Footnote Number Eleven

Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part III, Part 18

Even the Brahmu Samajists do not deny that the soul of a right-natured man is hungry and thirsty for the cognition of God. Hence, they should now realize it themselves in view of the fact that a man of pure nature naturally seeks to attain cognition of God, and it is established that the perfect means of attaining it is divine revelation and nothing else. In this scenario, if such means are impossible to attain and, rather, to seek them is disrespectful, then God’s wisdom would be open to the criticism that He bestowed upon man zeal for His own cognition, but did not bestow upon him the means of acquiring it. In other words, He afflicted man with hunger, but would not bestow upon him enough bread to satisfy his hunger; or that He afflicted man with thirst, but would not bestow upon him enough water to quench his thirst.

Wise people can readily understand that this concept amounts to belittling God’s immense grace. Considering that the All-Wise God has tied the ultimate bliss of man to beholding the rays of the divine light perfectly in this world, so that, due to its irresistible attraction, he is pulled towards God, how can one imagine that such a Benevolent and Merciful Being does not wish to lead man towards his cherished good fortune and natural goal. Strange indeed is the logic of the Brahmu Samajists!

Ninth Objection: The belief that God sends down His word from heaven is utterly wrong, for the law of nature does not confirm it, nor do we ever hear a voice coming down from above. Revelation is the name given to the thoughts which arise in the hearts of wise people by the use of reflection and observation, and that is all.

Answer: A truth which is self-evident and has been observed by countless men of understanding with their own eyes, and the proof of which can be found in every age by a seeker after truth, suffers no harm by the denial of a person who is bereft of spiritual insight, nor, the thinking or defective knowledge of a person whose heart is wrapped up in coverings fails to confirm it. Moreover, the truth cannot be considered as being outside the law of nature because of the idle talk of such people.

Consider, for instance, the case of a person who has never seen a magnet and is unaware of a magnet’s power of attraction. If he were to claim that: a magnet is only a piece of stone; that he has never witnessed any such power of attraction in any stone; and therefore, in his opinion, it is wrong to assert that a magnet has such a power—for it is contrary to the law of nature—then would his vain assertions cast any doubt on the well-established quality of a magnet. Certainly not. All that his assertion would prove is that he is absolutely stupid and ignorant and considers his own lack of knowledge to be a proof of the non-existence of a reality and does not accept the testimony of thousands of people who have experienced it.

How can we possibly lay down as a general condition for the laws of nature that they must be personally tested by every individual. God has created the human species with great diversity in their external and internal faculties. For instance, some people possess very good eyesight, while others have weak eyesight and some are altogether blind. When those who are weak-sighted find that those with good sight have perceived a thing from afar—for instance, they have sighted the crescent—they do not deny it; rather, they think that their denial would only humiliate them and expose their weakness. The blind, of course, are totally incapable of saying anything in such a matter. In the same way, those who possess no sense of smell believe it when hundreds of trustworthy and truthful people speak of good smell or foul odour. They do not doubt them at all for they know well that so many people do not tell lies and must be speaking the truth and that without a doubt it is their own impaired sense of smell that prevents them from experiencing these scents first-hand.

Likewise, human beings also differ with respect to their inner faculties. Some are weak and covered in the veils of their egos, while there have always been others who, due to their lofty and pure nature, have been receiving revelation from God. For those who are weak and covered in veils to deny the personal characteristic of those who possess a lofty nature would be the same as if a blind person, or one with weak sight, were to deny the observations of one with excellent sight, or as if a person congenitally lacking the sense of smell were to deny the experiences of one who possesses a sense of smell.

The ways to disprove such a denier are the same in the spiritual realm as they are in the physical realm. For instance, if a person who is congenitally bereft of the sense of smell denies the existence of good and foul smell, and asserts that those who claim to have such a sense are liars or are mistaken, then he can be persuaded to admit his mistake in the following manner. He should be asked to select a few pieces of clothing and rub some with perfume and leave others untouched and then test the sense of smell of a normal person, so that by repeated experiments he would be convinced of the reality and existence of the sense of smell and that, indeed, there are people who can distinguish between that which is fragrant and that which has no smell.

In the same way, a seeker after truth can be convinced of the existence of revelation through repeated observations. When hidden matters and secret mysteries, which cannot be discovered through reason alone, are disclosed to a recipient of revelation, and when a revealed book is found to contain wonders, which are not to be discovered in any other book, a seeker after truth is convinced that divine revelation is an established truth. If such a person possesses a pure nature, he himself, by treading on the right path can, to the extent of the illumination of his heart, experience divine revelation like the auliya’ullah [friends of Allah]. Thus, he learns of wahy-e-risalat [Divine Scriptures] at the level of haqqul-yaqin [true certainty]. In this regard, I myself take the responsibility of satisfying any seeker after truth who shows his readiness to accept Islam with heartfelt truthfulness, sincerity of faith and an unblemished spirit of obedience. وإن كان أحد في شك من قولي، فليرجع إلينا ر وهو في كل أمر نصيریعلى ما نقول قد ہللابصدق القدم، و [And if anyone doubts my word let him come to me in all sincerity; for Allah has the power to grant what I say and He is the Helper in every matter].

To think that revelation is nothing other than the insightful ideas that occur to the human mind as a result of deep thought and deliberation is also the product of inner blindness and ignorance. If human thoughts were the same as divine revelation, then surely man would be able to discover unseen phenomena through his own reflections and observations. It is obvious that no matter how wise a person may be, he cannot disclose anything hidden by merely reflecting on the matter. Nor can he exhibit any sign of divine power. Nor can his speech exhibit any of the special characteristics of the Divine. Even if he thinks himself to death, he still cannot discover the unseen, which is beyond his reason, observation, and other senses. Nor can his discourse be so lofty that no human power is able to match it.

Thus, there are enough reasons for a wise person to conclude that whatever a man might think—good or bad—as a consequence of his own reflection or observation, cannot be the word of God. Had it been the word of God, every door to the unseen would be open to man and he would be able to foretell all that only God can tell with His divine power, inasmuch as it is necessary that the work of God and the word of God should manifest the glorious signs of the Divine.

However, if someone has doubt in his mind about the source of beneficial or harmful schemes, deep insights about good and evil, clever thoughts and ideas that flash into the human mind as a result of reflection, and how by thinking about a problem a solution suddenly comes to mind, the answer is that such thoughts are khalqullah [the creation of Allah] and not amrullah [the command of Allah]. There is a subtle difference between khalq [creation] and amr [command]. Khalq denotes that God Almighty produces something through [physical] means and attributes it to Himself because He is the Cause of causes, whereas amr is that which proceeds directly from God Almighty without any intervening cause and cannot be attributed to any cause. Thus, divine revelation descending from the Omnipotent God proceeds from the world of amr and not from the world of khalq. All other thoughts that arise in people’s minds in consequence of observation and reflection proceed entirely from the world of khalq, in which divine power operates behind the veil of means and [human] faculties.

·

10 of 10 left today