Footnote Number Eleven
Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part III, Part 26
The second part of the lives of Prophets and auliya’ is the one in which they enjoy the highest level in victory, prestige, and wealth; so that they may be able to demonstrate those essential high moral qualities that can be demonstrated only by one who enjoys victory, prestige, wealth, authority, sovereignty, and might. Possession of wealth and power is an essential condition to prove that someone possesses such high morals as forgiving his tormentors, pardoning those who have offended him, loving his enemies, desiring the good of those who desire nothing but evil for him, not loving wealth, not allowing himself to become arrogant on account of his riches, not to be niggardly and tight-fisted, to be generous and bountiful, not to use his wealth for satisfying baser passions, and not to exercise authority and governance as a tool of tyranny and aggression. These qualities are demonstrated only when a person possesses both wealth and authority. Without passing through a time of trial and misfortune, and also a time of prosperity and authority, these two types of high qualities cannot be manifested. That is why the perfect wisdom of the Almighty God demanded that Prophets and auliya’ should be provided with both these types of conditions, which comprise thousands of bounties.
The occurrence of these two conditions, however, does not follow the same order for all of them. Divine wisdom ordains in the case of some that the period of peace and comfort comes in the first part of their lives followed by a period of hardship; while the life of others begins in tribulation and God’s succour comes to their rescue in the end. In some, the two phases are subtle and not easily defined; while in others they are clearly marked and evident. In this respect the foremost is Hadrat Khatamur-Rusul [the Seal of the Messengers], peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, for both these conditions were experienced by him in their perfection and in such order that all the high moral qualities of the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, were illuminated like the sun and thus the meaning of
What is more, the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, having been proved to be perfect in both types of moral qualities, also serves as proof of the moral qualities of all Prophets, because he has testified to their prophethood, authenticated their scriptures and has shown the world that they were indeed Allah’s chosen people. This analysis also completely repels the objection that might possibly arise about the moral qualities of Masih [i.e., Jesus the Messiah]—namely, that the moral qualities of Hadrat Masih, peace be on him, cannot be established to a perfect degree with respect to both of the above-mentioned types; rather, that they cannot be established even with regard to one type. Because the Masih showed patience under distress, the perfection of this quality would have been demonstrated only if the Masih had obtained authority and power over his persecutors and had forgiven his oppressors from the bottom of his heart, as did Hadrat Khatamul-Anbiya’, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, who obtained complete victory over the Makkans and others and after virtually having his sword upon their throats, forgave them their crimes, and he punished only those few who had been condemned by a special decree of Allah the Almighty to undergo punishment. Besides these eternally accursed few, every sworn enemy was pardoned. And having achieved victory, he announced to them: َ َوْمي
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
[‘No blame shall lie on you this day’].
On account of this forgiveness of offences—which had appeared impossible in the estimation of his opponents who, considering their own misdeeds, deemed themselves condemned to death in the hands of their avengers—thousands of people accepted Islam instantly. Thus, the sincere steadfastness of the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, which he had demonstrated for a long period under their severe persecution became illumined in their eyes like the sun.
As it is part of man’s nature that the grandeur and greatness of patience is illustrated perfectly only for the person who, after the time of persecution has been dispelled, forgives his persecutors after obtaining power to punish them; that is why the moral qualities of the Masih in the matter of patience and meekness and endurance were not fully demonstrated, and it did not become clear whether his patience and meekness was by his choice or was under compulsion. Because, the Masih did not acquire power and authority so that it could be judged whether he would have forgiven his enemies or taken revenge upon them.
In contrast, the good qualities of the Holy Prophet, peace and blessing of Allah be upon him, were demonstrated and put to test on hundreds of occasions and their truth shone forth like the sun. The good qualities of kindness, large-heartedness, munificence, selflessness, manliness, bravery, chastity, contentment and withdrawal from the world were demonstrated so clearly and brilliantly in the case of the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, that, let alone the Masih, there never was a Prophet before him who demonstrated them to such perfection. Because God Almighty opened for the Holy Prophet the doors to countless [worldly] treasures, he spent them all in the way of God and did not spend a penny on any kind of self-indulgence. He created no buildings and built no mansions; rather, he spent the whole of his life in a small mud hut that had nothing to distinguish it from the huts of the poor. He repaid evil with kindness and helped his tormentors in their distress out of his own wealth. He usually slept on the floor, lived in a small hut, and had barley bread to eat—and at times nothing at all. He was granted abundant wealth of the world, but he did not soil his holy hands with it and always preferred poverty to wealth and meekness to power. From the day of his advent to the day when he returned to his Companion on High, he attached no importance to anything except to his Benevolent God. Solely for the sake of God, he gave proof of his bravery, fidelity, and steadfastness on the battlefield against thousands of enemies when death appeared a certainty. Similarly did the Benevolent God cause all other moral excellences, associated with large-heartedness, generosity, contentment, courage, bravery, and love of God, to be manifested in the person of Hadrat Khatamul-Anbiya’ in such a manner as has never been displayed before nor ever will.
In the case of Hadrat Masih, peace be on him, these moral qualities were not clearly established for they can only be proved in a period of authority and riches and the Masih did not find the period of authority and riches. Thus in his case, both types of moral qualities remained hidden; hence the conditions were not present. However, this above-mentioned objection which can be raised against the deficiency in the case of the Messiah has been repelled by the perfect example of the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, inasmuch as his beneficent example perfects and completes the case of every Prophet, and through him whatever had remained hidden or doubtful in the case of the Masih and other Prophets shone forth brightly. Revelation and prophethood came to an end in that holy person in the sense that all excellences reached their climax in him. شاءی ؤتيه منی ہللا وهذا فضل [And this is Allah’s grace; He bestows it upon whomsoever He pleases].
Tenth Objection: Some short-sighted people raise the objection that revelation suffers from a defect and shortcoming—that it prevents and obstructs its recipient from arriving at perfect enlightenment, which is indispensable for eternal life and everlasting happiness. They explain their objection by asserting that revelation obstructs intellectual development and blocks the progress of research, for those who follow revelation find it sufficient to respond to every question by asserting that the matter at hand is either permissible or forbidden in their revealed book; and they do not use their reasoning powers, as if they had not been bestowed to them by God. The end result [according to the critics] is that: ‘By lack of use, all those powers gradually become weak and, indeed, they almost disappear; thus, human nature is completely changed and begins to resemble animals, the progress of rational faculties, which is the excellence of the human soul, is wasted, and man is thereby deprived of obtaining perfect enlightenment. Thus, the revealed books constitute an obstruction in the way of achieving eternal life and everlasting happiness, of which man stands in need.’
Answer: It should be clear that the objection—that following a true Scripture revealed by God necessitates the abandonment of rational faculties, or that revelation and reason are incompatible and opposite phenomena that cannot co-exist—only arises from the sheer ill-understanding, prejudice, and obduracy of the Brahmus. It is a strange objection with an equally strange composition, consisting partly of falsehood, partly of bigotry, and partly of ignorance. The falsehood is that, despite their knowledge that divine verities have been fostered only through people who have followed revelation, and that Oneness
Urdu edition of Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya, the Promised Messiah (as) presented this sub-footnote along with Footnote Number Eleven. For the ease of English readers, Hadrat Khalifatul-Masih V (aba) decided that it should be presented as its own section after Footnote Number Eleven. [Publisher]
of God has been propagated in the world only through the elect who believe in the word of God, they deliberately make a statement contrary to this known fact. Their bigotry is shown by the fact that in order to support their assertion they have held back the self-evident verity that in theological matters, unaided reason cannot carry a person to the stage of perfect certainty. And the ignorance is that they have regarded revelation and reason as inconsistent with each other, which cannot subsist together, and that they have regarded revelation to be opposed to reason and destructive of it, whereas this fear is entirely unfounded. It is obvious that a follower of true revelation cannot refrain from rational inquiries; rather, he finds that revelation helps him to see the nature of things in a rational manner. By the light and blessing of revelation, he avoids the pitfalls that might come his way in the pursuit of logical investigation, and does not have to waste time like misguided rationalists in inventing baseless arguments and indulging in useless formalities; instead, he sees the clear path of reason and his eyes settle on the real truth.
In short, reason rationally substantiates the phenomenon of revelation; and it is the task of revelation to safeguard reason from wandering aimlessly. Hence, it is obvious that there is no conflict between reason and revelation; and that they are not contrary to or opposed to, each other. Nor is the true revelation, i.e. the Holy Qur’an, a stumbling block in the path of progress of reason. Rather, it illumines reason and is its great helper, supporter and guide. As the full value of the sun is appreciated by the eye and the benefits of the bright day are disclosed only to those who possess sight, in the same way, divine revelation is fully appreciated only by those who possess reason, as God Almighty has Himself said: