Footnote Number Eleven

Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part III, Part 5

That is, the deniers of revelation have not made a just estimate of the holy status of Allah the Almighty, nor have they recognized His mercy, which is stirred at every need of man; this is why they have said that God has not revealed any book to any man.

Go and make a just estimate of Him and stop arguing and being stubborn,

For the views you express will cause you only trouble.

I positively and categorically say that to follow reason solely, without the aid of revelation, leads not to one but a host of difficulties, as I shall (God-willing) elaborate at the appropriate place.

The Benevolent God, having made everything in pairs, has also paired reason with revelation. The law ordained by the All-Wise is such that as long as something remains separate from its pair, its potential remains hidden and very often it even proves harmful rather than yielding benefit. The same is true of reason. It serves theology in a positive way only if it is linked with its pair—that is, revelation. Without its pair, it is like a monster ready to swallow an entire household and desires to completely devastate a city and lay it to waste. But when it joins its pair, lo and behold, it assumes the most beautiful form and aspect, bringing fortune to the household it enters and removing all woes from those it touches.

Think for yourself. Can anything serve any purpose without its pair? Then why do you go about parading your reason alone, which has so often been put to shame on account of its false conclusions. Has it not fallen headlong repeatedly and suffered massive bruises. Tell me, what has enchanted your heart. How could you have become infatuated with this fairy. Do you not know that it has sucked the blood of countless persons before you, pushed its victims into the bottomless pit of misguidance and killed them. It has devoured many a ‘lover’ like you and disposed of many a corpse. What religious truths have you discovered through reason alone that are not already written in the Holy Qur’an. I do not ask for many examples, just cite a few. Had you discovered such sublime truths solely with the aid of reason, which were not to be found in the Holy Qur’an, you would have had the right to boast in your circles that you were such people who had discovered truths that were absent in revealed books. Pitifully, however, your treatises are absolutely worthless, with the exception of a few matters that you have plagiarized from the Holy Qur’an. Instead of proving your wisdom, they only expose your ignorance, error, and lack of understanding, as I shall, God-willing, clearly elaborate in this book. Such being the measure of your merit and ability, you are truly unfortunate to deny divine revelation, to take upon yourself the role of God, and to think that the revered and holy Prophets had ulterior motives in making their claims. Do not be misled by the fact that reason is beneficial, as all our research is indeed based on reason. No doubt it is an excellent tool, but its true essence is revealed only when it is coupled with its pair. Otherwise, it is worse than enemies in deceiving you, and more treacherous than hypocrites. What a pity that even the mention of its pair irritates you.

Friends! You must realize that nothing works without its pair. It is wonderful how God has created everything in pairs. All around us, we see that everything functions in pairs; we see with our eyes, but we also need the sun; we hear with our ears, but we also require air. When the sun sets, we are virtually blind; when we shut our ears to the air, we become deaf. How can a woman conceive without having relations with her husband; how can a garden that is not touched by water bear fruit. None of this is beyond your understanding. It is the same law of nature that you claim to follow. So now live up to your claims lest they sound like mere rhetoric.

Second Objection: Even if we were to concede that perfect and unique revelation is essential for the perfect cognition of God, it does not necessarily mean that God Almighty has sent down such a revelation, as there are countless things that man also needs in the world but God has not fulfilled all of his needs. For instance, man does not wish for death to come and never to be poor or ill; yet, against his wishes, he dies one day and often suffers from poverty and illness.

Answer: Whereas the perfect and peerless revelation that we required is already with us in the form of the Holy Qur’an, and its perfection and uniqueness remains unchallenged to date, only those who have lost their vision will deny the existence of something that is already there, and consider the need for it to be hypothetical. The only option you have is to confute, if you can, the arguments for the perfection and uniqueness of the Holy Qur’an that I have set out in this book. However, if you cannot, and yet you go on advocating your views, it only shows that you are devoid of all attributes of decency. There already exists a perfect and matchless revelation which—by proclaiming its own inimitability—has settled that anyone is certainly free to deny revelation if he first refutes its claim of matchlessness. Thus, would anyone who fails to convincingly refute this claim, yet insists on dismissing the need for revelation to be hypothetical, be considered honest or stubborn.

Moreover, it is a grave mistake to apply the norms of the Hereafter to this world. God has created this world neither for everlasting comfort nor for everlasting misery. Rather, its afflictions and comfort are transient and every one of its cycles will come to an end. The Hereafter, on the other hand, is the abode of everlasting comfort or damnation. This is why every far-sighted person chooses hardship, and endeavours his utmost to obey God for fear of coming to a bad end. He leaves luxury and comfort and accepts adversity and hardship. Now tell me, is it not lack of insight to compare this temporary abode with the everlasting one.

Third Objection: Reason, by itself, may not lead to perfect cognition and complete certainty, but it does provide a degree of knowledge, and that is sufficient for salvation.

Answer: This is a completely biased assumption. I have already pointed out that coming to a good end, without being plagued by doubts and uncertainties, is not possible except with perfect certainty; and that perfect certainty cannot be attained without the aid of a matchless divine book. Likewise, it is not possible to avoid errors without perfect cognition—and one cannot have perfect cognition without perfect revelation. How is it possible then, that, imperfect as it is, unaided reason can lead to salvation on its own.

In particular, the method of divine cognition adopted by the strange reasoning of Brahmu Samajists under the influence of European philosophers is particularly flawed and ambiguous. Far from leading to any degree of certainty, it plunges man into all sorts of confusion and uncertainty, for it reduces God Almighty to some kind of a lifeless puppet devoid of all of His honour and glory. They assert that knowledge of God’s existence does not come from God Himself; rather, He came to be known accidentally through the deliberations of wise men. Their story is like this, that, in the beginning of human existence, people were totally devoid of intelligence like savages, and God gave them no knowledge of His existence. Then gradually it occurred to people that a deity should be appointed. Initially, they started worshipping mountains, trees, rivers, and other objects around them and called them ‘god’. As they progressed, they turned to the wind and the tempests and so on as their all-powerful gods; and later, advancing further, they considered the sun, the moon, and the stars as their gods. So in this way, after profound reflection, they gradually turned to the true God.

Just consider how their explanation casts doubt upon the true existence of the Almighty God and the scepticism it creates about His being the Living and Sustaining God who has the power to do what He wills. This would lead us to believe—God forbid—that He did not give us the news of His existence (as should be expected from a being who exists and is the Knower of the unseen and is All-Powerful). Rather, it was entirely an outcome of human endeavour. One day, out of the blue, man was tickled to appoint a god. He proceeded to deify water, trees, and stones; but eventually began to believe, without any rhyme or reason, that such objects cannot be God; for God must be some other being that we cannot see. Will not this belief create the doubt that if the ‘supposed’ God did really exist, He, like living persons, would surely have informed others of His existence some time or the other.

In particular, when someone with such thinking considers that it is not proper to think of God as imperfect, deficient or mute, and just as it is necessary for Him to have the perfect attributes of seeing, hearing, knowing, etc., so it is necessary for Him to have the ability to speak. He would wonder that if God has the power to speak, where is its proof. If He does not have this power, how can He be perfect. If He is not perfect, then how does He deserve to be God. And if it is right to think of Him as a mute, then why not believe Him to be blind and deaf as well. Man can free himself from these doubts only by believing in revelation. Otherwise, as thousands of philosophers perished by stumbling into the pit of atheism, so will he.

·

10 of 10 left today