Footnote Number Eleven
Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part III, Part 10
Herein lies the wisdom as to why such light of revelation—for which extraordinary and perfect inner light is a requirement—was bestowed only upon Prophets and was confined to them alone. The clear argument Allah the Almighty gives in the above analogy falsifies the statement of those who, in spite of admitting to the differences in human faculties, insist out of mere foolishness and ignorance that the light of revelation, which is bestowed upon those with perfect natures, can also be granted to imperfect individuals. They should reflect with honesty and fairness on how they are making a serious error about the grace of [divine] revelation. They clearly see that the divine law of nature does not support their wrong idea, yet out of extreme prejudice and stubbornness they persist in holding this false notion.
Similarly, the Christians do not believe that an inner light is required for receiving [divine] light and they allege that it is not necessary that a heart upon which the light of revelation descends should possess inner light. Rather, according to the Christians one can be a Prophet of God and attain nearness to Him in spite of all his vices, even if he is: utterly ignorant and foolish instead of being wise; a coward of the first order instead of being brave; an absolute miser instead of being generous; extremely shameless instead of having a sense of honour; consumed by the love of this world instead of having the love of Allah; a notorious thief or robber instead of having the moral qualities of temperance, fear of God, and trustworthiness; extremely immodest and lustful instead of having the virtues of chastity and modesty; and deplorably greedy and covetous instead of having the quality of contentment. Indeed, according to them, with the sole exception of Jesus, all other Prophets whom they accept as true and whose revealed books they call holy, were, God forbid, bereft of holy perfection—a condition of innocence and purity of heart—just like those described above. The Christians ought to be immensely congratulated on their intellect and cognition of God for coming up with such a ‘sublime’ philosophy of the descent of revelation!
But only those who are benighted and immersed in utter darkness can practise and admire such a philosophy. Otherwise, even a feeble-minded person would not deny the obvious truth, that to receive the grace of light it is necessary that the recipient should possess inner light. There can be no remedy, however, for those who have nothing to do with reason, hate light, and love darkness. Like bats, their eyesight is sharp in darkness but they become blind in broad daylight. God guides towards His light (namely the Holy Qur’an) whomever He wishes and sets forth examples for the people, and He is well aware of all things. (This means that guidance comes from Allah and is bestowed only upon those whom the Eternal Bestower has given the potential, and not upon others. God explains subtle points with the aid of analogies so that they are easier to comprehend. However, He knows full well, in His eternal knowledge, who will understand these analogies and embrace the truth, and who will remain deprived and frustrated.)
Hence, the analogy which has been translated above in bold letters tells us that the heart of the Holy Prophet, peace be on him, is like a clear glass, that is free from every kind of impurity. This is nur-e-qalb [the light of the heart]. Then, the Holy Prophet’s understanding, comprehension, perfect wisdom, and all the excellent morals inherent in his nature, are likened to a purified, luminescent oil which is the means of illumining the lamp. This oil is nur-e-‘aql [the light of intellect], for the faculty of reason is the source and fountainhead of all inner qualities. Then God has mentioned that heavenly light, which is revelation, descended upon all these diverse types of light [of the Holy Prophet (saw)]. This is nur-e-wahi [the light of revelation]. These three lights, when they converge, become the source of guidance for mankind. This alone is the true principle behind revelation which embodies the Eternal Law of the Eternal Holy God, and this indeed befits His Holy Being.
This inquiry shows that unless a person possesses nur-e-qalb and nur-e-‘aql to a perfect degree, he can never be the recipient of nur-ewahi. And as I have already demonstrated, the perfection of intellect and the perfection of the light of the heart are not found by everyone, but only certain individuals. Now, by combining these two arguments, we can establish beyond a shadow of a doubt that the gift of wahi [revelation] and risalat [prophethood] is given only to some perfect individuals and not to every human being. This conclusive argument should suffice to utterly demolish the false notion of the Brahmu Samajists, and this is what was intended.
Fifth Objection: Some Brahmu Samajists object that if perfect cognition depends upon the Holy Qur’an, then why did God not cause it to spread in all countries and in all civilizations, ancient and modern, and why did He deprive millions of His creatures of His perfect cognition and of the true faith.
Answer: This objection is the result of short-sightedness, for it has been made abundantly clear that perfect certainty and perfect cognition are not possible through reason alone. Rather, this magnificent level of certainty and perfect knowledge comes only from the kind of revelation that is perfect and peerless in its nature and effect, and whose peerless nature serves as a clear proof of its origin from Allah. I have also proven in this book that the only peerless book of this kind in the world is the Holy Qur’an—and none else.
This being the case, the straight path for the seeker after truth is that he should either refute my arguments and show that reason alone can lead man to perfect certainty, and true and certain cognition in matters of the Hereafter; or, failing to do so, should admit the truthfulness of the Holy Qur’an, which leads to the stage of perfect cognition. If he is unwilling to accept this, then let him cite another book like it, which contains all its exclusive excellences, so that it is proved that even though a revealed book is desperately needed for reaching the stages of perfect certainty and cognition, yet such a book is not found in the world.
However, if a disputant is unable to counter any of these arguments and is reduced to silence, he should judge for himself how far removed from honesty and integrity it is to present baseless conjectures in response to a truth that has been well-established with such irrefutable proofs that he cannot counter or disprove its arguments. It is a universal truth that until a fact, which has been proven with irrefutable proofs, is countered with solid arguments, it stands as a proven fact and cannot be falsified merely by ill-founded premises. Can a house whose foundation, walls, and roof are very solid be demolished with the mere breath of one’s mouth?
It is foolish to ask why God did not cause His Book to spread to all countries, thereby not allowing people of every disposition to benefit from it. If the light of the sun does not reach certain dark places, or if some people shut their eyes like an owl on beholding the sun, would this mean that the sun has not been created by Allah? If the rain does not fall on some arid land, or a saline area does not benefit from it, then would it follow that the rain of mercy is the work of man? To remove such doubts, God Almighty has made it manifestly clear in the Holy Qur’an that the guidance of divine revelation is not meant for every temperament, but is meant for those pure temperaments that possess the qualities of taqwa [righteousness] and salahiyyat [virtue]. It is only such people who take advantage of the perfect guidance of revelation and are benefited by it. Divine revelation reaches them in any case. In this context, we draw attention to the following verses of the Holy Qur’an:
From the verses quoted above, one should first ponder over the following verse:
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
. Observe how nicely, beautifully, and succinctly God Almighty has furnished the answer to the above objection. First, God mentions the efficient cause of the Holy Qur’an, and highlights His grandeur and majesty. He says: ّٓمٓلا , I am Allah, who knows best. That is to say, I—who am All-Knowing and All-Wise, whose knowledge is not to be matched by the knowledge of anyone else—am the One who has revealed this Book.
Then it refers to the material cause of the Holy Qur’an and announces its greatness in these words:
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
, this is that Book. That is to say, this is a grand and sublime Book, whose material cause is divine knowledge, and about which it has been established that it has its source and origin in the Eternal and All-Wise God.