Laying to Rest Doubts by Sayyed Muhammad ‘Abdul Wahid
Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part V, Part 5
In truth, the verse:
should by itself suffice for a seeker after truth, for it shows that the ‘exaltation’ that our opponents are so vocal about, is to take place after death and not before, for this is proven by God’s own testimony, and it does not behove a believer to reject Divine Testimony. And since it is clear, on the explicit authority of the Holy Qur’an, that the ‘exaltation’ is experienced after one’s death, it proves that this is the same exaltation which God has promised to every believer upon his death.
It is indeed strange that while God has placed
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
[‘I shall raise you to Myself ’] after متوفّیك [‘I shall cause you to die’], these people would like to reverse the order so that they might somehow portray Hadrat ‘Isa as sitting [somewhere] alive in the heavens. In this case how can they be different from the Jews in terms of interpolation? And if these people, like the Jews, have the right to change the Holy Qur’an arbitrarily, then the Holy Qur’an is not secure! Can they produce even one single hadith that permits them to put
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
[‘I shall raise you to Myself ’] before متوفّیك [‘I shall cause you to die’]? And when it is not permitted by either the Holy Qur’an or the Hadith, why do they not fear the curse that has already befallen the Jews?
His Statement—According to your statement, Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, after being saved from the cross, had gone to Kashmir. First of all, it was not easy at that time to reach Kashmir, especially travelling incognito. Then there is the objection why his disciples did not flock around him, and why Hadrat ‘Isa remained obscure like one buried alive?
My Answer—The same God who directed Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, to move to Kashmir, had also become his Guide, so what is so strange about a Prophet reaching Kashmir? And if this is so strange, then a faithless person can also wonder how our Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, remained hidden from the eyes of the disbelievers when they had reached the very mouth of the Cave of Thaur during his migration to Madinah. Therefore, the answer to such objections is that God’s special grace that attends the Prophets extraordinarily saves them and guides them. As to the question, ‘If Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, had gone to Kashmir, why did the Disciples not reach him?’; the reply is that the lack of knowledge regarding something does not necessitate its non-existence. How do you know that they did not reach him?
However, since it was a secretive journey1 ٭—just as the journey of our Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, at the time of migration was secretive—it was considered unwise to travel with a large caravan, just as it is evident that when our Prophet may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, had migrated to Madinah he was accompanied only by Hadrat Abu Bakr, may Allah be pleased with him; and undertaking the 200 kose1 journey to Madinah was not easy even at that time. Had the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, wished, he could have taken 60 or 70 people with him, but he only made Hadrat Abu Bakr, may Allah be pleased with him, his companion. To meddle into the mysteries of Prophets is an improper meddling.
And how do you know that the Disciples did not come to India to join Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, even afterwards? On the contrary, the Christians themselves believe that some of the Disciples did—indeed—visit India in those days. The arrival of the disciple Thomas in Madras and the gathering of Christians in a festival every year in Madras to this day in its commemoration is something which is no secret to any knowledgeable person. In fact, the tomb in Srinagar, Kashmir, which we call the tomb of Hadrat ‘Isa, is believed by some eminent Christian clergymen to be the tomb of some disciple. This is despite the fact that the person buried in that tomb wrote in his book that, ‘I am a Prophet and a prince, and the Injil [Gospel] was revealed to me.’ It is also written in the historical books pertaining to Kashmir, which I have had access to, that this Prophet was from among the Israelites, that he was called the Prince Prophet, and that he had migrated to Kashmir from his own land. Also, we learn from the time of his arrival as is recorded in these books, that nineteen hundred (1,900) years have elapsed since the time this Prophet came to Kashmir.
And we also indict the Christians that whereas you admit that the person in that grave who is buried in Mohalla Khanyar, Srinagar is a disciple of Jesus, but how could he be a disciple when it is written in his own book that he was a Prophet and was a prince and the Injil [Gospel] was revealed to him? Can a disciple say that he is a Prophet and a prince and the Injil had been revealed to him? Thus, there can be no doubt that this tomb, which is in Kashmir, is that of Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him. And let it be clear to those who believe him to be sitting in heaven that he, in fact, rests in Kashmir; that is, in Mohalla Khanyar, Srinagar. Just as God Almighty had kept the People of the Cave hidden for so long, so did He keep Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, hidden and finally disclosed the truth to me. There are thousands of such instances in the works of God Almighty, and it is not His way to seat anyone in heaven with a mortal body.
His Statement—In ahadith, ‘Isa [ Jesus], who is to descend, has been called Nabiyyullah [‘the Prophet of God’]. Can it be proven from the Holy Qur’an and Hadith that a Muhaddath [recipient of discourse with God] has also been called a Nabi [‘Prophet’]?
My Answer—In Arabic and Hebrew, the word Nabi [Prophet] merely means one who makes prophecies—one who makes a prophecy on the basis of revelation received from God. Thus, when—on the authority of the Holy Qur’an—the door of such Prophethood is not closed whereby a person, through grace of and submission to the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, may be granted the honour of converse and discourse with God and may be informed of hidden matters through divine revelation, then why would such Prophets not appear among the Muslims? What is the argument for it? I do not hold the belief that a seal has been placed on this kind of Prophethood. Only the door to that kind of Prophethood is closed that is accompanied by the ordinances of a new Shariah or that is a claim that moves away from submission to the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him. But a claim to Prophethood by one whom divine revelation describes as an ummati [follower of the Holy Prophets (as)]
on one hand and also calls him a Nabi [‘Prophet’] on the other, is not in contradiction to the injunctions of the Holy Qur’an, inasmuch as such Prophethood—being that of an ummati—is a reflection of the Prophethood of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, and is not an independent Prophethood.
Had you properly reflected on the ahadith, this objection would not have arisen in your mind at all. You say that ‘Isa [ Jesus] who is to descend has been called Nabiyyullah [‘a Prophet of God’] in ahadith; I say that the same Jesus who is to descend has also been called an ummati in ahadith.1٭
Can you tell me from the Holy Qur’an or Hadith that ‘Isa ibn Maryam [ Jesus son of Mary], the past Prophet, has been called an ummati at any place? It is thus quite clear that this ‘Isa who is called both a Prophet and an ummati is a different ‘Isa. He is not the ‘Isa [ Jesus] who lived among the Israelites, who was an independent Prophet, and to whom the Injil was revealed. How can you make him an ummati [follower of Holy Prophets (as)]?