Cover Page
Christianity - A Journey from Facts to Fiction, Part 13
and retain our right to describe it as a state of deep coma and not death. If correctly understood and applied, the phrase ‘resurrection of as Jesus ’ cannot mean the return of his soul to the same human body which it had deserted at the moment of death. The term ‘resurrection’ only means the creation of a new astral body. Such a body is spiritual in nature and works as a sort of crucible for a rarefied soul within. It is created for the eternal continuation of life after death. Some call it a sidereal body or astral body and some call it Atma [Atman]. Whatever name you give it the essential meaning remains the same; resurrection applies to the creation of a new body for the soul which is ethereal in nature and not, we repeat, not, the return of the soul to the same disin- tegrated human body which it left previously. St Paul has spoken at length in exactly these terms about the as resurrection of Jesus Christ . He believed in the resurrection of as not only Jesus but the resurrection in general of all those who die and are deemed fit by God to be given a new existence and a new form of life. The personality of the soul remains the same but its abode is changed. According to St Paul, this is a general phe- nomenon which has to be accepted, otherwise there would be no meaning left in Christianity or religion. St Paul’s letters to the Corinthians must be studied in depth because they are central to the issue. They leave no room for as doubt, in my mind at least, that whenever he spoke of Jesus having been seen alive after the Crucifixion he spoke clearly and without ambiguity of his resurrection and resurrection alone, and as it never crossed his mind that the soul of Jesus had returned to === PDF-Seite 119 === Revival or Resurrection? 91
his mortal body and that he was resuscitated from death in ordi- nary physical terms. If my understanding of St Paul is not accept- able to some Christian theologians, they will have to admit that St Paul glaringly contradicted himself because at least in some of his as accounts of Jesus’ new life he leaves no shadow of doubt that he as understood Jesus’ new life to be the resurrection and not revival of the human body in which his soul is said to have been caged. Following are some of the relevant passages which speak for themselves:
And God raised the Lord and will also raise us up by his power. (1 Corinthians 6:14)
So is it with the resurrection of the dead. What is sown is perishable, what is raised is imperishable. It is sown in dishonor, it is raised in glory. It is sown in weakness, it is raised in power. It is sown a physical body, it is raised a spiritual body. If there is a physical body, there is also a spiritual body. (Ibid 15:42–44)
Lo! I tell you a mystery. We shall not all sleep, but we shall all be changed, in a moment, in the twinkling of an eye, at the last trumpet. For the trumpet will sound, and the dead will be raised imperishable, and we shall be changed. (Ibid 15:51–52)
We are of good courage, and we would rather be away from the body and at home with the Lord. (2 Corinthians 5:8)
The problem which remains to be resolved arises out of St as Paul’s reference to the early Christian account of how Jesus was === PDF-Seite 120 === 92 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction
seen alive in his body soon after the Crucifixion. If St Paul as understood Jesus to have been resurrected, he could be right, of as course, and his personal ‘vision’ of Jesus or communion with him could be explained in terms of resurrection like the visiting soul of a dead person from the other world, acquiring an apparition very much like its form and shape prior to death. But there seems to be confusion over the mixing up of two types of evidence. Firstly we need to consider the early evidence of his disciples and of those who loved and revered him, although they might not have been formally initiated into Christianity. That evidence must have been as misunderstood by St Paul because it clearly speaks of Jesus in his human form with a corporeal body that cannot be interpreted as resurrection. as To prove this, one has only to refer to the episode of Jesus surprising some of his disciples:
But they were startled and frightened, and supposed that they saw a spirit. And he said to them, "Why are you troubled, and why do questionings rise in your hearts? See my hands and my feet, that it is I myself; handle me, and see; for a spirit has not flesh and bones as you see that I have." And while they still disbelieved for joy, and wondered he said to them, "Have you anything here to eat?" They gave him a piece of broiled fish, and he took it and ate before them. (Luke 24:37–43)
This episode categorically rules out the idea of resurrection, and as speaks of Jesus wanting to demonstrate clearly that he was the same person in the same human body and not a ghost; nor was he someone no longer dependant on food for survival. This further === PDF-Seite 121 === Revival or Resurrection? 93
shows that the early Christians were speaking of two different as things. Whenever they spoke of the revival of Jesus from the dead and were confronted by the sceptical regarding the sheer absurdity of the idea, they took refuge in the notion of resurrec- tion, which could be philosophically and logically explained. Corinthians, in particular, presents an excellent opportunity to study the dilemma of putting one’s feet in two different boats. Finally returning to the evidence of the early Christian’s en- as counters with Jesus Christ , we are left with no option but to as believe that the Jesus who appeared soon after the Crucifixion to many of his disciples and friends, who spoke to them, who accompanied them and moved gradually away from the scene of the Crucifixion, mostly under the cover of night was certainly not a resurrected person but one who could only be taken as a person who was either physically revived from the dead, or one who never died but was miraculously recovered from a state of near death. He was so near, indeed, to death that his state could be as compared to the state of Jonah in the belly of the fish. We have no doubt in our minds that this latter option is the only acceptable one. To make it easier for Christians to understand our point of view I will present a similar hypothetical case. The same story is repeated in real life today. An attempt is made to kill someone by crucifying him and he is supposed to be dead as a result. After- wards, the same person is seen moving about by some of his close associates. They also observe that his physical body visibly carries the marks of crucifixion. He is then recaptured by the Law and presented to a court of justice with a demand from the prosecu- === PDF-Seite 122 === 94 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction
tion that as he had somehow escaped death in the first attempt so as to consummate the sentence passed against him, he must be crucified once again. That man then defends himself by postulat- ing that he most certainly has died once; hence the purpose of law is indeed achieved and now that he had risen from the dead by a special decree of God so the past judgement of condemnation could not be re-executed for the reason that he is enjoying a completely new lease of life in which he had committed no offence against the law. If the court accepts this plea, obviously he would not be punished again for a crime for which he had already paid his dues. If such an incident were to happen in a court of law in a Chris- tian country with a Christian judge and a Christian jury, what verdict would the reader suggest they would or should pass? If the plea of the person under trial is to be rejected and he is con- demned to be hanged again, on what grounds would it be justi- fied? Evidently, any sane judge, Christian or non-Christian, and any jury made up of sane people would not even remotely entertain the plea that having died once the accused had come to life again. Such a verdict has no parochial, religious, racial or ethnic bias. It is universal in nature and no man in command of his sanity can think of a verdict other than this. Hence the universal consensus of human intellect would reject the plea of ‘revival’, and would only pass a verdict of ‘survival’ from death. That is exactly what as happened in the case of Jesus Christ . It was neither a case of revival, nor of resurrection, but simply as common sense would have it, a clear case of survival. === PDF-Seite 123 === Revival or Resurrection? 95
as The coming to life of the dead body of Jesus is so essential to Christianity that one has to investigate the real reasons behind it. Apparently there is no logic in the entire episode. Why should a so-called ‘Son of God’, having been once delivered from his human cage, ever choose to return to it? And how could it be taken as proof beyond doubt that he had actually died and had then come to life again? This aspect has already been considered at some length and I am not attempting to emphasize the same point, but I wish to draw the reader’s attention to another vital relevant question. Why did such an absurd idea take root in Christian theology, as and gradually in a few centuries after Jesus , grow into one of the pillars of Christian belief, without which the whole edifice of Christian theology would collapse? We will try to project our- selves into the minds of the early Christians who faced an almost insoluble dilemma, and began to reconstruct the circumstances in which Christianity was given a shape different from its reality. This way perhaps it will be easier for us to understand, in depth, the making and unmaking of Christianity. The hard fact which as must be brought into sharp focus is simply this: if Jesus , peace be upon him, did actually die upon the cross then in the eyes of the Jewish people he would clearly appear to be an impostor.
Vitriolic Language against Holy People As referred to earlier, the scriptures had predicted that any false claimant, who attributed anything to God which He had not said, as would hang upon the tree. Therefore the death of Jesus upon the === PDF-Seite 124 === 96 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction