Appendix to Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya, Part V
Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part V, Part 39
I can see that there is no God other than Him. He is the One who created the earth and the heavens. When He is shining upon me like the sun and has granted me perfect insight and shown me His wonders and granted me the true knowledge and thus apprised me of His existence, how then can I ever leave Him? It is easier for me to surrender my life than to forsake the God who manifested Himself to me.
The blind foe speaks nonsense, for he knows nothing of God. His heart is stricken with leprosy and his eyes are bereft of sight. The knowledge of such people is limited to the worship of the idol of their conjectures. In their eyes there exists nothing beyond this idol. They are totally deprived of the knowledge of God who is recognized through His powers. They are like the blind one who steps forward but knows not whether there is an elevation or depression in front of him, or whether he is treading upon clean land or dirty soil.
In their foolishness, they stress one aspect and totally ignore the other. They say that when ‘Isa descends, he will become an ummati,1 and the difference between their words and the Word of God is that while they declare ‘Isa to be an ummati, God Almighty declares an ummati to be ‘Isa. This1٭was not such an error as could not have been rectified. If the providence of God Almighty could bestow the title of ‘Isa upon an ummati, and thus establish the superiority of this Ummah over the Israelites, then what was the need to bring ‘Isa ibn Maryam [ Jesus son of Mary] down from heaven and contradict the promise of God (that the one who leaves this world never returns to it)?2٭ Hadrat ‘Isa was the last Khalifah of Bani Isra’il [the Children of Israel], therefore declaring an ummati to be ‘Isa signified that he would also be the last Khalifah of this Ummah, and that the ‘Jews’ of this Ummah would attack him too and would refuse to accept him. But
him, he title of an ummati, then why should they object if God Almighty gives an ummati the title of ‘Isa? Does not the hadith امامكم منكم mean precisely that: ‘O people of the Ummah! The ‘Isa who is to come will be from among you and not from another people?’ (Author)
Meaning that, ‘You will indeed live your lives on the earth, and indeed die on the earth, and be resurrected from this very earth.’
How then was it possible that a person live in heaven for hundreds of years? And God says:
Meaning that, ‘And for you there is abode in the earth.’
How then is it possible that abode of ‘Isa for hundreds of years should be in heaven? Again God says:
Meaning that, ‘We have made the earth such that it draws everyone towards itself and holds every body in its grip.’
How then was it possible for Hadrat ‘Isa to have escaped the grip of the earth?
what is the wisdom in declaring a Messenger to be an ummati? Also, it is evident from the Holy Qur’an that every Prophet is part of the ummah of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, as Allah the Exalted says:
Thus, in this way, all Prophets, may peace be upon them all, belong to the ummah of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him. What then is the meaning or significance of declaring Hadrat ‘Isa to be an ummati? Are we to think that—God forbid—he recanted the faith that he had professed along with all the Prophets, and that as a punishment he was brought down to earth again to reaffirm his faith, whereas for other Prophets their previous affirmation was considered sufficient. Does such frivolous talk not amount to ridiculing Islam?
The matter was clear enough, for just as ‘Isa appeared at the end of the Jewish line of Khilafat, and the Jews rejected him and refused to believe in him, so was it destined that a Khalifah would be born at the end of the Islamic line of Khilafat whom the Muslims would reject and renounce. This is why he will be called ‘Isa, for he would be Khatamul- Khulafa’ [the Seal of the Successors] and also for the fact that he would be rejected just as ‘Isa was rejected. This is how Allah the Exalted had outlined this similarity in Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya in these words:
A Warner came unto the world, but the world accepted him not; yet God shall accept him and demonstrate his truthfulness with mighty assaults.
So, this was simple enough; everyone, where there is a similarity like that, would give a person such a name. A mountain has been made out of a molehill for nothing.
Had our opponents limited their belief to the point that ‘Isa would definitely return, but that he would follow the teaching of the Gospel, that he would not be bound to follow what is deemed lawful or unlawful in Islam, and would also pray in his own manner separately, and would recite the Gospels in his prayer instead of the Holy Qur’an, and would consider himself a Messenger independently and not an ummati, and, in short, would not exhibit any characteristic that would lead him to be called an ummati; rather, he would abide by the Torah and the Gospel and follow their faith, then the point at issue would be whether the return of such a person could be considered beneficial for Islam while he practically shows himself to be separate from and even against Islam?
Obviously, the coming of such a person would not augur well for the Muslims. If a man of such stature presented himself as someone who does not conform to the norms of Islam, and did not pray like the Muslims, and preached the Gospel to the people instead of the Holy Qur’an, and ate what Muslims do not eat, and drank wine, then he would undoubtedly be the cause of great tribulation for Islam, and possibly there might also be some strife between him and the Muslims. Such a dangerous person would cause Muslims to be led astray, and it would hardly be surprising if they started converting to Christianity.