Cover Page

Christianity - A Journey from Facts to Fiction, Part 16

The Bhowal Case, compiled by J.M. Mitra and R.C. Chakravarty, published by Peer & *

Son, Calcutta. === PDF-Seite 139 === Revival or Resurrection? 111

percent of the subjects reported that they had been considered * dead during the near death experience. With all kinds of gadgetry at their disposal, if medical experts can pronounce a living person dead, how reliable would be the as testimony of an anxious observer who saw Jesus losing con- sciousness and from this deduced that he had died? Furthermore, after seeing him again, to draw the conclusion that he was revived from death is totally unjustified.

The Phenomenology of Near-Death Experiences, by Bruce Greyson, M.D and Ian *

Stevenson, M.D., AM. Psychiatry 137:10, October 1980 === PDF-Seite 140 === === PDF-Seite 141 === chapter six

trinity

So far we have only examined the underlying compulsions, as which led to the creation of the myths of the deification of Jesus and his so-called role in the Trinity as the Son of God. But the third person in the Christian dogma of Trinity, that is the Holy Ghost, is a bit of an enigma. Why could not ‘Two in One’ suffice and why was there the need to introduce the third entity into this fundamental doctrine? Logically, the third entity has no justifica- tion to occupy a place in the Christian concept of godhead. Harnack, a commentator on this question, feels that, initially, as Christianity was represented by a dyad in God and Jesus . It later encompassed the church, referring to it as ‘The Spirit,’ to add an element of divinity to what would otherwise be a hollow and implausible third partner. This also served an excellent anti-Judaic * tool. Rev K.E. Kirk in his essay on ‘The Evolution of the Doc- trine of Trinity’ has this to say on the same subject:

‘We naturally turn to the writers of that period to discover what grounds they have for their belief. To our surprise, we are forced to

Harnack, 'Constitution and Law of the Church,' E.T. p. 264 * === PDF-Seite 142 === 114 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction

admit that they have none. The question as it presented itself to them was not, Why three persons? But rather Why not?’

He goes on to point out the complete failure of Christian the- ology to produce any logical justification for the Trinitarian doctrine and the Christian triad could be explained as essentially a binary concept to which a third disparate entity was laced in order * to paint a more complete picture. We believe that this entity gradually evolved under the influ- ence of earlier pagan philosophies and myths which abounded in the Roman Empire. The exchange of ideas must have drawn Christian theologians to determine the position of the Holy Ghost. As there is ample evidence of the existence of such faiths or cults that visualized God as being composed of three entities in one, it is not difficult to trace back the ultimate source of the Christian doctrine of the Trinity. After all if two could be one, and one could be two, why could not three be one as well? It is for the research scholars to determine exactly when and how the third entity of the Christian godhead took its firm roots in Chris- tian mythology, but at present it is outside the domain of this discussion. Here, we only wish to examine the absurdity of such claims, which are rejected outright by human understanding. Human nature spurns self-contradictory and paradoxical ideas.

Essays on the Trinity and the Incarnation, p. 93, edited by A. E. J. Rawlinson, Longman, *

London 1929. === PDF-Seite 143 === Trinity 115

Interrelationship within Trinity When one tries to visualize the inter-relationship of the three constituents of the Christian godhead, the only possible scenarios which arise are as follows: 1. They possessed different phases or aspects of one single person. 2. They were three different persons, sharing eternity among them equally. 3. They were three persons with some of their characteristics individual, distinct, and not entirely shared by others. 4. They were three persons in one with completely similar characteristics and similar equal powers, merged with each other and with no functions separate from the other. We will consider each of these possibilities in turn.

Different Phases or Aspects of One Single Person As for the first possibility there is no need to discuss it at length because there is hardly any Christian today who would believe as Jesus to be an aspect or a phase of God rather than a distinct person. Believers in Trinity insist on there being three different persons merged into one. The moment one accepts the scenario of one person having different aspects displayed simultaneously, the concept of Trinity, that is, of three gods in one, melts away into thin air, and no Trinity is left at all. Then it would be God the Father Himself who, motivated by His mercy, would die for human sins. In this case it will merely be a transient phase of the same person. Aspects === PDF-Seite 144 === 116 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction

are not persons, and similarly phases do not create separate enti- ties. Any human being can pass through a multitude of varying moods and aspects, without splitting into two or three or many persons. Therefore, if God decided to die for the sake of the sinful humanity, it would have to be God Himself and not His aspects who would do so. Hence, regarding the case in point, that aspect of God which played a vital role in the Divine sacrifice for the sake of sinful humanity can only be understood to be a mere display of one of his attributes. So, if the mercy of God is alone to be treated as a ‘person’ and that person is given the name of Jesus Christas , then that something which died was the ‘mercy’ of God. What a strange contradiction it is that the mercy of God, having taken pity on sinful humanity, commits suicide. It implies that for three days and nights there was no mercy left in God. as Remember that, in this scenario, Jesus is not being treated as a separate independent person, but only as a characteristic or an aspect of God in which he becomes a sort of mercy personified. That person, however, remains to be the one single indivisible entity of God. So if anything died during this process, it would have to be either the person God or the attribute of His Mercy, which played the most vital role in this episode. Hence there is no option but to believe in either the death of the Mercy of God, or the death of Merciful God Himself. Many complications would arise out of the claim that aspects of a single person could be wiped out of existence, whether tempo- rarily or permanently. This scenario can only be understood in relation to its application to human experience. A man can lose === PDF-Seite 145 === Trinity 117

sight or hearing temporarily or permanently, but he would still be the same living man. The death of a faculty is, in fact, a partial death of the same person. In the ultimate analysis, the loser or sufferer remains the same individual entity.

Different Persons Sharing Eternity If the elements of the Christian godhead were three different persons sharing eternity simultaneously, the question would arise as to their internal relationship. If they were eternally three persons making up one god, they have to have their own inde- pendent egos, so that the suffering of one, if he could suffer, would be his own personal experience. The others could sympa- thise with him, but could not actually participate in and share the suffering. Of course it is almost impossible to imagine the thought mechanism and decision-making processes of God, but the claim that He is actually three persons moulded into one justifies an effort to interrelate the three independent thought processes. One possible scenario, which arises, is that of a human child born with three heads. This enormity can be referred to as a single person by virtue of there being only one trunk and four limbs, but three heads do present a problem of describing their true nature. If such freaks of nature live long enough to be able to speak and express themselves only then can we enquire as to what is happening inside the three different heads. In the absence of such knowledge, however, to declare them to be one person sharing three minds or three persons sharing one body is not possible. === PDF-Seite 146 === 118 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction

It is strange that this very important aspect of Christian doctrine is not explained in the scriptures at all. As far as the reference to as Christ and the Holy Ghost is concerned there is no dearth of evidence that they are presented as two distinct persons, who did not share the same thought processes and the same feelings. as Otherwise the visions of the Holy Ghost as distinct from Christ would be impossible to conceive, particularly during the period as that Christ was confined to his human body. The questions that would certainly arise as to what actually as happened to the person of Christ during that experience, in relation to the other two constituents of Christian Godhead, are: 1. Did the other two constituents, that is, God the Father and as the Holy Ghost, jointly share in any way the body of Jesus Christ or his experiences in their relation to that body? as 2. Was Jesus the sole occupant of that body and as such he did not share his experience in relation to that body with either of the remaining two constituents of the Trinity? The ramifications of the former have already been discussed. In the case of the latter a further complication arises as to the rela- as tionship of Jesus , at that time, with the other two constituents of as Trinity. Did Jesus become a completely separate entity by himself during that period or did he remain an integral part of the other two constituents, only additionally occupying a dwelling in the form of a human body exclusively? Now we have another ques- tion to answer: 3. Was his divine entity entirely contained in his human body, or was it only projected out of the commonly shared form of God === PDF-Seite 147 === Trinity 119

the Father and the Holy Ghost like a tiny finger jutting out of an amoeba’s body? This scenario will also have us believe that during that phase as Jesus was greater than both his co-partners because he equally shared the form of existence with the Father and the Holy Ghost, while they did not share the jutted out finger of his human existence. Hence, to make matters easily understandable, an attempt is made to illustrate the inherent paradoxes and absurdities by visualising different hypothetical situations. Of course, the illustra- tions should not be taken literally by the readers. The issue before us is whether there is a single person exhibit- ing different attributes or going through different phases. This brings us to the question of considering the proposition of ‘Three beings in One’ and ‘One being in Three’, particularly from the angle of different phases as distinct from each other, and display- ing different characters and moods by the same person. This position has been considered at length in a previous chap- ter. Here, it is only necessary to re-emphasise the point that if one person or one entity exhibits different phases, it cannot exhibit those different phases simultaneously, without dividing itself into different parts. Take, for example, water in a certain measure and quantity. It can be turned entirely into vapour or ice without compromising the singleness of its entity. If it is to be simultaneously observed in these different phases, it would have to be split so that a third of it would be ice, a third vapour and a third liquid. Each form would be different from the other, with none sharing the other two === PDF-Seite 148 === 120 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction

phases simultaneously. That quantity of water would be split into three states, but the size of each would certainly be smaller than the totality of the substance and no one can declare it to be ‘One in Three’ and ‘Three in One’. Similarly, the incarnation of as as Christ in the human form of Jesus , while keeping both the as bondages between Jesus the man and God the Father intact, is inconceivable. All human beings are made up of the same elements, but their conformity and similarity to each other does not turn them into one single person. It is their characteristics, individualities and separateness from one another, which divides them into a multi- tude of entities, although they are intrinsically made from the same substance. One cannot, however, call them ‘one in five billion’ and ‘five billion in one’, despite their all sharing the humanity factor. Let us now examine the same question from another angle. If, as for any specific period of time, Jesus was separate and distinguish- able from God the Father on the one hand, and the Holy Ghost on the other, in which areas did that distinct separate existence of as as Christ lie? Remember that one has to conceive of Christ as being so totally distinct and disengaged from the Father and the Holy Ghost that his sacrifice for his fellow human brothers, or shall we say partial human brothers, must be thought of as entirely his own personal experience, different from that of the Father or the Holy Ghost This would evidently result in our considering as Christ alone transferring his mind or his thought processes to the as physical body of Jesus . Also then he could be understood as having undergone an experience, which was not shared by the === PDF-Seite 149 === Trinity 121

·

10 of 10 left today