Appendix to Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya, Part V

Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part V, Part 36

And then, at the end of his article, he writes: ‘If God were to ask them on the Day of Judgment why they did not accept this man—Jesus son of Mary—and why they did not believe in him, they would submit Prophet Malachi’s book before Him.’

In short, it is a long-standing belief of the Jews that their true Messiah—the first Promised Messiah—will only come when Prophet Ilyas has returned to the world before him. And yet Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, wouldn’t listen to anything from them and insisted that the one who was to come was meant to be the Prophet Yahya. This is the verdict of Hadrat ‘Isa which you have raised a clamour against. Did Prophet Ilyas return to the world so that ‘Isa should come back too? Indeed, were it permissible for anyone to return to the world, then Hadrat ‘Isa would not be deemed a true Prophet. His Prophethood would be invalidated, for in that case, it would have to be conceded that, to unfairly justify his claim, he made Prophet Yahya to be Ilyas while Ilyas had not yet descended from heaven. Shouldn’t the story about the return of Elijah serve as a lesson for the wise as it led hundreds of thousands of Jews to reject Jesus and to be cast into Hell?

When the Prophet Ilyas—whose descent from heaven had been appointed as a Sign for the truth of the claim of Hadrat ‘Isa—did not descend from heaven, why then do the Muslims of today adopt the same path that led the Jews to disbelief before it? If descent from heaven had been the practice of God, then what were the obstacles in the path of Ilyas that he could not descend while the Scripture promised his descent, forcing Jesus to suffer embarrassment before the Jews and finally having to rescue himself from the nonsensical critique of the Jews by declaring Prophet Yahya to be the ‘like’ of Prophet Ilyas?

Just imagine how ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, would have been hurt by this contention of the Jews when they kept questioning how he could be the true Messiah when the Signs of the Promised Messiah were not to be found in him, for the Scripture says in clear words that the Promised Messiah would not appear until Ilyas had first come to this world. The Jews were apparently justified in this argument, for Ilyas had not descended from heaven—nor has he descended from heaven to this day. It would seem that all the audacity that the Jews showed in mischief and impertinence was due, indeed, to the fact that Hadrat Masih did not possess the required Sign for the Promised Messiah as given in the literal words of the Scripture. And Hadrat Masih had realized in his own heart that his reply was merely interpretative which the Jews would not accept. He, therefore, stated in soft words that the Ilyas who was to return to the world was none other than Yahya son of Zakariyya [ John the Baptist son of Zachariah], so accept him if you will. In the same vein, it was demanded of our Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, as is mentioned in the Holy Qur’an, that he should show a miracle of ascending to heaven and descending back, but ultimately they were told in categorical terms and God Almighty said:

To this day the Jews taunt the Christians that if Jesus was indeed the Promised Messiah, why did Prophet Ilyas not descend before him? The Christians have never been able to answer this objection and cannot argue with them.

Hence, our opponents should learn a lesson from the prophecy regarding the return of Prophet Ilyas lest their fate be like that of the Jews. However, to complete the similarity, it was also necessary that just as the earlier Jews had quarrelled much with Hadrat ‘Isa (as) about the second coming of Ilyas and had declared him faithless, disbeliever, and apostate, so would these people quarrel with me regarding the return of Hadrat ‘Isa. Little do these ignorant people realize that the person they supplicate for, and on whose account they hurl abuse at me, has himself decreed against them, for what I say to them with regard to the return of Hadrat ‘Isa is exactly what Hadrat ‘Isa said to the Jews. And just as God has named me as ‘Isa, so had He named Prophet Yahya as Ilyas.

This aforesaid precedent is reassuring to a person who has faith. And God also affirms:

The Jews were excusable to some extent because in their time there was to be found no decisive pronouncement in God’s books regarding the second coming of anyone, but now the verdict is already before us. Did the Prophet Ilyas return to this world in keeping with the prophecy of Prophet Malachi, so that these people too should entertain hope of the return of Hadrat ‘Isa?

In fact, the authentic ahadith do not even contain the word ‘second coming’ and only use the word نزول [nuzul—‘descent’], which is only used for honour and respect. We may say of an honoured guest that ‘when he comes he will “descend” at our house’, but would we take this to mean that he will return from heaven? In Arabic, the word for return is رجوع [ruju‘—‘return’], not نزول [nuzul—‘descent’]. It is a pity that this creed that helps Christianity has—without rhyme or reason—become such an entanglement for those who call themselves Muslims.

Thus humiliated and silenced, our opponents finally come up with the excuse that this is what their forefathers have been saying. They do not consider that those elders were not infallible, and that just as the ancestors of Jews stumbled in the understanding of their prophecies, so have these elders stumbled. By the will and providence of God Almighty, a similar false creed has gained currency among them—the creed had found currency among the Jews that Prophet Ilyas would descend from heaven a second time, and the elders of the Jews awaited the second coming of the Prophet Ilyas with much love and eagerness. Their writings—in poetry and prose—reveals how much their yearning and ecstasy was in anticipation of that event.

Your ancestors were not infallible, but the elders of the Jews even had among them God’s Prophets and recipients of revelation, yet they remained engrossed in this error and it remained hidden from them that some other Prophet was implied by the second coming of Prophet Ilyas and not that literally Ilyas would descend himself. Not until Hadrat ‘Isa had appeared could any of the Prophets or saints understand this sealed mystery that the return of Ilyas meant the coming of Prophet Yahya and not the real return of Ilyas. So it is nothing new that some of the elders of this Ummah were to be mistaken in the understanding of a matter.

What is even more interesting is that even these elders are not unanimous in this matter. There have been many ulema who were convinced of the death of Hadrat ‘Isa. Among them is Hadrat Imam Malik, may Allah be pleased with him, as it is written:

Meaning that there was disagreement concerning Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, as to whether he is alive or dead and Malik, may Allah be pleased with him, said that he is dead. And Muhy-ud-Din ibn al-‘Arabi wrote in one of his books—which is his last book—that ‘Isa would indeed come but only in a new manifestation; that is, that some other person of this Ummah would appear in the spirit of ‘Isa. It is an established creed among the Sufis that some perfect people return to this world in the manner that their spirituality manifests itself in some other person, and this latter person virtually becomes as if he is the same first person. The Hindus also maintain a similar principle and they call such a person an ‘Avatar’.

As for the belief that a living human being went to heaven or disappeared, it is also an ancient concept which had a different connotation in remote times, but the ignorant later took it to mean that a person goes to heaven with his body and then returns therefrom. Somewhat similar notions regarding Sayyed Ahmad Barelvi are in vogue among his followers even to this day, as though he too will return like Hadrat ‘Isa. And they believe that though, like ‘Isa, he remained unsuccessful in his first advent, he would wield the sword with great strength the second time. The truth is that such creeds were concocted to cover up for those people who left the world in failure and frustration after making grandiose claims.

·

10 of 10 left today