Footnote Number Eleven
Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part III, Part 28
A fact only remains dubious and is not considered clearly proven only so long as its proof is based on reason alone; but as soon as reason finds one of its essential companions—one of which is wahy-e-risalat [Divine Scriptures] that gives news of the super-sensible phenomena and the Hereafter—rational research is able to reach the level of absolute certainty.
Thus, reason achieves certainty by pairing up with a companion, as appropriate under the circumstances: sometimes with a perfect revelation, sometimes with repeated evidence based upon observation, and sometimes with well-established and reliable historical testimony. But if reason fails to find a companion which is suitable for the path it intends to travel, it then never reaches the state of perfect certainty. Rather, at best, it reaches the level of probability. But when it finds the companion to reach its goal, the companion definitely takes it to the level of complete certainty in a manner whereby it does not leave any room for doubt.
Such well-established matters are wont to be doubted only by those people who are insane, phobic or given to sophistry—who by nature are so overwhelmed by their phobia that believing something even to be most probably true is impossible for them, and who always remain immersed in doubts and suspicions. No matter how bright the light may shine, their inner blindness, which is an essential character of their being, as it is of a bat, shows no sign of decline; so much so that they continue to doubt even the existence of God. Thus, the ailment of such blind ones is, in fact, irremediable; otherwise, anyone who possesses even a glimmer of insight can understand that once research and analysis have reached the point at which true facts are fully revealed and clear arguments and decisive testimonies converge from all sides, and are shining like the sun, all investigation and inquiry stops there and then. The seeker after truth, then, has to take a firm stand at that point, for there is no choice for man but to believe it. Obviously, when perfect proof has been obtained and all aspects of the point in question have become apparent like the breaking of dawn and the facts of the matter are manifested brightly, why should then any wise and sane person harbour any doubts about it and why should any sound-minded person not find contentment in it.
Of course, as long as there is a possibility of error, or the truth has not yet been clearly manifested, thought and reflection can be given free rein, and revision after revision can be made. But for someone to indulge in baseless suspicions about proven facts, like a phobic, cannot be termed as the progress of thought, rather, it is only the excess of black bile [i.e., melancholia].
Once the lawfulness or prohibition of a matter has become as evident as the shining sun for someone, he would only be senseless and insane if, despite such perfect disclosures, he continues to harbour the suspicion that perhaps what he knows to be prohibited might be lawful and what he considers lawful might, in fact, be prohibited. However, such questions could arise, and such doubts could trouble the minds, if one were to rely solely on rational ideas; and human reason—like that of the Brahmu Samajists—was deprived and bereft of the assistance and support of its other companion.
But the reasoning of the followers of true revelation is not so destitute and helpless; rather, its helper and companion is the perfect Word of God that leads the process of inquiry to its true goal, and confers the level of certainty and enlightenment that cannot be surpassed. This is because, on the one hand, it clearly explains rational arguments, and on the other, it serves—on the basis of its being incomparable and unequalled—as a decisive argument that produces certainty regarding God and His teachings. The extent to which a seeker after truth achieves true certainty of knowledge by these twofold proofs can only be appreciated by someone who searches for God with a sincere heart; and only those desire it who seek God from the depth of their souls. But how can the Brahmu Samajists, who hold the doctrine that there is no book or person that is not prone to error, hope to attain such a level of certainty until they seek the path of certainty by repenting of this satanic notion.
Considering that, of their own admission, the Brahmu Samajists have neither found nor authored a book which is a collection of teachings that are free from error, it is all too obvious that their faith is still floundering in a whirlpool of doubts. Their doctrine clearly indicates that they do not possess certainty regarding any matter relating to divine cognizance. According to them it is impossible for any book dealing with religious knowledge to be a collection of true teachings. In fact they have openly declared that there is no book that is free from error, or worth believing, even if it totally affirms the existence of God, portrays Him as One without partner, the Omnipotent, the Creator, the Knower of the unseen, the Wise, the Gracious, the Merciful and possessing all other perfect attributes, and even if it were to consider Him to be free from and far above deficiencies, such as coming into existence, mortality, change, mutability, having associates, etc. This is the reason why they also reject the Holy Qur’an.
It may be noted that the summary of their faith and belief, in the light of their own assertions, is that according to them, even the concept of God’s existence, His Oneness and His Omnipotence are not free from the possibility of error!! In short, when they themselves admit that they do not possess a book that is truly authentic in their view, it becomes evident that their religion is based altogether on suppositions and that their faith is far removed from and bereft of the stages of certainty. This amounts to what I have repeatedly written in this very footnote, that mere intellectual discourses cannot bring about complete satisfaction and contentment regarding the knowledge about God.
Hence, we are in agreement with Brahmu Samajists that no man can reach perfect certainty under the guidance of reason alone. The only point on which we had disagreement was whether, as the Brahmus believe, God has created man with the objective that, in spite of his urge to zealously seek perfect certainty and truth, with which his nature has been invested, he should remain deprived of what he naturally desires to have and that his knowledge should remain restricted to such ideas alone as are not free from the possibility of error; or whether God has appointed means for him to attain perfect knowledge and complete success and whether He has also provided a book to which the above-mentioned principle of the possibility of error is not applicable.
So, والمنۃ هلل الحمد [all praise and munificence belongs to Allah], the fact that God has revealed such a book has become evident to us through categorical arguments, and through this commendable Book we have escaped the whirlpool of destruction in which the Brahmus lie like corpses. And that Book is the very same Magnificent and Holy Book that is called ‘Furqan’—which manifestly differentiates between truth and falsehood and is free from all types of errors.
Its very first quality is
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
; it alone has revealed to us that God does not desire to destroy the seekers after truth by depriving them of the degrees of certainty. On the contrary, the Merciful and Benevolent God has bestowed His favour upon His weak and imperfect servants by doing what defective human reason could never do. He has Himself dropped down fruit from the high branches which human hands could not reach and has provided the means for attaining true and perfect certainty to the seekers after truth who are hungry and thirsty for the truth.
Thousands of subtleties of religious truths were lying scattered like particles in the vast stretches of the spiritual heaven, and the water of life, dispersed like dew, was hidden and veiled in the innermost recesses of human nature, and in its deepest secret potential; to bring them all together from the limitless expanses was beyond the rational powers of man. He did not possess any discerning tool that could help him view the tiniest and most hidden points of truth, which were not clearly visible to the physical eye, nor did he have a long enough life span to collect them all. It is this perfect Book that has brought to us all these subtleties of wisdom and fine points of cognition of God, impeccably and flawlessly, through the Omnipotence and power of Divinity and the strength and sovereignty of His Providence, so that by drinking this water we are saved and do not fall into the pit of [spiritual] death. And the wonder of all wonders is that it has combined all these verities so comprehensively that none of the subtle verities and none of the fine points of wisdom have been left out, nor has it let anything enter it which is opposed or contrary to any truth.