Part II

Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Parts I & II, Part 8

Thirdly, let it also be clear to everyone that all the arguments contained in this book—whether they relate to the divine origin of the Holy Qur’an, or the truthfulness of the prophethood of Khatamul-Anbiya’ [the Seal of the Prophets], may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, or to the excellences and beauties of the Holy Qur’an, and the clear evidence that it is revealed by God, or to any other matter—have been taken from the same Book [the Holy Qur’an]. This means that both the claim and the arguments in its support have been derived from the Holy Book. I have not put forward any claim or argument based on my own speculation or reasoning. Hence, I have consistently quoted verses in the Holy Qur’an from which my claims and arguments are derived. Anyone who wants to write in support of his scripture in response to my arguments, or wishes to put forward any other claim, must follow the same approach. They too should produce both their claims and their arguments from their respective scriptures. And when I say arguments, I mean rational arguments that reasonable people employ in their discourses to prove their point, and not mere myths, fables or legends. Thus, in every context, they should produce only rational arguments contained in their revealed scriptures and eschew conjectures and suppositions that have no basis in their sacred texts. Every reasonable person understands that it is the duty of a Divine Book to clearly set out its claim of being the Word of God, as well as to provide clear proof in support of its claim and in support of the principles it lays down. It must not advance empty claims or principles that it cannot uphold and has to depend on others to plead its cause. ☆

☆ Another reason why a revealed scripture must provide rational arguments in support of its teachings is that the purpose of a scripture is not served if people merely read and repeat it parrot-like, thinking that they have thus merited salvation. rather, the highest objective of a revealed scripture is to provide rational arguments in support of its teachings so that people may attain absolute and unshakable certainty—the kind of certainty through which all their actions, words and beliefs are set right and they recognize right as right and wrong as wrong, thereby attaining true piety. People live in great peril as long as they languish in the hell of ignorance and blindly follow teachings inherited from their forefathers—teachings in which they have already

Therefore, it should be fully borne in mind that if anyone, in lost faith due to apathy and gross materialism. Such are the people described in this verse of the holy Qur’an:

i.e. whoever is blind in this world shall be blind in the next world also, indeed they shall be worse off. (Surah Bani Isra’il, Part 15) ‡

Any scripture that fails to establish its own divine origin or the divine origin of its principles cannot open for mankind the door to eternal bliss. Instead of leading them on the path of knowledge and wisdom, it stunts their spiritual growth and casts them into the bottomless pit of blind following wherein they dwell like corpses, neither hearing nor seeing nor understanding. The followers of such scriptures have little regard for reason, logic, contemplation or insight, and are perfectly content with myths and stories of the past, with no desire to find the truth. having abandoned the gifts of reflection and deliberation and having stifled their innate capabilities, they have become worse than non-rational beasts. Bidding farewell to the path of thought and reason—which is the essence of humanity—they descend to a level that can hardly be called human, for they no longer have the ability to distinguish between right and wrong. how aptly does the holy Qur’an describe such people in the verse:

i.e. those who blindly follow their forefathers have minds but they do not use them, they have eyes but do not see with them, and have ears but do not hear with them. They are like cattle, indeed they are worse off. (Surah al-A‘raf, Part 9) §

In short, the most important task of a revealed book would be to teach man the most appropriate use of the faculties inherent in his nature, so that none of the powers that God has wisely invested in him

‡ Surah Bani Isra’il, 17:73 [Publishers]

support of the truth of his scripture, presents an argument that is not contained in the scripture itself, this shall be taken as an admission that the scripture, which this person fancies as the Word of God, fails to meet this condition of the challenge. Fourthly, let the readers also bear in mind that this book has been written in a spirit of great civility, decency and courtesy, and does not contain any derogatory remarks about any holy personage or founder of a faith. I am personally appalled by the use of such words, either directly or by implication, and I believe that anyone who resorts to them is extremely evil and mischievous. I would, therefore, like to appeal to all good-natured people that, should they choose to reply to my challenge, they ought to exercise in the course of their writings such civilized manner as is worthy of any civilized and decent person. They should refrain completely from uncivil and derogatory language and disparaging remarks about holy personages, Prophets or Messengers. To write a religious discourse is a very sensitive matter in which no

are wasted or used excessively or insufficiently. one of these—the very crown of humanity—is the power of reason, the correct use of which makes a man truly human and opens for him the door to excellence and limitless progress.

It is obvious that if a revealed book does not uphold and protect man’s faculty of reason, but rather discourages its use, such a book, instead of cultivating human faculties, would become an impediment in their balanced use. Instead of helping and supporting human faculties, it would stultify and misdirect them. It would not deserve to be called knowledge or wisdom, for it would only be a collection of myths, irrational beliefs and naive expectations. Anyone who follows such scriptures is like a daydreamer who hopes to reap what he has not sown. obviously, a book that can only flourish by suppressing reason can bring no good to mankind.—Author one person has the final say. Readers, who distinguish good from bad, and recognize fair-minded from biased, and falsehood from truth, are watching them closely. There are civilized people in all religions who abhor such mischievous and uncivil speech and consider it extremely scurrilous and wicked to use derogatory language about the honoured founders of different faiths, whom God chose in His infinite wisdom and special divine will to be the leaders and guides of their nations. It was through their enlightened souls that the world was blessed with the light of divine worship and Divine Unity. Their forceful teachings uprooted idolatry and creature-worship—the mother of all evils—from most parts of the world. It was they who brought new life to the dried up tree of the remembrance of the One God and erected the fallen edifice of the worship of God upon solid foundations. They were the elects of God whom He took under His own benign protection, and supported them so magnificently that even though millions stood up against them, they remained undaunted and resolute in their mission. God saved them from every calamity and from the schemes of every mischief-maker until they had established the truth upon the earth. To revile such elect of God is an act of great impiety, inaptness and insolence.

He who spits upon the sun,

Ends up spitting on his own face;

Such a one will be cursed till the end of days;

The holy ones will remain far and beyond his stink.

It is not without reason and special significance that I remind people to be courteous and cautious in the use of their words. I can call to mind many who consider it a great virtue to disparage Prophets and Messengers. The kind of language they use against them only serves to expose the baseness of their own nature. I have studied the matter in depth and have discovered two reasons for such behaviour. It is either because they are incapable of sane and rational discourse, or because they are simply confounded by the arguments and objections of a man of truth and find refuge in turning intellectual debate into one of mockery and ridicule. Having failed in other ways, they seek to establish their reputation among their ilk in this manner. And having set themselves up as the leaders and teachers of their people, they try to hold on to this role by exhibiting greater prejudice and obduracy than their followers. To be honest, they are not wholly to be blame for this, as they are sunk deep in ignorance and prejudice. They neither fear God nor care about faith, truth and rectitude, and it is only the rotten world for which they lust. Abuse and slander is all that can be expected from them, insomuch as they are indifferent to God and are without shame or modesty, and are bent upon denying the truth under any circumstances. They can hardly speak or write anything else. Apart from those who are bereft of civility and the spirit of enquiry,☆ thousands among the

☆ The average christian is also not immune from this criticism. In addition to the personal grudge these people harbour against Hadrat Khatamul-Anbiya’ [the Seal of the Prophets], may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, they also do not revere any of the Prophets, apart from Hadrat Masih [Jesus], may peace be on him, the way they ought to be revered. From the very moment a person is baptized and Footnote № 6

Christians are emerging who, on account of their pure nature and takes Hadrat ‘Isa [Jesus] to be the special son of God, his tongue is loosened against all Prophets. Matters have been made even worse by certain Gospel statements in which all Prophets prior to Hadrat Masih [Jesus], may peace be on him, are described as ‘thieves and robbers.’ Such conceited remarks could never be attributed to a righteous person, let alone Jesus, who was so meek, humble and selfless that he did not allow anyone to call him good. how then could such haughty and disparaging words be attributed to him? No doubt, if we call God’s noble Prophets thieves and robbers, we ourselves would be a thousand times worse. If the hearts upon which holy revelation descended were not holy, how could they be deemed fit to receive the holy revelation? Maligning God’s chosen ones is nothing but a cruel attempt at deception. It is pitiful, indeed, that the very people who are in thrall to their egos, and are engrossed in what is wholly mundane, should utter derogatory remarks about the elect of God. Brothers! You must believe the Prophets to be holy, virtuous and perfect so that the Books that descended upon them may also be regarded as holy, for how could the holy Books be revealed to impure hearts? can the datura [stramonium] plant bear grapes, or can the akk [swallow-wort] produce figs? If you find the water of a spring pure and clean, then its source must also be considered pure and clean. Moreover, if those Prophets were not God’s most loyal and righteous servants, this would expose God to the objection that he is unable to tell a true gem from a false one. In that case, it would have to be admitted, God forbid, that like the evil-disposed people, God is in league with thieves and robbers. Just think whether these holy people, who act as bridges between God and man and spread heavenly light in the world, ought to be perfect or imperfect, truthful or liars?

If the Prophets themselves failed in their final objective—which was to establish people on true doctrines and appropriate conduct—who would have listened to them and how could their words have had any effect? To them even the illiterate would retort, ‘Physician, heal thyself.’ Besides, what kind of justice, decency, or piety is it to speak with such disrespect and indignity of God’s Messengers as if they were some sort of low menial workers and, at the same time, not settling for anything less than a stream of praise when speaking of worldly people. Is it fair to stand up in honour of fair-mindedness, have acknowledged the superiority of Islam. In

·

10 of 10 left today