Reply to Doubts of Rashid Ahmad Gangohi
Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part V
Reply to the doubts raised by
A Collection of Maulawi Rashid Ahmad Gangohi’s Absurdities
In this book, the author has tried desperately to disprove my claim. And, to lend weight to his viewpoint, he has used much that is contrary to the facts. This book is utterly untenable, baseless, and full of absurd notions and fabrications. I know that there is no need to refute it at all, and anyone who has basic knowledge of the Holy Qur’an and Hadith does not require a refutation to be written; however, since I have heard that Maulawi Rashid’s followers in the vicinity of Saharanpur hold this book in great esteem and read it with much reverence—considering it to be a memorable relic of his lifetime—I thought it appropriate that, in order to save such people from being misled, answers be given to some of the more significant objections that have caused the ignorant and unlearned people of that area to fall into a pit of misguidance and take pride in this book, which is a compilation of falsehoods.
In order to open up a straight path for seekers after truth, I deem it appropriate to describe briefly the real issue that is the basis of dispute. It is that my opponents, Maulawi Rashid Ahmad included among them, hold the belief that Hadrat ‘Isa [ Jesus], may peace be upon him, has not died and that he has gone to heaven with his earthly body for some purpose,1٭and that he will return to the world at some time before the Day of Resurrection. They do not, however, explain the purpose for which he was raised to heaven. Was it merely to save him from the hands of the Jews, or was there something else? And they cannot explain why, now that nearly 2,000 years have passed, he is still in heaven. Is there still some fear in his heart of retribution by the Jews? They also cannot explain why he was given the distinction, withheld from all other Prophets, of being in heaven for such a long period of time—now approaching 2,000 years—and descending to earth at some point in time in accordance with the prophecy of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him. Moreover, they cannot explain the wisdom that God had in a physical ascension and subsequent descent. Was it the fear of the Jews apprehending him or something else? And they cannot explain why the distinction of this ascension and descent was granted to a person who God knew would be deified, and that 400 million people would believe him to be the son of God—rather, God—merely because this miracle is ascribed to him.
Although these people assert forcefully that Hadrat ‘Isa has not died—rather, he is alive—they still cannot explain on the basis of which explicit and decisive pronouncement of the Holy Qur’an his continued existence, in contravention to the practice of God, stands proven. On the other hand, the belief on which God has established me, on the basis of enlightened conviction, is that Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, has died like other human beings after living a natural lifetime for a human. As for his ascension to heaven with his earthly body and then returning to the earth with his earthly body at some later age, these are all calumnies against him. Allah the Lord of Honour and Glory says:
Thus, the real issue that needs to be settled and decided is whether it is true that Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, did indeed ascend to heaven with his earthly body, in contravention of divine practice. If it can be proven from the clear and explicit statements of the Holy Qur’an that Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, was in fact raised with his earthly body to heaven, then there would be no need to dispute his physical return, because, in keeping with authority in the Holy Qur’an, if one were to go to heaven with an earthly body, he would necessarily have to return.
So if Hadrat ‘Isa has gone to heaven bodily, there is no doubt as to his return. The reason is that, even if he was not required to return to earth for any other purpose, he would still need to come back to die, as there is no place in heaven for graves. And it is established from the clear and explicit statement of Holy Qur’an that every human being shall die only on earth, be buried only in the earth, and be resurrected from the earth, as God says:
Granted, it is possible that he is ill when he descends from heaven, or becomes ill on the way, and then dies upon reaching the earth. I say this because it is established from ahadith [pl. hadith] that the ‘Isa to come will descend clad in two saffron-coloured sheets, and all interpreters of dreams agree that a saffron-coloured sheet denotes illness.
I have declared many times that I have been ordained by God as the Promised Messiah. These two characteristics are also mentioned among my physical characteristics as recorded in ahadith. Just as a saffron-coloured sheet denotes an illness, and as two saffron-coloured sheets have been mentioned in ahadith with regard to the Promised Messiah, so do I suffer from two illnesses. One illness is in the upper part of my body—and this is the ‘upper sheet’—which is the vertigo from which I suffer; sometimes, I fall to the ground due to its severity and the flow of blood to my heart is reduced, creating a frightening situation. The second illness is in the lower part of the body, and that is polyuria, which is also known as diabetes. I have to pass urine frequently on a daily basis; at times it reaches up to 15 or 20 times, but on occasion it can be a hundred times during the span of a full day and night, and this, too, causes much weakness. So these are the two saffron-coloured sheets that have become my lot. Even those who do not accept me must admit that Hadrat ‘Isa will bring with him this ‘gift’ from heaven at the time of his descent; i.e. he will suffer from two illnesses, one shall be in the upper part of his body, and the other in the lower part of his body.
Now, if someone were to say that these ‘sheets’ signify real sheets, then it would mean that Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, at the time of his advent, will be clad in two saffron-coloured sheets in the manner of Hindu yogis. But these meanings go against the interpretation that the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, has made concerning his visions. For example, the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, had seen [in a dream] two bangles on his hands, and he interpreted them to mean two false prophets; and he had seen cows being slaughtered, and interpreted it to mean the martyrdom of his Companions, may Allah be pleased with them. He had seen a large cloak for Hadrat ‘Umar, may Allah be pleased with him, and interpreted it to signify his taqwa [righteousness]. So why, in the case of this hadith, should we not interpret the two saffron sheets in the way it has been done—in accordance with the tradition of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him—unanimously by all the eminent interpreters of dreams in Islam? There is not a single one opposed to this interpretation. And the interpretation is that the two saffron sheets symbolize two illnesses. I can swear by God that this is also my own experience. Countless times I have seen a saffron sheet on the body of a person in a dream—either with reference to myself or someone else—and it has always materialized as an illness. Thus, it is outrageous that just as the word متوفّیك [mutawaffika—‘will cause you to die’] is interpreted differently when it pertains to Hadrat ‘Isa—in contravention of its universal meaning—so should the two saffron sheets be interpreted in contravention of the meaning given by the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, his Companions, may Allah be pleased with them, the Tabi‘in [the generation after the Companions], the Taba‘ Tabi‘in [the generation of the Tabi‘in], and the Imams of Ahl-e-Bait [those who belong to the household of the Holy Prophet s (as)].
In short, the critically important discussion at this juncture is whether or not Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, actually died, because, if it is established that he has gone to heaven with his earthly body, then, as I have just mentioned, it is necessary for him to return to the earth in any event—whether to join the Mahdi or merely to die. This is the essential contention which, once settled, will resolve the entire dispute, and the party that possesses strong arguments in favour of the life or death of Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, is truthful. Once this disagreement is resolved, all peripheral discussions become unnecessary; rather, all the miscellaneous objections of the vanquished party become automatically rejected. Hence, this is the vital issue that a seeker of truth needs to ponder with full attention.
The unfortunate matter here is that despite the fact that the Holy Qur’an has spoken of the death of Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, in clear words; the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, has clearly stated that Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, is included among the souls that have departed from this world; and the Companions, may Allah be pleased with them, have agreed to this verdict with open and manifest consensus that all Prophets have died,1 ٭
en due to the demise of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him. Because of this state of grief, when Hadrat ‘Umar (ra) heard the words of some of the hypocrites, he said that the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, would return to the world and cut off the ears and noses of the hypocrites. Since this was an incorrect notion, Hadrat Abu Bakr Siddique first went to the house of Hadrat ‘A’ishah Siddiqah (ra), lifted the sheet from the face of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, kissed his blessed forehead, and said:
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
. Meaning that: ‘You are holy, in your life and in your death. God will never subject you to two deaths. For you is only the first death.’ This was meant only to convey that the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, would not return to this world. He then gathered all the Companions (ra) in the Prophet’s Mosque—incidentally, on that day all the living Companions (ra) were present in Madinah—and after gathering them, Hadrat Abu Bakr, may Allah be pleased with him, climbed the pulpit and read the verse:
Meaning that: ‘The Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, is but a Prophet, and all Prophets before him have passed away. So if the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, too were to pass away or were killed, would you abandon the faith?’ [Surah Al-e-‘Imran, 3:145]