Cover Page
Christianity - A Journey from Facts to Fiction, Part 12
used is recorded in many classical books such as the famous medical textbook Al-Qanun by Bu ‘Ali Sina (see Appendix I for a list of such books). So what was the need of applying ointment to a dead body? This could only make sense if the disciples had as strong reasons to believe that Jesus would be delivered alive from the cross and not dead. St John is the only apostle who has ventured to offer an explanation justifying the act of preparing as and applying an ointment to Jesus’ body. This further supports the fact that the act of applying ointment to a dead body was considered extremely odd behaviour, inexplicable to those who as believed that Jesus was dead when ointment was applied. It is for this reason that St John had to offer an explanation. He suggests that it was done merely because it was a Jewish practice to apply some sort of balm or ointment to the bodies of their dead. Now it is a very important fact to note that all modern scholars who have researched into this are in agreement that St John was not of Jewish origin, and he proved it by this statement of his. It is known for certain that Jews or the Children of Israel have never applied any ointments whatsoever to the bodies of their dead. As such the scholars contend that St John must have been of non- Jewish origin otherwise he could not have been so ignorant of Jewish customs. So there has to be another reason for this. as The ointment was applied to save Jesus from near death. The as only explanation lies in the fact that Jesus was neither expected to die by his disciples nor did he actually die upon the cross. The body which was taken down must have shown positive signs of life before the application of the ointment; otherwise, it turns out to be an extremely stupid, unwarranted and futile exercise on the === PDF-Seite 108 === 80 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction
part of those who indulged in it. It is unlikely that those who had prepared this ointment in advance had done so without a very as strong indication that Jesus would not die upon the cross but would be taken down alive seriously wounded very much in need of a powerful healing agent. It should be borne in mind that the location of the sepulchre as where Jesus lay was kept a closely guarded secret, known to a few of his disciples. This was obviously for the reason that he was still alive and was not yet out of danger. As for what happened in the sepulchre, this is debatable on many counts; it cannot stand critical examination, and neither can it prove that the person who walked out had really died and had subsequently been resurrected. The only evidence we have is the as belief of Christians that the Jesus who walked out of the sepul- chre possessed the same body, which was crucified; bearing the same marks and wounds. If he were seen walking out in the same body, then the only logical conclusion, which could be drawn, would be that he had never died. as Another piece of evidence pointing to the continuity of Jesus’ life is as follows. After three days and three nights he is seen, not by the public, but only by his Disciples, in other words, by people whom he trusted. He avoids the light of day and only meets them under the cover of darkness at night. One may safely infer from the Biblical account that he seems to be moving away from the source of danger with a sense of urgency and secrecy. The ques- tion is, if he had been given a new and eternal life after his first death, and was not to suffer another, why was he hiding from the eyes of his enemies; that is, both the government agencies and the === PDF-Seite 109 === Crucifixion 81
public? He should have appeared to the Jews and the representa- tives of the Roman Empire and said: ‘Here I am, with an eternal life, try and kill me again if you may, you will never be able to.’ But he preferred to remain hidden. Not that the idea of appearing in public was not suggested to him, on the contrary, it was specifi- cally suggested to him to reveal himself to the world, but he refused and continued to distance himself from Judea so that no one could follow him.
Judas (not Iscariot) said to him, "Lord, how is it that you will manifest yourself to us, and not to the world?" (John 14:22)
So they drew near to the village to which they were going. He appeared to be going further, but they constrained him, saying, "Stay with us, for it is toward evening and the day is now far spent." So he went in to stay with them. (Luke 24:28–29)
This very strongly presents the case of a mortal who is not be- yond the reach of death or injury to his person. It only signifies as that Jesus had not died in the sense that he was delivered of the human element in him but he remained exactly the same in his nature, whatever it was, and there was no death separating his old self from the new. This is what we call continuity of life in human experience. A spirit or a ghost belonging to another world cer- as tainly does not behave like Jesus behaved during his secret meetings under the cover of night with his close friends and followers. as None other than Jesus himself emphatically rules out the ques- as tion of Jesus being a ghost When he appeared to some of his === PDF-Seite 110 === 82 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction
disciples, they could not hide their fear of him because they as as believed him to be not Jesus himself, but a ghost of Jesus . Jesus as Christ understanding their difficulties dispelled their fears by as denying being a ghost, asserting he was the same Jesus who was crucified and even invited them to examine his wounds, which were still fresh (John 20:19–27). His appearance to his disciples etc, by no means established his revival from the dead. All that it established was simply his survival from the throes of death. As if to remove any misunderstanding that might still have lurked in their minds he asked them what they were eating. When he was told that they were eating bread and fish he asked for some of it because he was hungry and ate some (Luke 24:41– 42). That certainly is a proof beyond a shadow of doubt against his revival from death, that is, a revival of the nature of a human being having died once and brought to life again. The problems as arising out of such an understanding of the revival of Jesus Christ would be two-fold. as If Jesus was still the god-human species, as he is claimed to have been before his crucifixion, then he could not have got rid of the man inside him. This presents a very complicated and problematic situation. What did death do to him, or them, that is as the man in Jesus and the god in him? Did the souls of both man and god depart together and return to the same earthly body again, having visited the same hell together, or was it only the as soul of the god in Jesus which returned to the human body without the soul of man? Where did that soul disappear to, one is left wondering. Was his journey to hell a journey of no return, while the godly soul in him was confined therein only for three === PDF-Seite 111 === Crucifixion 83
as days and nights? Was God the Father of the man Jesus or the Son as Jesus ? This question has to be settled once and for all to give us a as clear picture. Was the body of Jesus , partially a body of God and partially a body of man? The concept of God which we have been granted by the study of both the Old Testament and the New Testament is that of an incorporeal infinite being, with matter having played no role in the making of His person. Having understood this much, let us as look back at Jesus as he was going through different stages of as development as an embryo in the womb of Mary . All the matter as which went into the making of Jesus has to be contributed by the human mother with not even an iota of it being supplied by God the Father. Of course God could have created him miracu- lously. But from my point of view, creation, whether it appears to be, miraculous or natural, is still creation. We can only accept someone to be the father of a son if the substance of the father and the substance of the mother are both shared equally or partially so that at least some of the substance of the body of the child is derived from the substance of the father. From this it should become very clear to the reader that God did not play any fatherly role at all in the birth process of the human embryo and the entire corporeal body with all its cardiac, respiratory, alimentary, portal, cellular and central nervous systems was the unaided product of the human mother alone. Where is as the element of sonship in Jesus who was merely a receptacle for the soul of God and no more? This new understanding of the as relationship between God and Jesus can be sensibly described as anything but a father-son relationship. === PDF-Seite 112 === === PDF-Seite 113 === chapter five
revival or resurrection?
as The scenario of Jesus’ revival from the dead presents many problems. Some of them have already been discussed in the previous chapter. Now we turn to other elements and complexi- as ties. What we have in view is the nature of the ‘mind’ of Jesus , prior to the Crucifixion and after his revival from the dead. His mind was brought to life again, after a loss of function for three days and nights. The question is, what actually happens to the brain at the time of death? On one point at least there is a consen- sus among both the Christian and the non-Christian medical experts: if the brain remains dead for more than a few minutes, it is dead and gone forever. As soon as the blood supply ceases, the brain begins to disintegrate. as If Jesus died during the Crucifixion it can only mean that his heart ceased functioning and stopped supplying blood to his brain, and that his brain died soon after. So his entire life support system must have stopped operating, or he could not have been declared dead. That being so we are faced with a very intriguing problem in relation to the understanding of the life and death of Jesus as Christ . as The death of Jesus Christ , as has been demonstrated, would mean a final departure of his astral body, or soul as we may call it, === PDF-Seite 114 === 86 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction
from the physical cage of his human body. If so, his revival would have to mean the return of the same astral body to the same physical body that it had left behind three days earlier. Such a return of the soul would restart the clock of physical life and set it ticking once again. For such a thing to happen, the disintegrated and dead brain cells would have to come to life suddenly and the chemical processes of rapid decay would have to be reversed entirely. This involves an enormous problem and will ever remain a challenge for the Christian biochemists to resolve. Describing the reversal of the entire chemical processes of decay within the central nervous system is beyond the reach of the farthest stretches of scientist’s imagination. If it ever happened it would be a miracle indeed, defying science and making a mockery of the laws made by God Himself, but it would be a miracle that would still fail to solve the problem at hand. Such a revival would mean not just the revival of the cells of the central nervous system, but actually their synthesis. Even if the same cells were reconstructed and brought to life exactly as they were before, they would, in fact, be a new set of cells devoid of any previous memory. They would have to be re-manufactured, as complete with all the data relevant to the life of Jesus that was wiped out of his brain after the death of his mind. Life, as we know it, comprises a consciousness that is filled with information held by billions of neurons within the brain. That information is then subdivided into far more complicated and interrelated bits of computerised information received from each of the five senses. If that data were wiped out, life itself would be as wiped out. Therefore, the revival of the brain of Jesus would === PDF-Seite 115 === Revival or Resurrection? 87
mean the construction and the manufacture of a new brain computer with a completely new set of software. This complexity also relates to the chemistry of the rest of the body of Jesus as Christ . To revive the body, a colossal chemical reconstruction process would have to be put into operation after retrieving all the material lost in the process of decay. With such a great miracle having taken place the question would arise as to who was revived as and with what effect? Was it the man in Jesus , or was it the god in him? This is why we are emphasising the importance of under- as standing the person of Jesus . as Whenever Jesus is known to have faltered and failed to exhibit his superpowers as the Son of God, Christians take refuge in the claim that he faltered as a man and not as a god. So we have every right to question and to clearly define which part in him was man as and which was god. The faltering of the man in Jesus requires a human mind as a separate entity to that of the god in him. When as the brain was revived it was the human element in Jesus which as was revived because the ‘Divine’ entity of Jesus did not require a material brain to support him. For the ‘Divine’ entity it only worked as a receptacle during his previous sojourn on earth, as in as the case of a spiritual medium. Hence, the revival of Jesus would only imply the revival of the man in him, without which the return of his spirit to the same body is rendered impossible. If this scenario is not acceptable then we will face another grave as problem of attributing to Jesus during his earthly life two inde- pendent minds, one of man and another that of god, with the two minds cohabiting the same space but otherwise unrelated and independent. If so, the revival issue will have to be re-examined === PDF-Seite 116 === 88 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction
so that its true nature is clearly understood. In this scenario, one does not have to conceive of the essential reconstruction of the human brain to provide a seat for the human mind; we need only as to imagine Jesus revisiting a skull filled with the decaying remains of the brain of his former human host The deeper we look into this problem, more problems raise their heads at every newly probed level. Man’s mind requires a brain as a tool of his thought process. As far as the functions of the physical body are concerned, if we believe that the mind is a separate entity which lives by itself, then this would imply that the mind and the soul are the same thing. By whatever name we refer to it, whether we call it mind or soul, it may be considered as capable of living separately even when its relationship with the human brain is severed. But if the mind or the soul is required to govern the human body, or to be influenced by what goes on in its physical realms then there has to be a profound bondage between the mind and the brain, or the soul and the brain, otherwise they simply cannot influence, motivate or control the physical, mental or sentimental processes in man. Perhaps this is not debatable. From this we are led to another serious problem: does the so- called Divine Son need to control a body through a brain? And does he depend on a physical brain for his thought processes? If he transcends all human limitations and if he has an independent system of thought processes, unique to him, with no parallel in the entire universe of his creation, then the return of the soul of God to the human body along with that of the mind of man reconstructs a bizarre situation of a dual personality with two === PDF-Seite 117 === Revival or Resurrection? 89
conflicting thought processes, because it is impossible for the human mind and the human soul to be completely at one with the mind of God and His being. There would be a constant variation between the two thought processes with very irritating clashes of brain waves. Such a case would be fit to be treated by a superhuman psychiatrist It is a new type of spiritual schizophrenia, perhaps. Having said that, let us reconstruct the entire scenario from a different angle. After studying Christianity at some depth I have come to the conclusion that there is confusion prevailing in the understanding of some terms and their application, without fully understanding their implications, to situations where they do not actually apply. Christian ideology is densely befogged with such confusion and misapplied terminology. ‘Revival’ is one term and ‘Resurrection’ is another, and both have different meanings. So far, we have intentionally used the term ‘revival’ when discussing as the possibility of Jesus coming to life again. As we have clearly seen from the previous discussion ‘revival’ means the return of all vital functions of the human body after death. But ‘resurrection’ is a completely different phenomenon. Unfortunately, the Christian church, all over the world, has been responsible for creating confusion in Christian minds by misusing these terms by swapping one with the other, or at least by attributing the meaning of one to the other. Most Christians as understand the resurrection of Jesus Christ as the springing to life once again of his human body which he had abandoned at the moment of his so-called death. Of course we disagree with this === PDF-Seite 118 === 90 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction