facts of the second world as a true historian and gives an eyewitness account.

With divine revelation, the dawn of truth breaks;

The eye that has not seen those holy scriptures has seen nothing.

The castle of my heart is filled with the fragrance of that musk;

The Beloved who had left me has returned.

The eye which does not partake of the light from the Furqan,

By God, its blindness will never be cured.

Of course it is true that reason is not without its use and its benefit, and when have I ever said that it is useless? Nevertheless, how can we escape the obvious fact that through reason and conjecture, alone, we cannot attain the treasure of perfect certainty which can be achieved through the combination of reason and revelation; nor can we escape faltering, making mistakes and errors, misguidance, self-approval, and self-conceit. Nor can our self-conceived ideas prevail against our carnal passions as the forceful, majestic, and awe-striking commandments of God can. Nor can our self-conceived fancies, idle speculations, and baseless superstitions yield the joy, delight, satisfaction, and contentment that are conveyed to us by the delightful Word of the True Beloved. Shall we then, by following reason alone, subject ourselves to all of the losses, disadvantages, misfortunes, and ill-fate, and open the door to thousands of calamities upon us? A wise person can never accept the senseless notion that He who has created the thirst for perfect divine understanding has withheld the brimful cup of complete divine understanding; and that He who Himself has drawn the hearts toward Him has kept the doors of true cognition closed, and has confined all stages of the cognition of God solely to the flights of our imagination at the time of our supposed need.

Has God created man so ill-fated and unfortunate that, in this world, he is to remain wholly disappointed and hopeless in obtaining full satisfaction of the cognition of God which his soul desires and his heart longs for, and for the attainment of which his heart and soul are filled with eagerness? Is there not one soul among the thousands of you who can realize that the doors of divine cognition—which are only opened by God—cannot be opened by human faculties, and that God’s own proclamation, ‘I am Present’, cannot be equalled by the hypothetical conjectures of human beings? Undoubtedly, God’s affirmation of His own Being is like a manifestation of God, but man’s saying so by conjecture is not the same; and since our conjectures based on reason cannot equal God’s Word, which points specifically toward His distinct Being, then why is His Word not needed for the perfection of certainty? Are your hearts not awakened by observing this obvious disparity? Is there nothing in our discourse which affects your heart? O people! There is no difficulty in understanding that human reason cannot be the instrument for ascertaining matters of the unseen, for who among you can deny that whatever we encounter after death, indeed, belongs to the domain of the unseen? For instance, reflect whether anyone knows with certainty how the soul departs at the time of death, where it goes, who accompanies it, where it is kept, and, thereafter, what experiences it passes through.

How can human reason make a conclusive decision regarding all of these matters? A person could give a conclusive verdict had he died once or twice before and had become familiar with the paths along which he reached God, and recollected the places where he had dwelt for some time; however, as it stands, we have only conjectures to fall back on. No matter how much you hypothesize, the fact remains that no sane person has ever visited the place and seen it for himself. Thus, in such a situation, it is obvious that to gratify oneself with these baseless conjectures amounts to a false sense of comfort, not true satisfaction.

If you were to view this in the spirit of ascertaining the real truth, you would testify yourself that human intellect and conscience can never understand all of these matters with certainty, nor does any page of the book of nature point to them with certainty. Leaving aside matters of greater profundity, reason is perplexed at the very first step—what the soul is, how it enters [the body], and how it departs. On the face of it, nothing is seen as departing or entering. Even if you were to enclose a living being at the time of its last breath inside a glass chamber, nothing would be seen departing from it. Similarly, if germs are produced in some matter that is enclosed within a glass chamber, one cannot discern the path of entry of these souls. The egg is even more astonishing as to how the soul flies into it, and if the chick dies inside, by what way does the soul escape? Can any wise person resolve this puzzle through the use of his intellect alone? You may run wild with your conjectures as much as you want, but nothing actual and certain can be established through reason alone.

That being the case at the very first step, what can this defective reason discover with certainty about the matters related to Hereafter? Is there no one left among you who can understand this fact? Do you feel no remorse yourself about this miserable plight of yours? You have such an insatiable craving for the carrion of the world that you eagerly travel thousands of miles over land and sea in pursuit of it, but does the world to come amount to nothing in your view? Alas! Why do you not understand that it is impossible to find a remedy for every anxiety of the soul and to treat every malady of nafs-e-ammarah through self-conceived imagination and conceptions?

It is the law of nature that when a man is overpowered by some carnal desire or is subjected to a spiritual calamity—for instance, when his anger is fuelled, or his sexual desires are aroused, or he runs into some trouble, or he is in mourning, or is stricken with grief and a painful situation, or has been overcome by some carnal or spiritual disturbance—he cannot cure his maladies and motives that have taken control over both his mind and soul, merely through his self-admonition and advice. Rather, to remove such passions he is in need of a counsellor who commands the respect of the listener, is venerable, truthful in his speech, perfect in his knowledge, and trustworthy of fulfilling his promises; and furthermore, has the power to achieve that which inspires awe, hope, or comfort in the listener’s heart. For, it is manifestly evident and obvious that man often finds himself in a situation where, although he really considers a sin to be a sin, or regards an action that is incompatible with steadfastness and patience to be contrary to steadfastness, yet the veil of negligence or the shock of sudden grief afflicts his heart. That veil is removed only when some other person, whose greatness, reverence, and truthfulness is established in his heart, admonishes him and urges him to do good or warns him, or comforts or satisfies him, in accordance with the situation. And his speech has such a marvellous impact that even though he presents the same arguments that are already known to the listener, he transforms a staggering one to be ready for action, an inactive one to be active, a weak one to be strong, and a disturbed one to be contented. All of these matters are such that a wise man would himself admit that he needs them when he finds himself in a situation of being overpowered by his ego and afflicted with anxiety. Rather, those whose souls are highly refined, seekers after truth, and those whose hearts are disgusted at the very onset of the turbidity and sordidness of sin, implore like a sick man for such treatment themselves when they are in situations where they are overpowered by their egos, so that they might be cured of their internal constriction by hearing some words of inspiration or warning, or by listening to some words of satisfaction and comfort flowing from the tongue of some man of God.

In short, it is certainly inherent within human nature that however knowledgeable and learned a man may be, his own words alone can never affect him as do those of others in times of calamity and arousal of carnal passion. For instance, if someone faces a disaster or is mourning the loss of a life, although he is aware that this world is not a place of permanent happiness and peace, nor is it everlasting, times of shock, grief, and anxiety overwhelm the helpless man and his heart is totally beyond his control. In this situation, if such a person—who, in his opinion, is exceedingly holy, saintly, and venerable—admonishes him to be patient because there are great rewards with God for those who are patient and that this world is not a place of eternal life—even though he already knew it—hearing this from his mouth impacts him with such a wonderful effect that it prevents him from falling.

In short, one’s own self-invented ideas cannot affect one’s heart at all times and on all occasions. Rather, many a time reason is so completely subdued by carnal passions or spiritual misfortunes that man loses the abilities of thinking and understanding, and on such an occasion he finds himself in a situation where the words of advice, warning, or satisfaction and comfort should issue forth from someone else.

·

10 of 10 left today