Chapter One
Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part III, Part 5
For every person, literate or illiterate, there is a clear and straightforward way for testing this aspect of the Holy Qur’an. If anyone should doubt as to how the Holy Qur’an can be comprehensive of all religious verities, I undertake the responsibility myself that if anyone—as a seeker after truth, that is, after making a written promise that if he is satisfied he would accept Islam—should set forth a certain number of religious verities from any book in Hebrew, Greek, Latin, English, Sanskrit, etc., or should set forth a subtle point relating to any subjects of divinity out of his own intellect, I shall produce for him the same from the Holy Qur’an—provided he sends it to me while this book is being compiled, so that it can be incorporated and published at an appropriate place as a footnote in this book. However, when such questions are sent, the following condition should be kept in mind:
anyone who desires to start the debate, should first publish a clear statement in a newspaper stating with utmost sincerity that his sole purpose is to find the truth, and in case he is fully satisfied with the answer, he is ready to embrace Islam. Otherwise, it is a waste of time to pay attention to anyone who does not sincerely seek the truth, and whose heart is devoid of fear of God, and who, because of his inner wickedness, indulges in idle talk like mischief-makers.
Another proof of the matchlessness of the Holy Qur’an that can be readily understood by every seeker after truth is that, in addition to its brevity and despite its comprehensiveness of all truth and wisdom, which has been mentioned above, its style is profoundly eloquent, balanced, delicate, soft, and awe-inspiring. Even if a zealous critic and staunch opponent of Islam, who is also well-versed in Arabic writing and composition, were categorically commanded by a ruler having full authority, to produce the like of the Holy Qur’an in, say, twenty years—which amounts to a lifetime of effort—under the penalty of death, he will fail to do so. Nay, even if he is told to take just a few lines from the Holy Qur’an and try to match or excel them in such a way that his text should not only comprise all the truths and verities contained in the relevant portion of the Holy Qur’an, but should also be equally eloquent, even then, in spite of his undying enmity, fear of being disgraced as well as of death, he can never have the power to produce anything like it, even if he were to summon to his aid hundreds of linguists and writers from around the world.
The above-mentioned example is not an imaginary illustration or a baseless supposition. Rather, this is an established fact that was put to the test at the time [of the revelation] of the Holy Qur’an itself, and its truth has been proved to every seeker after truth up to this day. And even now if any seeker after truth wishes to witness this miracle in the Holy Qur’an first-hand, I take it upon myself to very easily prove it to his satisfaction. To verify this statement and to distinguish between truth and falsehood is not at all difficult. It is not something that requires any expense, or loss of any other kind. The seeker after truth needs only to choose any topic of his choice from anywhere in the Holy Qur’an and give it to any of the scholars of Arabic, who are found in this country in the hundreds of thousands, with the request that he should write on that topic in his own words, covering all subtleties and fine points. When such a composition is ready, it should be sent to me. I shall then make it very clear, in a plain and lucid discourse, which everyone who can read Urdu will be able to understand easily, how his piece of writing is totally deprived and devoid of the excellent qualities of the Holy Qur’an.
Here, it should also be remembered that just as the characteristics of other things are learned through repeated tests and experiments, the distinctive quality of the Holy Qur’an’s matchlessness in respect of its lucidity and eloquence can also be known only through test and experiment. God has prescribed only one course to discover the distinctive qualities of things; that if we are in doubt about a particular distinctive quality of a thing we should go on repeating the experiments until we are fully satisfied. Anybody who persists in doubting a quality, which is found to exist in an object through experiments, by saying that he cannot find any rationale for it, is surely mad or insane. For instance, if a person knows from repeated tests and experiments that arsenic is a fatal poison, but continues to deny it by saying that he does not know why it has this fatal quality, such a person will be regarded by the wise as insane; rather, worse than the insane.
It is a self evident truth that different elements have different properties. When the specific property of something has been verified by repeated experiments, can denying it be called anything other than madness or insanity. The greatest folly, however, is to deny the attributes and acts of God Almighty. For, in the case of all other things, the peculiar qualities that distinguish them from others can be proven only through experiment, it is not necessary to provide a rational ground for it. But as I have already stated in the case of divine attributes, the fact that His existence, His attributes, and His acts are not shared by anyone else and are replete with His mighty power is not only proven by experience but also by rational arguments that demonstrate that God must be One without any partner in respect of His person, all His attributes, and acts; and also demonstrate that the proof of His divinity is contingent upon the proof of such unique qualities.
The ignorant people who have not accepted the inimitability of the Divine Word, should, therefore, be ashamed of themselves and reflect. Their refusal is based only on their concocted notion that since the discourse of God is made up of the same words and letters as the discourse of man, why should man be considered incapable of creating the like of the Word of God. I pity those who have failed to grasp this solid and evident truth that has been proved by irrefutable arguments. Had they possessed even a little God-given intelligence, they would ask themselves first—prior to advancing such foolish criticism—as to whether or not it is necessary for God to be One without having any partners in His person, His attributes, and all His actions.
And if they had not reflected over this argument, at least they should have thought over the second argument, that when a being, by their very admission, is Supreme and Peerless in knowledge and creative powers, then everything that proceeds from such powers should also be peerless. For, as I have already mentioned, the magnificence and grandeur of a discourse depends on the intellectual prowess of the author; the greater his intellectual prowess, the higher in degree would be the greatness and grandeur of his composition.
And if they have shut their eyes to this argument as well, I wish that they had borne in mind the fact that all things have distinct qualities. Are they not aware that there are hundreds of things that belong to the same species; rather, they are counted under one category and yet the All-Wise God has granted different qualities to each and every one of them. [Continued in Part IV.]