Signs of the True Faith
Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part V, Part 4
In short, true religion is not merely beholden to reason, for this would bring it into discredit and give rise to the suspicion that its texts have been plagiarised from men of letters—of whom there has been no dearth in this world. Rather, in addition to rational arguments, a true religion also demonstrates its intrinsic quality—that is, heavenly Signs. This is indeed the hallmark of a true faith.
The truth is that the self-concocted miracles and wonders which are tales of extreme exaggeration that ignorant people commonly attribute to some religions or personalities, cannot be a source of pride for any religion; on the contrary, they are a source of disgrace and humiliation. No other Prophet has had so many fictitious miracles attributed to him as have been attributed to Hadrat ‘Isa [ Jesus], may peace be upon him, to the extent that some ignorant ones even imagine that he had revived thousands—rather, hundreds of thousands—of the dead. The Gospels have documented such highly exaggerated accounts even to the point that on one occasion all the dead buried in a graveyard, which had existed for thousands of years, were revived and all of them walked into the city alive.
Now, anyone with intelligence can judge: Who would believe this degree of hard-heartedness that despite millions of people suddenly coming to life and entering into the city, recounting their stories to their descendants and confirming the truth of Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, but the Jews still did not believe! Moreover, if the revival of thousands of corpses was, in fact, the vocation of Hadrat ‘Isa, reason dictates that all of those corpses would not have been deaf and dumb. Some of them must have been the brothers, fathers, sons, mothers, grandmothers, grandfathers, or other near and dear relatives of those to whom these miracles were shown. For this reason a vast scheme had been opened for Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, to convert disbelievers into believers. Many of those [revived] corpses who were relatives of those Jews must have accompanied Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, and he must have arranged for them to deliver public addresses in a number of cities that must have been heard with the utmost interest and eagerness. When a corpse would stand up to address the audience: ‘O ye before me! Many of you present here at this time recognize me as you buried me with your own hands. Now I come before you having heard from the mouth of God that Jesus the Messiah is true, and he is the very one who revived me’—then this would have had an amazing effect, and it is obvious that such lectures from the dead would have had a massive impact upon the hearts of the people of the Jewish nation. Thousands upon thousands of Jews would have believed. Yet the Holy Qur’an and the Gospels affirm that the Jews had totally rejected Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him; in spiritual reform he was the least successful of all Prophets, and almost all the Jews considered him a deceiver and an impostor.
Ponder over it, O intelligent ones: Should this have been the result of such a supreme and magnificent miracle! Given that thousands of resurrected corpses testified to the truth of Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him—even affirming that they have seen Heaven inhabited only by the Christians who follow Hadrat ‘Isa, and seeing Hell filled with the Jews who rejected Hadrat ‘Isa—who could dare have even the slightest doubt in the truthfulness of Hadrat ‘Isa after all of these testimonies? And should anyone have doubted, then his ancestors—having been revived—would have been there to kill them saying, ‘O ye wretches! You doubt after our testimonies?’ Therefore, understand with full conviction that such ‘miracles’ are pure fiction. There is no doubt in the phenomenon of a miracle itself, but it only occurs to the extent that I shall henceforth explain in detail.
It is a great pity that the Muslims attribute such miracles to Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, that go against the norms set by the Holy Qur’an. They walk upon the road leading to a dead end. Not only do they go to the extent of believing the old Christian tales regarding Hadrat ‘Isa, but for the future they also believe that—contrary to the experience of the whole world—his descent from the heavens will occur at any moment, and they claim that in the coming Latter Days (although according to the age of the world—which is seven thousand years—these are the very Latter Days!), Hadrat ‘Isa will descend from the heavens alongside angels, creating a great spectacle. A swarm of hundreds of thousands of people will gaze upon the sky and people looking from afar will say, ‘He’s come! He’s come!’ as he descends near a white minaret in Damascus. However, the wonder is that such marvels are attributed to a weak and meek man who was not only unable to bring the Prophet Ilyas back to the world as proof of his own prophethood, but also to the point of even being hung upon the cross! Such phenomena are readily spoken about him. If such stories merit acceptance, then why do they deny the miracle of Hadrat Sayyed ‘Abdul-Qadir Jilani that is so well known among the masses, whereby he pulled a boat out of the bottom of the sea twelve years after it had sunk while carrying a wedding party, and all the people emerged forth alive, singing and rejoicing with bands and drums beating as they had been when the boat had sunk? Similarly, in another miracle it is said that once the Angel of Death took away the soul of one of his followers without his permission. When he learnt of this, he immediately flew up to the heavens, seized the angel, hitting him with a stick and breaking his leg. Thus, all the souls that the angel had extracted that day were set free and came to life again. The angel tearfully complained to God Almighty, but Allah Almighty said that ‘Abdul-Qadir occupies the station of Mahbubiyyat [being the beloved of God], so that none could get in his way, and even if he had revived every corpse that had ever passed away, he would be entitled to do so.
Now, whereas such well-publicised marvels have not been accepted while there was not much harm in accepting them, then why are such accounts—which are not only against the purport of the Holy Qur’an but also aid the idolatry of worshipping Jesus—attributed to a person whose worship has deprived 400 million people from the Tauhid [Oneness] of God Almighty? I cannot understand what superiority or uniqueness Hadrat ‘Isa ibn Maryam [ Jesus son of Mary] holds over other Prophets. Consequently, how egregiously wrong it is to assign him a ‘uniqueness’ which is the basis for idolatry from which a vast nation of people has been ruined! Alas! How sad that they have ruined themselves by relying upon a purely fabricated atonement, never giving any thought to the fact that only he will cross the ego’s river of fire who builds his ark with his own hands, and only he will get wages who does his work himself, and only he will save himself from loss who carries his own burden. How ignorant it is for a man to abandon all of his own efforts—depending upon another for his success—and to consider the physical strength of another to be of any benefit to his spiritual life!
It is the law of God that He has not made any human being unique in any aspect, and no one can say that he has such and such characteristic that no one else has. Had such been the case, this would form the basis for holding such a person as being worthy of worship. During the time of our Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, some Christians presented the uniqueness of Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, as being born without a father, upon which Allah Almighty immediately replied through this verse of the Holy Qur’an:
Meaning: ‘The case of ‘Isa [with Allah] is like the case of Adam. God created him from dust and said to him “Be”, and he was.’ In the same way was ‘Isa born of Maryam’s blood and Maryam’s fluid, and when God said ‘Be’, he was. What is so divine and unique in this trivial matter? In the rainy season, thousands of insects are born without a father or mother, and come out of the earth on their own; no one declares them to be God, no one worships them, no one prostrates before them. So if it is not ignorance to create such an uproar over Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him—without rhyme or reason—then what is it?
And to say that he is still alive to this day while all other Prophets have passed away goes against the Holy Qur’an. Allah the Almighty categorically affirms his death in the Holy Qur’an, so how can he be alive? It is also proven from the Holy Qur’an that he will never return. The verse 1
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
establishes both these points because the meanings of the entire verse from beginning to end are that on the Day of Judgment, God will question Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, whether he told people to worship him and his mother. To this he will reply: ‘As long as I was present among my people, I was aware of their condition and was a witness, but when You caused me to die, You alone were aware of their circumstances.’ In other words, after my death I knew nothing about their circumstances. Now, this verse categorically proves two points:
1. First, that Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, admits in this verse that as long as he was present among them, he was their guardian and they did not transgress in his presence, but after his death they went astray. Thus, if it is assumed that Hadrat ‘Isa,
may peace be upon him, is still alive in heaven to this day, then it will also have to be admitted along with it that the Christians have not yet gone astray to this day; for, in this verse their going astray has been established to be a result of the sentence 1
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
; that is, it has been made contingent upon the death of Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him. However, since it is obvious that the Christians have indeed gone astray, it must be necessarily admitted along with it that Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, has also died. Any other interpretation would constitute the rejection of a verse in the Holy Qur’an.
2. Second, it is clearly stated in this verse that Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, will deny any knowledge of the Christians’ transgression and will say that he knew of their condition only up to the time he was present among them, but ever since he had been caused to die, he was completely unaware of what happened after him. Now, it is evident that his excuse would be sheer perjury in the event he had returned to this world any time before the Day of Judgment and learnt that the Christians had gone astray. If that were so, the retort from God Almighty should have been: ‘O insolent man! Why are you lying in front of My face in My court, and why are you falsely claiming that you had absolutely no knowledge of their transgression, whereas you know that I had sent you back again into the world before the Day of Judgment and you fought wars against the Christians, breaking their cross and killing their swine! Yet [you dare] so much falsehood before Me as if you know nothing!’ Now, it is obvious how disgraceful for Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, is the belief that he would return to this world, and—God forbid—thereby expose him to the charge of perjury.