Laying to Rest Doubts by Sayyed Muhammad ‘Abdul Wahid

Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part V, Part 6

In Sahih Bukhari, where the future ‘Isa is described as an ummati, his physical appearance is also described as distinct from the first ‘Isa. Of course, had the ahadith only used the word Nabi and not ummati, one might have been mistaken, but now that Sahih Bukhari has clearly written

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

[‘your Imam from among you’] with regard to the coming ‘Isa: ‘O my followers, the coming ‘Isa is also only an ummati and no more.’ Likewise, Sahih Muslim records these words

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

meaning that, ‘Isa will be your leader and will be from among you.’ That is to say, he will be an individual from within this Ummah.

Thus, when it is proven from these ahadith that the ‘Isa to come is an ummati, it follows that him being called Nabi [Prophet] in the Word of God is not with the sense that is applicable to an independent Prophet. Rather, the only intent here is that God Almighty shall have discourse and converse with him and He shall reveal to him the news of the unseen. This is why, despite being an ummati, he will also be called a Nabi. And if it is asked, ‘How could any ummati be called a Nabi—it being essential for a Prophet that God speak to him—when the door of divine discourse and revelation is closed upon this Ummah till the Day of Resurrection?’; the reply is that this door is not closed upon this Ummah at all. Had this door been closed upon this Ummah, this Ummah would have been a dead ummah and would have become distant and estranged from God. Moreover, had this door been closed upon this Ummah, why would this prayer be taught in the Holy Qur’an:

The fact that the Holy Prophet s (as) has been called Khatamul-Anbiya’ [the Seal of the Prophets] does not mean that, after him, the door to divine converse and discourse is closed. Had this been the import, this would then be an accursed ummah which, like Satan, would be forever removed and alienated from God. Instead, what it means is that direct bestowal of the gift of revelation from Almighty God is barred and it is impossible and prohibited for anyone to receive this blessing without rendering obedience to the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him. It is a point of honour for the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, that obedience to him is so blessed that when a person renders the fullest obedience to him, he is granted the honour of converse and discourse of God.

What honour, stature, spiritual prowess, and holy power would a Prophet have in his person if the people who claim to render obedience to him are blind and devoid of sight, and God does not open their eyes through His converse and discourse. How absurd and futile is the doctrine that one should maintain that after the Holy Prophet s (as) the door to divine revelation has forever been closed, and that there is no hope for it in the future till the Day of Resurrection, and that one needs only worship the tales from the past. Can such a religion be worth its name in which no direct evidence of God can be found—all it has are tales? And even if one were to give up one’s life in His path, and totally lose oneself in seeking His pleasure, and give Him preference over all else, God would still not open the door to His recognition for him, and would not bless Him with His converse and discourse.

I swear by Almighty God that no one in this age would be as disgusted with such a religion as I would. I call such a religion a satanic religion—not Godly—and I am certain that such a religion leads to Hell. It keeps one blind and lets him die blind and takes him to the grave blind. But, at the same time, I swear by the Gracious and Merciful God that Islam in not such a religion. In fact, Islam is the only religion in the world that has the quality of investing one with divine discourse on the condition that one renders true and full measure of obedience to our lord and master, the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him. This is the very reason why the hadith says:

Meaning: ‘The saintly ulema of my Ummah are like the Prophets of the Israelites.’ In this hadith, too, the saintly ulema are called ummati on the one hand, and are likened to the Prophets on the other.

It is self-evident that whereas Almighty God has continued to speak to His servants from ancient times—so much so that even women among the Israelites were honoured with divine converse and discourse, such as the mother of Musa and Mary the Truthful—then how unfortunate and wretched is this Ummah that its men are not equal even to Israelite women? Can it be expected that now is such an age that in this age God still hears but no longer speaks? If there is no dishonour for Him to hear the supplications of poor mortals, why is it a dishonour to speak to them?

Let it be remembered that attributes of God Almighty are never suspended. So, just as He shall always continue to hear, so shall He continue to speak. And what can be a clearer argument than this that the continuation of God’s speaking, like His hearing will never come to an end? And it proves that there will always remain a group of people with whom God will continue to have converse and discourse. And I cannot comprehend why people get so agitated by the word Nabi [Prophet]. Once it has been established that the coming Messiah will be from within this Ummah, what is the harm if God called him a Nabi? Such people do not see that he has also been called an ummati [follower of the Holy Prophets (as)] and invested with all the attributes of an ummati. This compound name is quite distinct and Hadrat ‘Isa, the Israelite, was never known by this name. Further, Almighty God has repeatedly called me an ummati as well as a Nabi in His revelations. Hearing these names creates extreme ecstasy in my heart and I express my gratitude that I have been honoured with this compound name. The wisdom behind the granting of this compound name seems to be to strike the whip of castigation upon the Christians that whereas they portray Jesus, son of Mary, as God, our Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, is a Prophet of such calibre that an individual from his Ummah can be a Nabi and can be called ‘Isa despite being an ummati.

His Statement—With regard to the Promised Mahdi, there are found in some ahadith words such as من وُلد فاطمۃ [‘from among the progeny of Fatimah’], and من عترتی [‘from my progeny’], and من اھل بیتی [‘from among the people of my household’], and it is also written

[Urdu or Persian text in the original, see the original page]

[‘his name will be my name, and the name of his father will be that of my father’]. Please explain what is meant by each of them.

My Answer—My claim is not that I am the Mahdi who conforms to من ولد فاطمۃ [the progeny of Fatimah], من عترتی [from my progeny], etc. Rather, my claim is that of being the Promised Messiah, and regarding the Promised Messiah, there is no statement of any muhaddith [scholar of hadith] that he would be from among the progeny of Fatimah etc. Nevertheless, at the same time—as every muhaddith says—I also say that all the ahadith regarding the Promised Mahdi are moot and suspect and not one of them is authentic. The degree to which fabrication has taken place in these ahadith has not taken place in any other hadith.

During the time of the Abbasid Khulafa’ etc. the Khulafa’ were very fond of pronouncing themselves the Promised Mahdi. So for this reason, some ahadith describe the Mahdi as being from the progeny of ‘Abbas and some from the progeny of Fatimah. There are some ahadith which also say that رجل من اُمّتی ‘He will be a man from my Ummah.’ But essentially all of these ahadith are not worthy of any trust. This is not just my word; all eminent scholars of the Ahl-e-Sunnah have been saying the very same. As opposed to these ahadith, this hadith recorded by Ibn-e-Majah is very authentic:

[Urdu or Persian text in the original, see the original page]

meaning, there is no other Mahdi; ‘Isa is the very same Mahdi who is to come.

His Statement—The prophecies of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, that even the divines have tried to interpret [rather than taking them literally], are mostly those that have been disclosed in the form of dreams.…

My Answer: I could not understand this question; hence, I am unable to answer it.

His Statement—Literal-minded people do not possess inner insight; hence, there is no wonder that they do not recognize the Promised Messiah. But the men of God and men of insight ought to recognize His Holiness through revelations etc. as the late Qadi Thanaullah of Panipat writes in regard to the Promised Mahdi, in his book Tadhkiratul-Ma‘ad:

[Urdu or Persian text in the original, see the original page]

[‘The saints from Levant and the elite from Iraq will come to pledge allegiance to him’].

·

10 of 10 left today