Footnote Number Eleven

Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part III, Part 17

Mere indications contained in the law of nature cannot settle textual disputes, nor can they fully convince the misguided one of his error. For instance, if a judge does not record the pleas of the plaintiff, nor counter the objections of the defendant with strong arguments, how then would it be possible that the parties should discover the answers to their questions, objections, and pleas, merely through the hints [contained in his judgement]. And how can a final judgement be propounded on the basis of confused hints which do not completely satisfy either side. In the same way, the commandments of God are established to the satisfaction of His servants only when He informs them, through His perfect and truthful speech, of the diverse types of false notions into which they have fallen due to the erroneous statements of people, and makes them aware of their misguidance with a reasoned and clear statement, so that, if they do not mend their ways even after being informed and do not give up their error, they should deserve to be punished. Would it be just on the part of God Almighty that He should seize a person as an offender and be ready to punish him, without first disproving his pleas of innocence through a clear statement and removing his doubts through His unambiguous Word.

He also pointed towards the same in another verse:

This means that the Holy Qur’an has three qualities. First, it guides people to the knowledge of the faith that they had forgotten. Second, it sets forth the details of such knowledge as had been stated somewhat briefly in the past. Third, it gives the decisive verdict concerning matters over which differences and controversies had arisen, and thus distinguishes between truth and falsehood.

Again, concerning this comprehensiveness, He says:

Meaning that, all knowledge of faith has been explained in complete detail in this Book and it identifies the means and teaches the perfect knowledge which should lead man not only to partial progress but to full development. Again, it is said:

Footnote Number Eleven — Seventh Objection 129

Meaning that, We have revealed this Book to you so that every religious verity might be explained clearly and this perfect discourse of Ours might prove to be the means of guidance and mercy for those who submit wholly to Allah. Then He says:

Meaning that, We have revealed this magnificent Book to you, so that you may bring mankind out of every kind of darkness into light. This is an indication that the Holy Qur’an removes every kind of doubt and misgiving that passes through a man’s heart. It eradicates all kinds of corrupt thoughts and bestows the light of perfect divine enlightenment. That is to say, it bestows all the insights and verities that are needed for turning towards God and believing in Him. Again, it is said:

This means that the Holy Qur’an is not a book which could be composed by man. The signs of its truth are patent, for it establishes the truth of previous Books, meaning that with its coming it has proved true all prophecies relating to it that were recorded in the Books of past prophets. And the Holy Qur’an also provides arguments in support of true doctrines—arguments that were lacking in those Scriptures. It thus perfected their teachings and testified to their truth in such a manner as to establish its own truth as well. The second sign of its truth is that it sets forth every religious verity and states all those matters which are necessary for perfect guidance. This is a sign of its truth inasmuch as it is beyond the power of man that his knowledge should be so comprehensive that no religious verity or the most subtle of religious truths should be left out of it.

To summarize, in all these verses God Almighty has clearly stated that the Holy Qur’an is comprehensive of all verities, and it is this very magnificent argument which supports its truth. Centuries have passed after this claim of the Holy Qur’an, but no Brahmu or anyone else has come forward to contest it. Therefore, it is obvious that, without presenting any new verity that might have been left out of the Holy Qur’an, to put forward baseless, false notions like the insane is strong proof that such people do not desire to seek the truth like the righteous. However, to please their nafs-e-ammarah [the self that incites to evil], they are seeking ways whereby they should somehow be freed from God’s holy commandments, or rather, from God altogether. For procuring such freedom they turn away from the true Book of God, the truth of which is as evident as the shining sun, and they neither discuss any matter in the spirit of decency, nor listen to anything said by the other side.

They should be asked if anyone has ever presented a religious verity in challenge to the Holy Qur’an and found no convincing answer from the Holy Qur’an. When, for the last thirteen hundred years, the Holy Qur’an has vociferously claimed that all religious verities are comprised in it, then how vile is it that, without a test, such a grand Book should be held to be defective, and what kind of arrogance is it neither to admit the claim of the Holy Qur’an nor to come forward to refute it. The truth is that though the name of God does occasionally come upon their lips, their hearts are full of the filth of materialism. Even when they start a religious debate, they do not wish for its [logical] conclusion and try to stifle it as soon as possible lest the truth should emerge. And such is their brazenness that they sit in the comfort of their homes and try to deprecate this perfect Book which announced in unequivocal terms:

That is, today, having revealed this book, I have perfected religious knowledge to its heights and have completed all My bounties upon the believers.

Gentlemen! Have you no fear of God? Will you go on living like this? Will curses not be cast upon your liar’s face one day? If indeed you possess some great truth which you think you have acquired by sweating blood, working tirelessly, and doing research into the minutest details, and which you believe the Holy Qur’an has failed to mention, I beseech you to leave everything else and bring that verity before me, and I will show you that it is already present in the Holy Qur’an. But, of course, in such a case you must be ready to embrace Islam. If you still persist in your scepticism, and do not stop your nonsense, and refuse to engage in direct debate, then what can I say other than:

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

[‘May the curse of Allah be upon the liars’].

Eighth Objection: It is disrespectful to suggest that God speaks to man. What relationship can subsist between the mortal and the Eternal and Ever-Existing. What resemblance can there be between a handful of dust and the Eternal Light itself.

Answer: This objection is also baseless and absurd. To shatter it, it is enough to understand that the Benevolent and the Gracious has inspired the hearts of perfect human beings with untold zeal for His cognition, and has drawn them so powerfully to His love, affection and devotion that they have been lost to their own selves. To propose in such a case that God would not desire to converse with them would be tantamount to saying that all their yearning and love is vain and all their zeal is one-sided. However, one must stop to think that this notion is utter nonsense.

Can a seeker of the One who bestowed upon man the capacity to win nearness to Him, and made him restless with His own love and yearning, be deprived of the grace of converse with Him? How can it be that, though it is right and legitimate and in accord with God’s majesty that His creatures should yearn for Him, love Him, and lose their whole being for His sake; yet it should be impossible, illegitimate, and contrary to His majesty that He should bestow His revelation upon the hearts of His true lovers.

Man’s plunging into the limitless ocean of God’s love, and stopping nowhere in that pursuit, is conclusive evidence that man’s wonderful soul has been fashioned for the complete cognition of God. Thus, if it is fashioned for the cognition of God, but is not bestowed the perfect means of cognition, which is revelation, it would have to be said that God did not fashion it for His own cognition.

·

10 of 10 left today