Signs of the True Faith

Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part V, Part 6

Returning again to our previous subject, I say that the miracles and marvels that the masses have attributed to Hadrat ‘Isa are contrary to the way of Allah. Just as one group has taken themselves to one extreme by rejecting miracles altogether, so has the other gone to the opposite extreme by employing extreme exaggeration regarding miracles—both sides having abandoned the middle path. It is evident that without miracles there would be no sure and categorical Sign for the existence of God Almighty, but if miracles are said to be of the kind just described, they deprive one of all the fruits of faith, so that faith can no longer be called faith, and it leads one to the verge of idolatry.

Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, has strangely been the target of the ignorant. During his lifetime, the irreligious Jews called him a disbeliever, a liar, a deceiver, and an impostor, and denied his spiritual exaltation. When he died, he was deified by those who were dominated by the disposition to worship man, whereas the Jews continued to deny even his spiritual exaltation. Now, against this came the doctrine of his physical ascent to heaven and it became widely publicised that he ascended bodily to the heavens, as if to say that the previous Prophets were exalted to heaven spiritually after death, but Hadrat ‘Isa, while yet alive, went to sit in heaven with his physical body, along with his clothes and all his bodily necessities.

This was a hyperbolic response concocted to counter the antagonism and rejection of the Jews with which they denied spiritual exaltation, yet this reply was entirely illogical because the Jews had no concern with bodily ascension whatsoever. It was a doctrine of their shariah [religious law] that those who die on the cross are accursed, disbelievers, and faithless; they are not spiritually exalted towards God Almighty. The doctrine of the Jews was that upon death, the soul of every believer is carried to heaven by angels and the doors of Heaven are opened for him, but the soul of a disbeliever is not raised to heaven. A disbeliever is accursed and his soul goes downwards. Since Hadrat ‘Isa was put on the cross, and also because some of the disagreements in their religious verdicts, the Jews had declared Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, to be a disbeliever; since, in their view, he had been killed through crucifixion and it was clearly decreed in the Torah that whoever is thus killed on the cross is accursed; therefore, on the basis of these reasons, they had declared Hadrat ‘Isa to be a disbeliever and had rejected his spiritual exaltation.

In the opinion of the Jews, the plea that the Messiah went up to the heavens in his physical body was laughable. As a matter of fact, this fabrication was perpetrated by those who were not acquainted with the teachings of the Torah. The very idea in itself is the greatest degree of gibberish, which exposes God to criticism. For, while the Messiah, may peace be upon him, had not yet conveyed his message to all of the tribes of the Jews, which had been divided into various sects, and not even a single sect had been guided through his hand up until that point, to leave the work of preaching incomplete and for Hadrat ‘Isa to ascend to heaven is totally against good judgement and tantamount to dereliction of his official responsibility. Moreover, it is self-evident that for Almighty God to arbitrarily seat him in heaven is a frivolous and useless act that can never be ascribed to Almighty God.

In short, it is a slander against Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, to say that he ascended to heaven with his earthly body. Just as his enemies had slandered him during his lifetime as a disbeliever and a liar, so have those who had gone to the other extreme in his excessive praise—being his foolish friends—bodily lifting him up to the heavens, as has been said: ادننز چ بدن رمی داں ز چ

اں ز ی چ [‘Saints do not fly; their disciples give them wings’].

And not only that, but they even declared him to be ‘God’. And then, after more time had elapsed, another doctrine was fabricated to the effect that he will descend from heaven with the same body, the last days of the world will be his, and he will be Khatamul-Anbiya’ [Seal of the Prophets]. Thus, in no other Prophet do we find anything like the false miracles and marvels that are ascribed to Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him. Stranger still, despite all the supposed miracles, he stands in first place when it comes to the failure and ineffectiveness in spreading the faith. Such a degree of ineffectiveness has not been seen in the case of any other Prophet. However, keep in mind that the religion that is now spreading in his name is not his religion.

The commandments to eat pork and belief in three gods are nowhere to be found in his teachings in the Gospels. Rather, this is the same idolatrous teaching that was opposed by the Prophets. The Torah contained only two major and eternal commands. First, not to deify a man. Second, not to eat [the flesh of ] swine. Both commandments were violated by the teachings of St. Paul.

[Urdu or Persian text in the original, see the original page]

[Surely, to Allah we belong and to Him shall we return].1

I would now like to elaborate on what a miracle is, and why a miracle is needed. In the first chapter of this book I will lay down the true essence and need of miracles. In the second chapter I will cite some examples of miracles in keeping with my claim. The third chapter would sum up the subject to conclude the book.

10 of 10 left today