Appendix to Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya, Part V
Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part V, Part 35
Why should I be disappointed in someone who does not accept my Signs, when he neither believed the Word of God nor did he accept the testimony of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him—and he did not wish to disavow his error by being fearful of God? Then why should I regret if such a person fabricates a lie against me?
One person’s error cannot be used as justification by the other. If during the Dark Ages, such a notion had developed in the heart of people that Hadrat ‘Isa had gone to heaven alive, it cannot serve as an authority. In the best of ages [the age of the Holy Prophet s (as) and his Companions], there was no trace or sign of this concept; otherwise, why would the Companions, may Allah be pleased with them, have reached the agreement that all Prophets, peace be upon them, had passed away?
In Islam, the very first consensus was that all Prophets had died. When the Messenger of Allah, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, passed away, some of the Companions were also of the opinion that he had not died, and would return to this world and would cut off the noses and ears of the hypocrites. At that time, Hadrat Abu Bakr Siddique, may Allah be pleased with him, gathered them all in the Prophet’s Mosque and read out the verse:
Meaning that Muhammad, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, is a Messenger and all previous Messengers have died before him.
Thereupon, the Companions, who were all present, may Allah be pleased with them, realized that the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, had undoubtedly passed away, and they were fully convinced that none of the Prophets was alive. No one raised the objection that Hadrat ‘Isa (as) is outside the purview of this verse and he is still alive. Was it possible that those true lovers of the Messenger of Allah, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, could be reconciled with the notion that their own Prophet died at a relatively young age while ‘Isa had been alive for 600 years and would continue to live until Doomsday? Indeed, such a thought would have killed them. This is why Hadrat Abu Bakr, may Allah be pleased with him, reassured them by reciting this verse to them:
And such was the impact of this verse upon the hearts of the Companions that they roamed the bazaars of Madinah reciting this verse as though it had been revealed that very day. In Islam, the earliest ijma‘ [consensus] was that all Prophets had died. But O Maulawi Sahib!! What would you care for this ijma‘ of the Companions! Your religion is prejudice, not Islam.
The religion of Islam is being destroyed day after day by such false beliefs but you people are exulting;
Your beliefs have demolished the splendour of the Faith;
Enemies are happy, but the friends are sad.
It appears that prior to this ijma‘ upon the death of all Prophets, may peace be upon them, some of the less-informed Companions, who lacked perspicacity, were still unaware of the doctrine that all Prophets had died, and this was the reason why [Abu Bakr] Siddique, may Allah be pleased with him, needed to recite this verse to them. Upon hearing this verse, they all became convinced that all the people of the past had been consigned to their graves. It was in this context that Hassan bin Thabit, may Allah be pleased with him, wrote these few couplets as elegy for the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, in which he has alluded to this. These are:
(Translation): You were the pupil of my eye, so I became blind with your demise. After you, it makes no difference to me if someone (be it Jesus or Moses) dies, for I was only fearful of your demise.
May God reward him the best reward [for these verses]. This indeed is called love.1٭
And if there is an iota of fairness, you would realise that Hadrat Masih, may peace be upon him, was himself against the belief that someone can go to heaven and then return to the world. Therefore, when the Jews asked him about the second coming of the Prophet Ilyas [Elijah] and showed him the Scriptures—that it was written that Ilyas would return to the world, and only after the coming of Ilyas, the Messiah whose advent had been promised to the Jews, would come and he was to be the Khatamul-Anbiya’ [Seal of their Prophets]. Hearing this objection, ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, said that Prophet Yahya [ John the Baptist] who was among them and has come before him [ Jesus] ‘He is Ilyas who is to come. He who has ears to hear, let him hear!’1. His statement greatly displeased the Jews and they labelled him disbeliever, an innovator, and violator of the consensus of the people. In the same vein, in a book recently compiled by a great Jewish
have perished. For, in that case, today’s mischievous ulema would have contended that the Companions, may Allah be pleased with them, too believed that Hadrat ‘Isa is alive. But now, due to the presentation of Siddique the Great this verse, an ijma‘ has formed among all the Companions that all past Prophets had died—even couplets were composed reflecting this consensus. May God shower thousands of blessings upon Abu Bakr’s soul. He saved all souls from perdition. All the Companions were included in this ijma‘, not even a single one of them was out of it. It was the first ijma‘ of the Companions and was an act deserving of the utmost gratitude. There is a mutual similarity between Abu Bakr, may Allah be pleased with him, and the Promised Messiah, namely, the promise of God, in the Holy Qur’an, regarding both of them was that they would appear at a time when a state of fear will prevail upon Islam and a chain of apostasy will start. So, that is exactly what happened in the time of Hadrat Abu Bakr, and in the time of the Promised Messiah. That is, in the time of Hadrat Abu Bakr hundreds of ignorant Arabs had turned apostate after the demise of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, and there remained only two mosques where prayers were held. Hadrat Abu Bakr re-established them on Islam. Similarly, in the time of the Promised Messiah hundreds of thousands of people renounced Islam and became Christians. Both these circumstances are mentioned in the Holy Qur’an, that is, they are mentioned by way of a prophecy. (Author)
scholar, which I have with me in which he makes a great clamour to denounce Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, and calls him, God forbid, a great liar, a disbeliever, and heretic and appeals to people and says: ‘Be a judge and consider that whereas God had given the information in His book—as is written in Malachi, which is declared by the author to be authentic and from God—that the Promised Messiah of the Jews would not come until the Prophet Ilyas comes to the world again having descended from the heavens; and it is acknowledged that the Prophet Ilyas has not yet descended from the heavens—whose descent in advance of the Promised Messiah is essential—how, then, can we accept him as the true Promised Messiah? Are we to ruin our faith or turn away from the Torah? What should we do? And when the Prophet Malachi has told us, having received revelation from God Almighty, that it is necessary that the Promised Messiah must not be born among the Jews until Prophet Ilyas returned to the world according to the promise of God, how can this man be the Promised Messiah for Jews?1 ٭ And [he further says that] since we received the news of
Messiah of the earlier advent, for whom there is the precondition that Elijah would come to the world before him. This is the Messiah who Jesus claimed to be, but the Jewish scribes did not accept this claim and said that this claim was contrary to the categorical dictates of the Book of God, the reason being that Elijah, as told by the book of God, did not return to the earth from heaven. Hadrat ‘Isa told them again and again that such texts are metaphorical in nature and that the Elijah referred to here was the Prophet Yahya. But, since the Jews were strict literalists they did not accept this explanation and, for this very reason, they still do not accept Hadrat ‘Isa to this day and vilify him. (2) The second Messiah awaited by the Jews is the one regarding whom they believe that he would appear at the end of the sixth millennium. Therefore, there is much consternation among the Jews these days, since, according to the lunar calendar, the sixth millennium since Adam has ended and now the seventh millennium is underway, and that Promised Messiah has not yet come. The Christian scholars also held the same belief that the second coming of their Messiah would take place at the end of the sixth millennium. They too are in despair now as the sixth millennium has ended. At last, having despaired, they have expressed the view that the Church itself should
Ilyas’s return to the world before the coming of the Promised Messiah with such clarity and detail, which cannot have any different interpretation, if we artificially turn away from its obvious import and give some interpretation to this prophecy, it will be a terrible dishonesty. God did not tell us in His book that someone the like of Ilyas will come before the Promised Messiah; rather, He told us in explicit terms that Ilyas himself would descend from heaven. How can we deny such categorical tidings?