Footnote Number Eleven
Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part III, Part 6
Now every fair-minded person should judge with impartiality as to whether or not this belief paves the way to the denial of the existence of God. Is there any guarantee of a person’s belief in God if in his opinion God is so weak that had there not been logicians, there would be no trace of His existence? These ignorant people do not realize that God sustains mankind with all—not just a few—of His attributes; how then is it possible that some of these perfect attributes should be of no use to mankind. Can there be a greater blasphemy than to believe that He is not the complete Rabbul-‘Alamin [Lord of all the worlds], but only a half or a third.
Fourth Objection: If perfect certainty depends upon a revealed book, it would have been better for all mankind to receive revelation, so that they could all directly attain perfect divine cognition and thereby partake of divine grace directly without being dependant on anyone else. If revelation is indeed an established fact, then everyone should be able to receive it; but if not, then no one should.
Answer: Divine revelation is conditional upon the recipient’s potential and eligibility. It is not possible for all people to become Messengers of Almighty God or for divine revelation to descend upon everyone. Allah the Almighty refers to this in the Holy Qur’an as follows:
This means that when a Sign is shown to the disbelievers to demonstrate the divine origin of the Holy Qur’an, they say, ‘We will never believe until the Book of Allah is revealed to us directly’. God knows best where and when to confer prophethood; that is, He knows who is and who is not able [to receive revelation]. In other words, He bestows the grace of revelation only upon him who possesses the requisite ability and capacity.
To elaborate, the Eternally Wise has created all individuals different from one another for various reasons, so that the whole chain of the children of Adam resembles a line rising to the loftiest heights on the one end, and descending to the lowest depths on the other. At the higher end are the pure souls whose capacities are perfect in regard to their own distinct ranks, while at the lower end are those who are more akin to animals, devoid of all reason. In the middle are people with average faculties of intelligence etc. Observation of the diversity of capacities in different people is a sufficient argument to prove this point. No sensible person can deny that human beings are divided into different levels with respect to intelligence, righteousness, fear of God, and love of God. Just as the operations of the laws of nature produce the beautiful and the ugly, the seeing and the blind, the sharp-sighted and the weak-sighted, the perfect and the imperfect, similarly, the difference, to varying degrees, in the ranks of intellectual and spiritual powers is also patent and visible.
It is true that every individual—provided he is not absolutely insane or deprived of sense—can make progress in his reason, his righteousness, and his love of the Divine; but it should be borne in mind that no one can grow beyond the limit of his capacity.
Let us take, for example, the case of someone who is congenitally deficient in mental capacity [and suffers from microcephaly—the abnormally small circumference of the head], who in our part of the country is nicknamed by the common people as doulay shah ka chuha; it is obvious that no matter how much effort is put into training and educating such a person, and no matter how great a philosopher is employed as his tutor, he will not be able to progress any further than the limit God has defined for him. On account of his limited sphere of ability, he cannot attain the heights of a man with greater ability. This is such a self-evident fact that I cannot imagine that any sane person who reflects on it would deny it, but I would not be surprised if someone totally bereft of reason did so.
Clearly, if there were no such differences in intellect, why would different people differ in their acquisition and grasp of knowledge, and why would some outshine others. Those belonging to the teaching profession must be well aware of the fact that some students are so intelligent that the slightest hint or gesture is sufficient to make them understand, and some are so ingenious that they even come up with wonderful ideas of their own. Conversely, some are inherently so dull and slow-witted that no matter how much you exert your mental energies on them, they will not understand. Even if they come to learn something, after you have worked yourself very hard to teach them, their memory is so weak that, in a moment, everything is erased from it like a mark of water [on something] which disappears in no time.
Similarly, there is an immense difference in people’s moral capabilities and spiritual enlightenment. Take, for instance, two sons belonging to the same father, who have been taught by the same teacher. One of them may turn out to be righteous and good-natured, and the other wicked and mischievous; one brave, and the other cowardly; and one with a deep sense of honour, and the other shameless. Sometimes, it so happens that the mischievous one is reformed to a certain extent as a result of being admonished; and sometimes the coward, due to some selfish motives, performs a feat of courage—leading inexperienced people to believe that they have deviated from their true nature. But I repeatedly draw attention to the fact that no soul can exceed the limits of its capacity. If one makes any progress, it is only within the sphere of his inherent natural capacities.
Many naive people have fallen prey to the misconception that appropriate practice and training can help develop one’s abilities beyond one’s innate potential. Even more far-fetched and illogical is the doctrine of the Christians, who believe that merely accepting the Messiah to be God brings about a transformation in one’s nature, and that however greatly one may be overwhelmed by the animal instincts and evil desires that are ingrained in one’s nature, or however defective one’s mental faculties may be, by simply professing that Hadrat ‘Isa [ Jesus] is the only son of God Almighty, one changes his innate nature. However, it should be borne in mind that such thoughts are harboured only by those who have never closely studied natural sciences or medicine, or whose eyes are blinded by extreme prejudice and creature-worship. Otherwise, physicians researching the causes of different dispositions have found, through repeated experiments, that cowardice or bravery, stinginess or magnanimity, intelligence or dullness, weakness or resoluteness, kindness or fury, purity or impurity of thought, are not casual or accidental traits. Rather, the Eternal Creator has Himself made mankind distinct from one another in terms of their chemical ingredients, the proportion thereof, and the structure of their chests, hearts, and skulls.
It is because of these peculiarities that we see such stark differences in people’s mental and moral faculties. This long-held theory has been endorsed by physicians as well. They maintain that when they minutely analyzed the skulls of thieves and robbers, their structure was found to be of a kind peculiar to such wicked people. Some Greeks have gone even further and claim that they can ascertain the inner state of a person’s mind just by looking at his neck, eyes, forehead, nose, and various other organs. In any event, there is no running away from the proven fact that there is a marked difference in the moral and intellectual faculties of human beings, and though everyone may try to improve himself, he can do so only within the sphere of his capacity.
At this point someone may harbour the doubt that:
‘God Himself has declared belief in Tauhid [Oneness of God]
to be ingrained in the nature of all human beings, as He says:
Meaning that the belief in Tauhid is inherent in human nature