Appendix to Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya, Part V

Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part V, Part 25

My Answer—Alas! You know nothing of the practice of Allah. It is not necessary for a Prophet to have definitive knowledge of a particular aspect of a prophecy that it shall necessarily be fulfilled only in this particular way. What is necessary for a prophecy, though, is that its implication should be supernormal, and human prowess or machination or contrivances should not be able to match it; but it is not necessary that the true nature of the prophecy should be made known in every respect. In the Torah, there is an important prophecy about our Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, but it is worded in general terms, that:

A Prophet like unto Moses will be raised from the Israelites from among their brethren.1٭

Nowhere was it clearly stated that he will be from among the Ishmaelites, his name would be so and so and his father’s name would be so and so, he will be born in Makkah, and he will come after lapse of this much time. This is why the Jews did not benefit the least from this prophecy and, for this very error, hundreds of thousands of the Jews ended up in Hell, even though the Holy Qur’an has alluded to this same prophecy in the verse:

And the Jews say that the ‘like of Musa’ [Moses] was the Prophet Yasu‘a [ Joshua] who succeeded him after his death. And the Christians say that ‘Isa [ Jesus] is the ‘like of Musa’, for, like Musa, he too came as a saviour. Now, tell me what good did this prophecy of the Torah do since it did not make a clear decision. Neither the Jews nor the Christians could recognize the Prophet, may peace be upon him, whom the prophecy was about and both groups remain deprived of the blessing of accepting him.

However, the revelation of Allah that descended upon me:

[Temporary residences and permanent ones will be wiped out]

is not ambiguous, as you imagine it to be, for another prophecy had previously been published in the same newspaper as:

Shock of earthquake.

Then subsequent to it, this second revelation:

[Temporary residences and permanent ones will be wiped out]

describes the features of that very earthquake already mentioned in the same newspaper. This prophecy cannot apply to the plague in any way. Both of these revelations were published in the same newspaper Al-Hakam just five months apart. Tell me, is it obduracy or not to declare such a grand prophecy—which foretells this great calamity twice in the same newspaper, specifying the term ‘earthquake’ and its attributes—to be useless and absurd? If that is so, it is doubtful if you can remain faithful to Islam, for it is written, in authentic commentaries, that when the verse:

was revealed, the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, said that he did not know what event that prophecy referred to.

Later, at the great victory in the Battle of Badr, he said that he had now realized that this was the victory the prophecy had foretold. On one occasion he said that [in a vision] he was given a bunch of grapes and was told that it was for Abu Jahl, but he was surprised that Abu Jahl was so thoroughly evil that he was not worthy to enter Paradise. And he [the Holy Prophet s (as) ] did not comprehend its purport at all. At last that prophecy was fulfilled when Abu Jahl’s son ‘Ikrimah became a Muslim. On another occasion, he made a long journey from Madinah to Makkah in conformity to a divine revelation in which the glad tiding was given that he would enter Makkah and make a tawaf [circuit] of the Ka‘bah. The time had not been disclosed. However, the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, suffered the hardship of that journey only on account of his interpretation, but that interpretation did not prove correct and he could not enter Makkah. So here an error was made in understanding the prophecy due to which some of his Companions were put in a trial.

Similarly, God had informed Hadrat ‘Isa [Jesus], may peace be upon him, that he would be a king. He took this revelation to mean a worldly kingdom and on that very basis Hadrat ‘Isa ordered his disciples to buy arms by selling their clothes. Eventually, however, it turned out to be a misunderstanding of Hadrat ‘Isa and that the kingdom implied heavenly kingdom and not the kingdom of the earth. The essential point is that a Prophet too is a mortal, and it is not a blemish for him if he happens to be mistaken in his interpretation. He is not, however, allowed to persist in the error and, at some point, he is necessarily informed of his error.

The prophecy of a Prophet should always be viewed with regard to its extraordinary import. The greatness and the significance of the prophecy does not suffer the least if the prophecy is not fulfilled in one specific way; rather, it is fulfilled in another manner. However, the essential element of the prophecy—namely, its extraordinary import—is evident in this second aspect as well; and, at the occurrence of the event, every reasonable person realizes that the true meaning of the prophecy was indeed the one that the unfolding event had itself revealed. To unfairly object to it is tantamount to mischief, dishonesty, and obduracy.

His Statement—To make an ambiguous statement that some calamity is about to come without specifying its nature and timing is not a prophecy but is mockery. And anyone can make such a statement.

My Answer—What shall I say except

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

[‘The curse of Allah be upon the liars’]! Such an opponent ought to merely say [as a counter prophecy] that such a calamity will not strike. Just think for yourself: How can this prophecy be deemed ambiguous when the word ‘earthquake’ is clearly present in it, it is also stated that a part of the country will be annihilated, it is also stated that it will occur within my lifetime, and with it is also the prophecy that it will be like unto Doomsday for those whom it will afflict? If this is ambiguous, then what else is called a clear prophecy? And saying that there is no indication of time in it, is tantamount to an attack not only Islam but on all heavenly Scriptures.

The prophecies of the Holy Qur’an, in most cases, do not make any mention of time. [Tell me], what time limit did the Torah give for the prophecy about Nebuchadnezzar and Titus of Rome? Similarly, what time stipulation was made in the prophecy that was present in the Torah concerning the advent of a ‘like of Musa’? And with regard to the prophecies about earthquakes and wars contained in the Gospel—can you tell what is the stipulation about time with regard to them? And then there is the prophecy about the advent of the Promised Messiah—which you construe to justify bringing Hadrat ‘Isa ibn Maryam [ Jesus son of Mary] back upon the earth a second time. What is the time frame given to you by God Almighty so that you may take a few steps forward with the intention of welcoming the one coming from so far off—at least proceed up to the extreme cold of the stratosphere if not farther—and take quilts etc. along with you?

I wish that you had considered that such objections are not just against me but your objections strike Islam and—God forbid—the Holy Qur’an itself ! Rather, they constitute an assault on all past Prophets. The essential point is that when a prophecy is extraordinary in itself or comprises of the unseen such that its knowledge is beyond human ken, if the prophecy contains a clear claim that such an event has never happened in this country for centuries, and that it had not in fact happened, and if, then, that event happens as claimed—to raise objections against such an extraordinary prophecy is the wont of the faithless who care nothing for God or the truth. Such unfortunate people, owing to their hard-heartedness, have always criticized every Prophet. Now you tell me! The certainty and persistence with which the news about the earthquake is given in the prophecy—can you cite its parallel in this country during the last two thousand years?

Also bear in mind that it is not just one prophecy; rather, my God has foretold about it through me again and again in the previous volumes of Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya. It is mentioned in Mawahib-ur- Rahman [‘The Bounties of the Gracious One’]. It is mentioned in the pamphlet Amin, and it is mentioned in various revelations in several issues of the newspaper Al-Hakam. And yet, the prophecy, in your estimation, is vague. Now what is the remedy for this!

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

[Surely, to Allah we belong and to Him shall we return].

·

10 of 10 left today