Footnote Number Eleven
Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part III, Part 27
Meaning that, We present these examples for the people, but only those people can understand them rationally who are knowledgeable and wise.
Likewise, just as the benefits of the seeing eye are realized only in the presence of the sun, without which there would be no difference between seeing and not seeing, in the same way, the excellences of rational insight emerge only with the help of revelation, which saves rationality from thousands of types of confusion and points to the shorter path and shows the way which, if adopted, leads to the objective very quickly. Every wise person knows it well that, when thinking through a problem, if one gets a hint as to the right direction to pursue, then this knowledge yields great help to the intellect, safeguarding it from many confused thoughts and unnecessary headaches.
The adherents of revelation not only choose the excellent tool of reason by themselves, but revelation itself stresses the need for sharpening their intellect. Thus, they are drawn by two attractions towards advancement in rationality: first, the natural curiosity that every man displays for understanding the nature and working of things in a precise and logical manner; second, the revealed injunctions which intensify their burning desire. So those who read the Holy Qur’an even in a cursory manner will not deny the obvious fact that this blessed Word of God places great stress on the exercise of thought and reason, so much so that it describes it as a characteristic of believers, that they constantly reflect upon the wonders of the heavens and the earth and deliberate on the wisdom of the law of God, as is said in one place in the Holy Qur’an:
That is, in the creation of the heavens and the earth and in the alternation of the night and the day, there are a number of Signs for the wise to prove the existence of the Creator of the Universe and His might. The wise are only those who remember God sitting, standing, and lying on their sides and keep meditating and pondering over the creation of the earth and the heavens and other creations, and their hearts and tongues keep supplicating: ‘O our God, You have not created any of these things in vain and without purpose; rather, everything in Your creation is full of the wonders of Your power and wisdom, and points towards Your Blessed Being.’
It is true that there is an emphasis on adhering to irrational and impossible beliefs in other Scriptures, which have been interpolated and perverted, as for instance, in the Holy Gospels of the Christians. But this is not the fault of revelation; in fact, this too is the fault of defective reason. Had those who were in thrall to falsehood possessed sane reason and had they been in their senses, why would they have followed these interpolated and perverted books; and why would they have permitted such thinking about the Unchangeable, Perfect and Eternal God—that He transformed Himself into a helpless embryo, was nourished on impure sustenance, took on an impure body, was born through an impure passage and came into the mortal world, and after enduring all sorts of torments died in a state of extreme misfortune, adversity and failure, calling out ‘Eli, Eli’.
Ultimately, it was revelation which corrected this error as well. Subhanallah [Holy is Allah]. How exalted and what an ocean of mercy is the Word which brought the creature-worshippers back to Tauhid [the Oneness of God]. How charming and attractive is that light which brought a whole world out of darkness. Outside of it, thousands who were considered wise and called philosophers remained engrossed in this error and countless similar errors and, until the Holy Qur’an came, no philosopher had forcefully refuted this false doctrine, nor reformed these ruined people. As a matter of fact, the philosophers themselves were afflicted with hundreds of unholy doctrines. As the priest Davenport has recorded, the Christians in fact adopted the doctrine of the Trinity from Plato, and built a false structure on the false foundation laid by this foolish Greek.
In short, true and perfect revelation of God is not the enemy of reason; rather, defective reason is the enemy of the pseudo-intellectuals. It is obvious, for instance, that an antidote is not in itself harmful for the human body, but if a short-sighted person mistakes poison for an antidote, it is the fault of his understanding and not of the antidote. So it should be borne in mind that it is absurd to think that recourse to a revealed book for investigating everything is dangerous. As I have stated, revelation is a mirror reflecting the truth for the benefit of reason. The greatest testimony to its truth is that it is wholly free from matters, the impossibility of which is established after pondering over God’s Omnipotence, Perfection, and Holiness. In fact, it is the only leader and guide for the frail human intellect in the minute and subtle matters of religious knowledge. Thus, it is obvious that to have recourse to it does not render reason useless; rather, it helps reason to fathom the hidden secrets that were very difficult for reason to reach on its own. Therefore, reason derives great advantage and benefit from the True Revelation, namely, the Holy Qur’an, and suffers no harm or loss therefrom. And through revelation, reason is safeguarded against dangers and does not fall into them.
Every wise person knows it for a fact—rather, regards it an obvious truth—that there is a possibility of fault or error in research that is based on reason alone, whereas there is no possibility of fault or error in the Word of the Knower of the unseen. Now be the judge and ask yourself: Is it good or bad for that which is sometimes confronted with the possibility of stumbling badly, that it should be furnished with a companion which should safeguard it against slipping and support it where it loses its foothold. Would such a companion help to lead it to its utmost purpose, or would it be a hindrance to attain the utmost purpose. What kind of inner blindness it is to regard a helper as an opponent and obstructor, and to consider that which completes and perfects as harmful. When you reflect on this matter with full attention and for the sole purpose of finding the truth, it will suddenly dawn upon you that God has not harmed reason in any way by appointing revelation as its companion. On the contrary, finding reason perplexed and bewildered, He furnished it with a sure instrument for recognizing the truth, by the pointing out of which, reason is aided in safeguarding itself from straying into hundreds of erratic ways and is not led astray, nor wanders aimlessly everywhere. Rather, it finds the proper way to its true purpose, and finds the exact place of its desired objective and is saved from useless toil. It is like the case of a truthful informant who gives accurate news of a lost person’s whereabouts; that he has gone in a certain direction and is hiding in such and such town, in such and such ward and in such and such location.
It is evident that no sane person objects to the help of such an informant who supplies the needed information about the lost one and points out the simple and easy way of reaching him. Sane people do not accuse him of creating hurdles in their investigation; on the contrary, they are deeply grateful and appreciative to him that he informed them while they were ignorant, and pointed out to them a particular spot while they were wandering here and there, and he opened the door of certainty while they were involved in conjectures. In the same way, those on whom God has bestowed sane reason are grateful to—and praise and eulogize—true revelation and realize fully that true revelation does not obstruct the progress of their thinking. Rather, it safeguards their thinking from confusion and, out of a variety of labyrinth and doubtful ways, shows the desired right path treading along which becomes very easy for reason. It also delivers man from all those deficiencies that confront him on account of his short life, insufficient intellectual capacity, and limited insight.
I have stated time and again that human reason is so imperfect and incomplete in its nature that it cannot cope with any task without the help of a companion. It is incapable of settling, clearly and rightly, any disputes, whether spiritual or secular, on its own unless it is aided by empirical testimony. And whenever reason gets empirical testimony from a reliable source, its task becomes much easier, as if a huge burden had been lifted from its shoulders. When human intellect, by its very nature, is dependant on a companion, how can it make progress in its thought process alone and by itself.
I have repeatedly stated that all the faults suffered by reason in the realm of theology and knowledge of the Hereafter are rectified by the Holy Qur’an. Not only that, but the Holy Qur’an also furnishes all rational arguments and guides and leads towards all religious verities.
I have also just pointed out that if anyone wishes to verify and study this claim, I take it upon myself to satisfy him; and every seeker after truth can satisfy himself on this account by putting me to the test. So, despite the fact that the arguments have been completed by refuting all their objections, why do the Brahmu Samajists not desist from uttering their absurdities. Have they been drugged into a slumber or intoxication, or have all their senses been suspended or destroyed at once so that they do not hear what they have been told, nor understand what has been so clearly explained, nor see what they have been shown.
It should be remembered that their claim that the process of rational investigation continues indefinitely, and at no stage stops, is also completely absurd and nonsensical. It is obvious that had such been the case, no endeavour, whether worldly or religious, would ever reach a conclusion and no judge would be able to decide any case categorically, and a court verdict would be deemed impossible and unwarranted on account of unending doubt. But is it right to believe that the facts concerning all things are never and in no way clearly and accurately manifested, and that there is always room for debate and discussion. God forbid, surely this opinion is not correct.