Chapter One

Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part III

Submission of Arguments that are

External and Internal Evidence to Prove the Divine Origin and Superiority of the Holy Qur’an Before laying out the arguments in this chapter, it is necessary to mention some preliminary points that are of fundamental importance for understanding the details and substance of the following arguments, and to comprehend their purport. These preliminary points follow.

External evidence signifies those extrinsic circumstances which, when examined, prove that a given book is revealed by Allah, or that there is a need for a book to be revealed by Allah; and internal evidence refers to the inherent excellences of a book that are present in the book itself, and whose study makes it a rationally incontestable fact that it is the Word of God, and that it is impossible for man to write such a book.

The arguments that serve as external evidence in support of the divine origin and superiority of the Holy Qur’an are of four types: first, those proofs that are derived from matters that need to be reformed; second, those that are derived from matters that need to be perfected; third, those that are derived from matters that manifest the power of God; and fourth, those that are derived from matters relating to the unseen. However, the arguments that constitute the internal evidence of the divine origin and superiority of the Holy Qur’an are all derived from matters manifesting the power of God. The explanation of the above types is as follows:

Matters that Need to be Reformed refer to matters such as disbelief, infidelity, idolatry and sinful conduct, which people have adopted in place of true doctrines and righteous actions, and which may have become so widespread in the world that eternal divine favour should address itself to their reform.

Matters that Need to be Perfected relate to the teachings which are found in defective condition in revealed books, and whose defectiveness and incompleteness are manifested upon comparison with perfect teachings, and which are therefore in need of a revealed book to raise them to the level of perfection.

Matters that Manifest the Power of God are of two kinds:

1. External evidence:

These refer to things that are created by God without any human planning and that invest every insignificant particle with such majesty, dignity and greatness as is impossible according to reason, and of which no parallel is to be found on the face of the earth.

2. Internal evidence:

These refer to those beauties of form and meaning of the revealed Book, the like of which human powers are utterly incapable of producing, and which, by being truly matchless and peerless, point to the Unique and Almighty God as though reflecting His very countenance.

Matters Relating to the Unseen mean those matters which are proclaimed by a person with regard to whom it is certain that their exposition is, in every respect, beyond his power. That is to say, by looking at these matters and by considering the circumstances of the person in question, it becomes manifestly clear that he could not have acquired the knowledge of those matters either by observation and experience, nor could he have learned them by thought and reflection; nor should it be possible to imagine that he could have obtained their knowledge from one who was familiar with them. However, the same matters may not be beyond the power of another person. This exposition makes it clear that the nature of umur-e-ghaibiyyah [matters relating to the unseen] is relative and subjective. That is to say, when they are attributed to some particular person they can be considered as matters relating to the unseen, but when they are attributed to some other persons they do not possess this quality.

Examples:

(A.) Person Y is born fifty years after the death of Person X, while Person X was born in the present age. Person X is not the contemporary of Person Y, nor does Person X have any external means to know about the life of Person Y. For Person Y, the events of his life do not fall under the category of umur-e-ghaibiyyah because they are part of his own life as he felt and experienced them. However, if Person X were to foretell these events correctly, and in their minutest detail, Person X will be said to have revealed the unseen, for these events were not observed or felt by Person X, nor was it possible for him to know them by some external means.

(B.) Person Y is a philosopher who, after spending a long time in the deep study of philosophical books and cogitating on their contents, has acquired complete proficiency in the knowledge and comprehension of subtle, philosophical truths. Moreover, he has acquired many facts of rational knowledge and irrefutable arguments because he has studied the books written by his predecessors, has access to the treasures discovered through research carried out by earlier scholars, and is in the habit of meditation, mental exercise, and constant use of established rules of logic.

On the other hand, it is an established fact that Person X has not learnt even the rudiments of logic and philosophy, nor does he know that there are such things as books of philosophy, nor is he trained to exert his mind through meditation and reflection, nor does he keep the company or acquaintance of the learned or philosophers. Rather, he is completely unlettered and has always lived among the unlettered.

Thus, all the branches of knowledge that Person Y has learnt with diligence, effort and hard work are not ‘matters relating to the unseen’ for Person Y, because he has spent a long time assiduously learning them. However, if Person X, who is completely unlettered, explicitly expounds the abstruse and subtle points of wisdom and philosophy in such a way that his exposition is neither inaccurate nor lacking in any respect whatsoever, and, moreover, if he expounds philosophical truths so comprehensively that no previous philosopher has ever been able to do so, then each of his expositions which fulfils the above conditions would fall under the category of umur-e-ghaibiyyah because he expounded that which was beyond his ability, his scope of knowledge, as well as his spectrum of grasp and understanding. Furthermore, he did not have at his disposal any means to explain such things.

10 of 10 left today