Part II
Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Parts I & II, Part 9
wealthy materialists while refusing to speak even a word of praise for those who are honoured with divine discourse and possess qualities that are pleasing to God? If you really think that they are so unworthy, then why do you even accept them as Prophets? Why do you not reject their prophethood altogether? The fact is that all these calumnies against the Prophets are rooted in your ignorance of the true value of divine revelation. You imagine it to be a worldly office like that of a judge, collector of revenue, or a horseman, which in a dysfunctional government can be acquired through bribery, with no questions asked as to one’s character or merit; or like a post that the authorities want filled by someone who can do the work even if he meets just the minimum standard of good character and has only limited abilities. This happens because such jobs are so lowly and insignificant that absolute honesty, good character, or good disposition are not a requirement for such jobs. But brothers! You are gravely mistaken. divine revelation, which is God’s own holy word, is only granted on condition of utmost purity and perfect ability of the recipient. A person given to cravings of the flesh and selfish desires is far away from the holy Source and hence is not considered worthy of receiving divine revelation. Unless he has been completely purified of all that is unworthy, he cannot acquire the capacity to be graced with revelation. If perfect purity was not the precondition and if the worthy and unworthy were all equal, then every person would become a Prophet. But since purity is the essential requirement, it has to be conceded that the Prophets are the purest of mankind, such that no higher station of purity can be conceived for a human being. If Hadrat dawud [david] was not as free from sin as Hadrat Masih [Jesus], he would certainly not deserve to be a Prophet. The belief that Jesus is superior to david is at the root of the fallacy that has crept into the hearts of the christians. It stems from their sheer ignorance of the reality of revelation and Prophethood. God willing, this shall be explained at its proper place and with the required evidence.
Let us not forget that the christians I speak of in this footnote not only ridicule other Prophets, but also consider Hadrat Masih [Jesus] to be the best of all Prophets—in addition to believing him to be God, that is. This is another one of their false beliefs. In actual fact, the their writings, they have emphatically rejected the doctrine of the Trinity and have conceded that many innovations have crept into Christianity. Unfortunately, such fair-mindedness is disappearing among our fellow citizen Aryas. They are so steeped in prejudice that even to remember a Prophet with respect is regarded by them as a sin. They malign all Prophets and accuse them of falsehood and imposture, claiming without any evidence that the Vedas, which descended on their forefathers, are the only Word of God and that all other Revealed Books—which have benefited the world immensely by teaching the Unity of God and imparting knowledge of the Divine—were fabricated by men. Though I have refuted this claim in this book by exposing the falsity and inadequacy of the existing Vedas, I would like to point out here how the beliefs of these people are at odds with the norms of decency, civility and piety, and how prejudice,
greatest among the Prophets has to be the one who proves himself to be the greatest reformer of mankind. he has to be the one who has corrected the greatest corruption and mischief of all times; who has re-established the long-lost concept of God’s oneness; who has vanquished all false creeds with reason and argument and has removed the doubts and suspicions of those who had gone astray and disbelieved; who has shown the true path of salvation which did not require that an innocent man be crucified or that God be forced from his eternal and ever-lasting station into a woman’s belly; and who has revived and re-established the true principles of faith. Since such a one would be of the greatest benefit to mankind, his status would naturally be the highest. history tells us, heavenly scripture testifies to it, and every discerning eye can see that, in the light of this criterion, the one who stands superior to all Prophets is none other than Hadrat Muhammad Mustafa [the Chosen One], may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him. In this book, this too shall soon be made evident like the sun.—Author which seems to run in their very blood, has impaired their capacity for trust and good-will, in which lies the nobility and dignity of humankind, and which adorns humanity with elegance and beauty. ☆ Consequently, they have been led to believe that, with the exception of those who appeared in the land of the Aryas, the Prophets and Messengers—who delivered a large section of mankind from the darkness of idolatry and made the light of faith and Unity of God shine in most countries of the world—were, God forbid, liars and imposters. They hold that Brahmans alone have inherited true Prophethood and Messengership, which was the
☆ To trust and have faith in others, unless there is a genuine reason for suspicion, is a part of human nature. Anyone who is unduly suspicious and distrustful is considered a madman, paranoid, insane or an imbecile. For instance, if a person refuses to eat bread or sweets purchased from the market fearing that they may be poisoned, or, during a journey, unduly suspects anyone who guides him to the path, or is terrified lest the barber should cut his throat with a razor, all these would be considered signs of approaching madness and insanity. Such perverse thoughts are a precursor of insanity. As one gets more and more obsessed by such thoughts, they lead to insanity. Undue suspicion is thus a kind of madness that every reasonable person should do his best to avoid. God has invested man with the faculty of trust in the same way as he has ingrained truth and righteousness in his nature, so that one does not want to tell a lie or do evil unless prompted to do so. had man not been blessed with a trusting nature, he would have been deprived of all the benefits of truthfulness and righteousness upon which rest the entire fabric of society and culture, and on which all domestic and national affairs are poised. It is because of this trust, for example, that babies learn to speak and accept their parents as their own. had they been distrustful, they would imagine that the parents had some ulterior motive in trying to teach them to talk. They would thus learn nothing and remain dumb and even doubtful of their parentage.—Author exclusive preserve of their ancestors; that God has granted them absolute monopoly over it; that God has squeezed the vast river of His guidance into their small country; and that He loves only their nation, their language, and their Prophets, who, as a matter of fact, number no more than three or four. ☆ This [limited view] contradicts the fact that sending Prophets and revelation is an eternal practice of God, necessitated by the law of nature. If we were
☆ It is impossible to tell who were the actual recipients of the books that the hindus today revere as the Vedas and which they call Rig, Yajur, Sham, and Atharvan—also known as Rich, Yajash, Saman and Atharvana. It is not clear to whom these were revealed. Some believe that they were revealed to Agni [god of fire], Wayu [lord of the winds] or to the Sun, which is plainly absurd. others claim that the four Vedas issued forth from the four faces of Brahma. And still others are of the opinion that they are the words of different rishis. These claims are so conflicting that it is hard to tell whether these persons ever existed or are merely fictitious characters. In the light of the Vedas themselves, however, the third opinion seems to be true, because, even now, different mantras bear the names of different rishis. As for the Atharvan Veda, most learned pundits agree that it is either a fake Veda or a Brahmin Pustak [a book written by a Brahmin] that was added to the Vedas much later. This view seems to be correct, for the Rigveda—which is the source of all the Vedas and considered most authentic among them—speaks only of the Rig, Yajur and Sham Vedas and makes no mention of Atharvan Veda. It could not have been left out if it was indeed a Veda. Likewise, the 26th Adhyay of Yajurveda only speaks of three Vedas, as does the Samaveda. Manu Ji, in the 7th Adhyay of the 42nd shlok of his Pustak, also acknowledges only three Vedas. The Yog Washishth, which is revered as a holy book in hinduism and is a collection of the teachings imparted to raja ram chandra by his revered teacher, has given the final verdict regarding the four Vedas.
It says that the authenticity of all the Vedas, and not just that of the Atharvan Veda, is in question, and that none of them has escaped change and interpolation.—Author to believe in only a small number of the recipients of revelation, the reality of Prophethood and revelation would, in such a case, remain a weak, unreliable and doubtful matter. Moreover, in that case, millions of people who were unaware of this country, or this country remained unaware of their countries, would deem to be deprived of divine grace, mercy, guidance and salvation. Worse still, according to the proudly-held belief of Aryas, these three or four were not raised as Prophets by the special will and wisdom of God; on the contrary, they merited this office by their own good deeds, done in some unknown past existence, and God had no choice but to make them Prophets; while the rest of the people were forever denied this exalted station. Some were deprived of receiving revelation because of their own sins and shortcomings, and some for the crime of belonging to a nation or country other than that of the Aryas.
Just consider how this unholy doctrine vilifies the elect of God who rose like the sun and dispelled the darkness that had spread in the world during their times. Even their Parmeshwar [God] has not been spared. He is effectively considered a heedless, neglectful and confused being who is unaware of the thousands of innovations and millions of tribulations and commotions into which the world was thrown, and the wide variety of mischief which arose after the time of the Vedas, creating great upheaval in his kingdom that needed to be reformed urgently, but he could not be woken from his slumber and slipped away never to return. It means that the amount of revelations that Parmeshwar possessed was limited and he exhausted it in the Vedas. Having given away the sum total of his possessions, he was left empty-handed and tongue-tied forever. While his other attributes remained intact, the power of speech was lost after the revelation of the Vedas and Parmeshwar became permanently incapable of communicating with or sending revelations to his creatures. ☆ Such are the beliefs
☆ At this stage, someone might think that as the Muslims believe that revelation started with Hadrat Adam and ended with the holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, it proves that the revelation ceased for all times to come after the advent of Hadrat Khatamul-Anbiya’ [the Seal of the Prophets]. Be it clear that we do not believe, like the hindus, that God had only so many words to reveal and has now run out of revelations. According to Islam, God’s words, his knowledge and his wisdom are boundless, just as his own Being is boundless. Allah the Almighty says himself [in the holy Qur’an]:
That is: if the oceans were to be made into ink for writing the words of God, surely, the ocean would be exhausted, but the words of my Lord would not suffer any decrease even though other similar oceans were brought as further help. (Surah al-Kahf, Part no. 16) ‡
The question remains: in what sense do we consider divine revelation to have ceased after the holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him. God’s words are limitless—that goes without saying—but the evils that beset the world, or the needs that divine revelation fulfils, are not limitless. Therefore, God only sends down his words to the extent that they are required for the reformation of man and fulfilment of his needs. Now, when we look at the age in which the holy Qur’an was revealed, we find that mankind stood in need of every kind of guidance because all human affairs, whether related to ethics and morals, or doctrine and practice, had deteriorated, and every kind of excess and corruption had become rampant. Therefore, the teachings of the Holy Qur’an were revealed at the highest point of perfection. consequently and in this sense, the teachings of the holy Qur’an are established to be final and perfect. All past scriptures are
Footnote Number 9
‡ Surah al-Kahf, 18:110 [Publishers]
of the Aryas towards which they invite all Hindus. But, strangely found wanting because, in their time, spiritual deterioration had not reached such an extent as to require perfect revelation, whereas at the time of the holy Qur’an they had all reached their extreme. This is why the holy Qur’an stands apart from all other scriptures, which, even if they had not been tampered with, were imperfect at the outset, and always left room for the perfect teaching. however, there is no room for any further teaching after the holy Qur’an, as there is no stage beyond perfection.
But if it is supposed, for the sake of argument, that there might come a time when the teachings of the Holy Qur’an are replaced by those of idolatry, as happened in the case of the Vedas and the Gospels, and the concept of God’s oneness is changed and interpolated, and the millions who strictly abide by the principle of divine Unity turn into polytheists and idolaters, in such an eventuality a new law and new Prophet would surely be required. Both these assumptions, however, lie outside the realm of possibility. It is impossible for alteration or interpolation to find its way into the holy Qur’an, as Allah the Almighty has himself promised to safeguard it: