Cover Page
Christianity - A Journey from Facts to Fiction, Part 15
had to admit ultimately that the verses in Mark and Luke are additions without a foundation in the original texts.♣
What Happened to Jesus’ Body? A closer critical examination from the point of view of common sense and logic reveals further absurdities inherent in the episodes of the Crucifixion and the Ascension as presented by the Chris- as tians of today. As far as the question of Jesus’ return to his human body is concerned, enough has been said. We only want to add to as the issue of what might have happened to that body when Jesus finally ascended, if he ever did. When confronted by the question as to what happened to the as body of Jesus Christ , it is suggested by some Christians that as he ascended to his heavenly Father his carnal body disintegrated and disappeared in a glow. This raises a fundamental question. If the as departure of Jesus from the human body was to result in such an explosive event, why did it not happen at the instant of his first as reported death? The only reference we have in the Bible to Jesus’ death is when he was still hanging on the cross and in the words of St Matthew ‘he gave up the ghost’ Apparently, nothing hap- pened other than a smooth departure of the soul from the body. Are we to assume that he did not die upon the cross after all, because if he had left the body, it should have exploded in a
♣ New World Translation. === PDF-Seite 131 === Revival or Resurrection? 103
similar fashion even then? Why did it only happen the second as time Jesus left his body? Under the circumstances only two avenues are open to proceed further: as 1. That the person of Jesus did not remain eternally confined to the human body after his soul returned to it and that during his ascent he cast away his human body and as- cended purely as a spirit of God. This is neither supported by facts nor is it conceivable because as that would lead into a blind alley of believing that Jesus died twice. The first time on the cross and the second time on Ascen- sion. 2. That he remained confined within the human shell eter- nally. This cannot be accepted because it is utterly repulsive and in- consistent with the dignity and majesty of the image of God. On the other hand, we have a point of view of common sense; ‘It as would be a mistake to understand Jesus’ ascension as a sort of ancient space trip, and heaven as a place beyond the sun, moon 4 * and the galaxies. The truth is neither here nor there.’ The con- coction of such a bizarre story, therefore, could only have been motivated by the insoluble dilemma that the Christians faced as during the nascent period of Christianity. When Jesus disap- peared from view, naturally the question would have been raised as to what happened to him. The early Christians could not have
*
The Lion Handbook of Christian Belief, Lion, London (1982) p. 120. 4 === PDF-Seite 132 === 104 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction
resolved the quandary by openly professing that as he had never died so there was no question of a body being left behind and that his body had in fact gone along with him during the course of his migration. In this way the problem of the disappearance of the body could have been easily resolved. But this confession was impossible to make. Those who would have dared to admit that as Jesus was seen alive and gradually moving away from Judea faced the peril of being condemned by the Roman Law as accessories to the crime of escape from justice. To seek refuge in the concoction of a story, like the ascent of as Jesus to heaven offered a safer option, however bizarre the idea. Yet of course it would involve indulgence in falsehood. We must pay our tribute to the integrity of the early disciples who despite this predicament did not seek refuge in a false statement. All writers of the Gospels chose to remain silent on this issue rather than take refuge behind a smoke screen of misstatements. No doubt they must have suffered the jeering of their adversaries, but they chose to suffer in silence. Mysterious silence on the part of those who knew the inside story must have been largely responsible for sowing the seeds of doubt in the minds of Christians of later generations. They must as have wondered: why, after the soul of Jesus Christ had departed, was there no mention of his body being left behind? Where had it as gone and what had happened to it? Why did the soul of Christ return to the same body if it ever did? These vital but unanswered questions could have given birth to other questions. If revival meant returning to the same body, what must have happened to as Jesus Christ after the second term of his imprisonment in the === PDF-Seite 133 === Revival or Resurrection? 105
carnal human frame? Did he eternally remain locked up in that body, never to be released again? as On the other hand if the soul of Jesus once again departed from the same body, then was that revival temporary or perma- nent? If he did not remain locked in it then what happened to his body after his second death? Where was it buried and is there any mention of it in any archives or chronicles? It seems that these questions, even if not raised earlier, must have been raised during the later centuries when intense philoso- as phical exercises concerning the mystery of Christ and all about him were witnessed widely among Christian theologians. It appears that some unscrupulous scribe tried to wriggle out of this by interpolating the last twelve verses in the Gospel of St Mark, as and falsely attributed to him the statement that Jesus was last seen ascending to heaven in the same body. The hands of concoction did not spare the Gospel of Luke either, where the clever insertion of the words ‘and he was carried up to heaven’ in 24:51 served the purpose of the interpolator. In this way he put to rest the queries once and for all. At least one mystery of Christian dogma was thus resolved. But alas, at what cost! At the cost of the noble facts relating to the real holy image as as of Jesus Christ . The fact of Christ was thus sacrificed on the altar of fiction. From then on, Christianity continued to proceed unabated and unchecked in the journey of his transformation from facts to fiction. We know for certain that the Jews were as unhappy and disturbed at not finding the body of Jesus Christ as (Matt 28:11–15). They wanted to be sure of Jesus’ death and for that they needed the universally acceptable proof of death, that is, === PDF-Seite 134 === 106 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction
the presence of a dead body. Their complaint, lodged with Pilate, evidently displays their uneasiness about its potential disappearance (Matt 27:62–64). The real and simple answer, however, lay in the fact that as as Christ had not died in the manner that was believed, so the question of a missing body was totally irrelevant, and in keeping with his promise he must have left Judea in search of the lost sheep of the House of Israel. Obviously he could not be seen again.
The Ahmadiyya Muslim Viewpoint as The Ahmadiyya Muslim viewpoint of the whereabouts of Jesus’ as body is very clear, logical and factual. It presents Jesus and what happened to him in the light of truth, haloed by its glory. The as very reality of Jesus Christ is so beautiful that there is no need to build an ornamental mystery around him. His reality encompasses his suffering for the sake of sinful humanity throughout his life, which culminated in the agony of the Crucifixion; his deliverance from the cross as promised by the Merciful and Beneficent God Almighty, and his subsequent migration in pursuit of the ten lost tribes of Israel. Hence he delivered the message of God not only to the two tribes whom he addressed before the Crucifixion, but he also reached out to all the other tribes of Israel and thus fulfilled the purpose of his commission. It was only then that he brought the full purpose of his ministry to a final end. These are the noble and as illustrious realities of Jesus’ life. === PDF-Seite 135 === Revival or Resurrection? 107
The founder of the Ahmadiyya Community, Hadrat Mirza as Ghulam Ahmad of Qadian declared about a hundred years ago as that Jesus , a true prophet of God, was delivered from the cross as was implied in his earlier discourses. For the first time in the history of Islam, Hadrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, divinely guided as as he was, lifted the mystical veil from the brilliant realities of Jesus’ life. It was he who declared in the face of the bitter resentment of as the majority of the orthodox Muslims that Jesus had neither died upon the cross, nor ascended bodily to heaven, but was miracu- lously delivered alive from the cross in keeping with God’s as promise. Thereafter Jesus migrated in search of the lost sheep of the House of Israel as he himself had promised. By following the probable route of the migration of Israeli tribes one can safely assume that he must have travelled through Afghanistan on his way to Kashmir and other parts of India where the presence of Israeli tribes was reported. There is strong historical evidence that the peoples of both Afghanistan and Kashmir have stemmed from migrant Jewish as tribes. Hadrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad revealed that Jesus ulti- mately died and was buried in Srinagar, Kashmir. When Ahmadis put forward this explanation as a plausible and as realistic solution to the disappearance of Jesus’ body from the country of his birth, many a time they are met with the rebuttal that even given that he was delivered from the cross alive, it is extremely far-fetched that he should have taken the hazardous journey from Judea to Kashmir. Hearing this rebuttal Ahmadis are left wondering as to which distance is longer, the one from Palestine to Kashmir or the one from the Earth to the farthest === PDF-Seite 136 === 108 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction
reaches of Heaven. Again Ahmadis wonder as to what happened as to the promise of Jesus Christ that he would go in search of the Lost Sheep of the House of Israel. If he departed straight from Palestine to sit on the right hand of his Father, did he forget about his commitment, or was his promise impossible for him to keep? It is either this or, as we suggested earlier, should it be expected that the Lost Sheep of the House of Israel had earlier ascended to as the heavens where Jesus went in their pursuit?
Survival Cases For those who still find it difficult to believe that the scenario of as Jesus having been delivered alive from the cross is too far-fetched and unacceptable, we draw their attention to the fact that in the light of known and recorded history of man’s survival in ex- as tremely hazardous situations, the case of Jesus , as we have pre- sented it, is neither bizarre nor impossible to accept. Many medically reported and verified cases of near death present a host of evidence in favour of the survival of people in almost impossi- ble situations. The well documented case of a Maharajah of a small state of pre-partition India is worthy of mention. He was subjected to a similar near impossible situation in which he had few chances of survival. The Maharajah in question was poisoned by his wife and while his body was being cremated with the fires well lit, a violent storm suddenly appeared. Ultimately he not only escaped death but also after a long legal battle was reinstated to his throne. The story runs like this: === PDF-Seite 137 === Revival or Resurrection? 109
"Ramendra Narayan Roy, the Kumar of the Bhowal Estate with headquarters of the Court of Wards at Joydevpur, was alleged to have been poisoned and subsequently declared dead and placed for cremation at the burning ghat in May, 1909. Circumstances suggested that his wife was a principal player in the attempted murder. A heavy thunder burst, before the completion of the cremation, caused the party responsible for burning the dead body to hurriedly return, leaving the dead-body. The rain caused the fire to extinguish. A group of sadhus (Hindu hermits) who were passing by noticed that the man was alive. He was thus rescued. Next day when it was discovered by the conspirators that the body had disappeared, they had another body cremated to make Kumar’s death look like a fact.
The sadhus, who had saved him, then took him from place to place. The near death experience had caused Kumar to lose his memory but he regained it gradually and visited Joydevpur twelve years later. The familiar surroundings of his home town caused him to regain his memory entirely. When Kumar filed a civil suit to recover the estate from the Court of Wards as the genuine heir and owner of Bhowal Estate, his wife and some others contested it. A court case was then bitterly fought between the two parties. More than one thousand people gave evidence in favour of Kumar and four hundred in support of his wife. The actual matter being contested was regarding the identity of Kumar as according to common knowledge he had died twelve years ago. === PDF-Seite 138 === 110 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction
The case was won by Kumar after he identified some marks on the body of his wife which only a husband could have known. His estate * was then restored to him."
Hundreds of thousands of similar cases might have gone com- pletely unreported. Thanks to modern medical facilities and media coverage, hundreds of similar cases are being reported and re- corded. If all this is plausible in cases of ordinary people from all classes of society and from all sorts of religious moral backgrounds, as why could it not be possible in the case of Jesus ? If anyone has the chance of surviving in challenging and almost impossible as situations, Jesus indeed stands a greater chance because of the special circumstance surrounding him. Strangely enough, how- as ever, the sceptics dismiss the suggestion that Jesus did survive the attempted murder by crucifixion. Yet they would readily believe a far more unrealistic, bizarre and unnatural tale of his revival from absolute death—death, which lasted a full three days and nights according to them. The field of medical research has also taken interest in the phe- nomenon of near death. A study was carried out in which seventy eight reports of near death experiences were examined. In eighty percent of the cases medical personnel were present during or immediately after these experiences. Interestingly, forty one