Cover Page

Christianity - A Journey from Facts to Fiction, Part 17

other two components of the Christian Trinity. Mind boggling, is it not?

Different Persons with Distinctly Different Characters as If God the Father, Jesus and the Holy Ghost were three persons with individual characters, not entirely shared by others, then they may not be considered as ‘Three in One’ and ‘One in Three’. The complete merger of the Trinity into Unity can only be conceived if the characters, attributes, functions and all the facul- ties possessed by three persons become identical to each other’s, without any distinctive feature separating one from the other. This presents a scenario which could to a degree be likened to that of identical triplets, who with reference to their mind, heart, feelings and the functions of their organs are in such perfect unison that the individual experience of each of them is shared by the others completely. If this happens then something of the Trinity of God, the Son and the Holy Ghost could become more understandable. But the problem would still remain concerning the three bodies, which contain the three identical persons. This of course is not applicable to the Christian idea of Trinity. At second glance one is compelled to visualize a single body possess- ing three identities. Again, such an identity of the so-called triplets can only be visualized if one body can contain three persons, which in itself poses many problems. However, it can be pointed out that God has no body and as such the similitude of a human body, as suggested, is not applicable. Of course, we fully under- stand that God has no body in human terms, but the problem === PDF-Seite 150 === 122 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction

would still remain concerning three spiritual beings as identical triplets, individually as persons, yet being one in all other respects. Another problem, which would confront the existence of hy- pothetical triplets would be their relationship with regards to worship. Would the ‘Three in One’ spiritual persons of the godhead worship one another? Would they all be the recipients of worship by their creation without there being any exercise of worship in relation to each other? Although repeated mention is made in the New Testament of as Jesus Christ worshipping ‘God the Father’ and admonishing others to do the same, no such mention has been made in relation to the Holy Ghost worshipping God the Father. Again, there has as never been any attempt by Jesus , as recorded in the New Testa- ment, to exhort others to worship him or to worship the Holy Ghost One is intrigued by this total absence of reference to worship except in relation to God the Father. Although it is a common practice among the Christians to wor- as ship Jesus as the ‘Son of God’ along with the Father, there are no as recorded instances of any of the disciples of Jesus Christ ever as having worshipped him or Jesus prompting them to do so during his sojourn on Earth. Even if he had done so, it would raise many unanswerable questions. Again the same applies to the Holy Ghost and raises the question why did the Holy Ghost not require anyone to worship him. The case where they were ‘Three in One’ in the sense that their ultimate ego or consciousness of existence was one, despite being divided into three aspects or phases, has already been examined at some length. A being of such a description cannot be === PDF-Seite 151 === Trinity 123

logically referred to as ‘three persons in one’. Moreover, aspects or phases are neither worshipped nor do they worship their own central ego. To conceive of these as separate persons they have to have their own independent identity in the form of an ultimate ego, which offers a reference point to their consciousness as persons. Otherwise the question of referring to themselves and others as ‘1’, ‘You’ and ‘He’, simply does not arise. Trinity in application to one being can only be conceived as attributes and no more, and as far as attributes are concerned, they are certainly not limited to three. Whether we know them or not, God could possess a multitude of attributes. To bring this discussion to a conclusion, we re-emphasise that the question of worship in relation to each other can only arise if they were different persons who did not enjoy equal status and equal characteristics. In this instance, only one would be worthy of worship and the other two by the logic of their being inferior would be expected to worship him. The answer, again, is acceptable except that the ‘Oneness in Trinity’ will vanish. There is no way that you can have both ‘Three in One’ and ‘One in Three’ simultaneously. This reminds me of a joke which I would like to share with you. It is reported that Joha, a famous court jester, so amused Tamerlane during his invasion of Baghdad that he decided to carry him back with him as booty and appointed him as the chief court jester. Once, it is said, Joha felt like eating meat alone by himself so much that he could not resist it any more. So he bought two kilos of the best meat available from the butcher. While handing it over to his wife he instructed her to prepare a === PDF-Seite 152 === 124 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction

delicious roast out of it, and that no one, including the wife, except him must touch it. Unfortunately for him, however, as his wife had just finished cooking, a few of her brothers gave her a surprise call. This was a pleasant surprise for her indeed but one which was destined to become a very unpleasant surprise for Joha. The tempting aroma of the freshly roasted meat was simply too much for them to resist and what followed was a logical conclu- sion. Having finished it to the last morsel they happily took leave of their rather worried sister. However, she had composed herself by the time Joha returned home and was ready with a foolproof excuse. When Joha, also smelling the remnant of the flavour, longingly asked for his two kilos of meat, the wife responded by pointing at the cat which was Joha’s favourite pet, and said: ‘Take your meat out of this cat, if you can. While I was busy working, he made short work of the entire roast’ Thereupon Joha immedi- ately picked the cat and weighed him in the scale. It so happened that the cat turned out to weigh exactly two kilos. Then he turned gently to his wife and enquired: ‘Please my dear, I do believe you of course, but if this is my meat then where is my cat, and if this is my cat where is my meat!’ Jokes aside, let me assert that I do not wish to contend this issue as on the basis of Jesus’ real and true teachings. This treatise is purely an exercise in viewing the current Christian doctrines which we believe have deviated a long way from the original as teachings of Jesus . === PDF-Seite 153 === Trinity 125

as Having denied that there is any reference in the Bible to Jesus being worshipped, it is left to us to explain the only reference * relating to this, in Luke 24:52 . Many claim that these verses as provide evidence of Jesus himself exhorting his followers to worship him. Contemporary Christian scholars are well aware that these verses have been proved to be spurious and have no right to be treated as a genuine part of St Luke’s Gospel. Let us now turn to the question of common practice, whether it is supported by evidence in the Gospels or not. According to as the common practice, in many sects of Christianity today, Jesus is indeed being worshipped as the ‘Son of God’. Yet they all agree as that the same Jesus whom they worship used to worship God the Father and Him alone. In vain I have often enquired from knowledgeable Christian as scholars as to the reason why Jesus should have worshipped God the Father if he himself was an inseparable part of God and was so completely merged with Him so as to create a sense of unity despite there being three persons? Did he ever worship the third constituent of the Trinity, that is the Holy Ghost? Did he ever as worship himself? Did the Holy Ghost ever worship Jesus ? Did the Father ever worship either of the remaining two? If not, why? Perhaps the answer to these questions would compel the Chris- tians to confess that a distinct superiority is certainly established of God the Father over the remaining two constituents of the

* The Bible translated by James Moffatt, published by Harper & Brothers, printed in the USA. === PDF-Seite 154 === 126 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction

Trinity. From this it emerges that the three constituents of Trinity are not identical in their status. Hence they are ‘Three in Three’, if at all they are three, but they are not ‘Three in One’. Some- times when Christian scholars are confronted with the question of as Jesus , whom they believe to be the Son of God, having wor- shipped God the Father, they claim that it was the man who as worshipped God the Father, and not the Son Jesus who did so. That takes us back to the discussion, which we have already covered earlier. Were there two conscious beings possessing the as same body of Jesus , one possessing human consciousness and the other that of the Son of God? Again, why did the man bypass and completely ignore the Son as God in him and never worship Christ as such? The same man as as Jesus , the co-partner of Christ , should also have worshipped the third constituent the Holy Ghost, which he never did. Worship is an act of mind and soul that is expressed sometimes in bodily symbols, but it remains an act rooted in the mental and emotional entity of the person. Hence it has to be determined as who worshipped when Jesus Christ worshipped God. We have already dealt with the scenario, with all its intricacies, in which it as is Christ , the Son of God, who worshipped. Conversely, if it was the man who worshipped God the Father and if he never wor- as shipped Christ , then why on earth do the Christians defy this as holy example of Jesus himself? Why should they start worship- as as ping Christ beside God, while Jesus the man never worshipped as his co-partner Christ , despite being so close to him. === PDF-Seite 155 === Trinity 127

Different Persons with Identical and Equal Characters Once again let us now examine, from a different angle this time, the formula of ‘Three in One’ in Trinity as three distinct persons who are absolutely and completely identical to each other. In this scenario we are not talking about a single person with different features combined in one but of three separate forms, rather like triplets. We refer to the kind of triplets, which are so completely identical that their similarities do not end with likeness of form alone, but also extend to the entire thinking and feeling processes. They share their thoughts, feelings and experiences identically. In this case one has to admit that two out of the three constituents of the Trinity are superfluous. If they are done away with, it will not in the least affect the remaining constituent of Trinity, which will remain complete in it. The Holy Qur’an also raises the same question when it points out that if God decided to destroy and wipe out of existence both as Jesus Christ and the Holy Ghost, what difference will it make to His Majesty, Eternity and Perfection and who can stop Him from doing so (the Holy Qur’an 5:18). It implies that all the divine attributes will continue to function eternally and as such the concept of the Trinity as portrayed in this scenario appears sense- less and needless. If, however it is supposed that the three distinct persons in the Trinity perform different functions, then obviously all three components would become essential to the making of the God- head. Nevertheless, in this case there will be three distinct Gods cooperating with each other and living together in perfect har- === PDF-Seite 156 === 128 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction

mony and as such they can only be treated as ‘Three Gods in Three’ and not ‘Three Gods in One’. Again if it is proposed that the Trinity is similar to the case of a single person with different organic functions, all combined in one, then of course Unity can be retained but not Trinity. Here we are not discussing a person with different organic functions but three entirely identical persons, each performing similar functions yet retaining its individuality. What is being discussed presents the case of a single person with different organs. So far there is noth- ing illogical about it. But when the organs are treated as persons in their own right and at the same time they are believed to constitute a personality which in its totality is one, then the confines of logic are breached and the whole discussion becomes unacceptable. Indeed organs have their individuality, but their individuality is only a component of a larger personality, which not only comprises this one organ but also other organs. All such organs together within a man are called ‘man’ in its totality. Of course some organs perform relatively minor functions and man can remain a man without them, but only with imperfection. A perfect man must possess all organs that are commonly possessed by a human being and the sum total of these organs would make him a perfect man. If we take the case of a man called Paul, one cannot say that since the liver, heart, lungs and kidneys of Paul have individuality with specific functions to perform, they are distinct persons completely identifiable with Paul. Complete identification can only be possible if, say, the kidneys function exactly like Paul in his totality and the same can be said of his other organs. That === PDF-Seite 157 === Trinity 129

proposition would require that the absence of each organ would not change the character of Paul in any manner or alternatively Paul even without his lungs, heart, kidneys and brain, indeed with all his organs removed, would still remain a complete Paul in himself. This is because in the ultimate analysis they are all exactly similar to each other and the person of Paul remains absolutely intact, irrespective of the absence of these organs. If that is the scenario of ‘Three in One’ then of course it is wrong to make any attempts to criticize Christian beliefs with reference to logic. Then the logic, which is applicable to the present day Christian dogma, is only the logic of the witches of Macbeth when they say: ‘Fair is foul, and foul is fair’. === PDF-Seite 158 === === PDF-Seite 159 === chapter seven

the evolution of christianity

The doctrine of Trinity, which is one of the fundamental constituents of Christian dogma, was absent from Christianity as during the lifetime of Jesus Christ . The maximum one can grant is that this doctrine started taking shape after the Crucifixion. It took many centuries for it to reach its final well defined but inexplicable form. It went through a long process of extremely bitter and controversial debates between Christian theologians and philosophers representing different religious, cultural and tradi- tional backgrounds. It was greatly influenced by the myths and the traditions of various lands, which hosted Christianity in its early period. The main stem of Christianity, however, which took care of and nurtured the development of Christian beliefs and philosophy in its early formative part was of Jewish stock. Jewish influence remained predominant throughout the early part of Christian as history. The disciples of Jesus , who learnt and understood Chris- as tianity directly from Jesus and witnessed it in the form of his life, belonged to this stock. They were the primary custodians of Christianity and had deeply embedded roots in the holy soil of as Jesus’ instructions and way of life. It was they who witnessed the as Crucifixion and had seen Jesus survive from his attempted murder. === PDF-Seite 160 === 132 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction

The First Followers of Jesus Early Christians appear to have been fundamentally divided over as both the nature of Jesus and whether to adhere to the Mosaic Law or not. In the second phase of Christian development, St Paul acquired the most pivotal character in giving Christianity a new philosophy and ideology. There were fundamental differ- ences of opinion between Paul and James the Righteous. While James looked after the Jerusalem Church, Paul was preaching in the West, particularly to the gentiles. The Western Church evolved along Pauline doctrinal lines, whereas the Church in Jerusalem developed along monotheistic teachings. One offshoot of James’ ministry was the Ebionites, a sect whose name derives from the Hebrew ebionim meaning ‘the meek’ or as ‘the poor’. They were the Jewish Christians, for whom Jesus took on the mantle of Messiah and not that of the ‘Son of God’. They followed the Mosaic law with great zeal, and had their own Gospel known in various contexts as the ‘Gospel of the Hebrews’, ‘Gospel of the Ebionites’ or the ‘Gospel of the Nazare- nes’. Here is a description of the Ebionites drawn from various sources. In his book ‘The History of the Church’ written in the 4th cen- tury AD in Caesarea, Eusebius mentions the Ebionites in Book 3, Vespasian to Trajan. He mocks at their views, saying that their as name comes from their poor and mean opinion of Jesus . The as Ebionites regarded Jesus as mortal and esteemed him as righteous through the growth of his character. As Jews, they observed the Sabbath, and every detail of the Law, and did not accept the === PDF-Seite 161 === The Evolution of Christianity 133

Pauline idea of salvation through faith alone. He also talks of another group of Ebionites who accepted the virgin birth and the as Holy Spirit, but refused to accept Jesus’ pre-existence as ‘God the Word and Wisdom’. They followed a ‘Gospel of the Hebrews’ which could possibly have been St Matthew’s Gospel. They observed the Sabbath and Jewish system, but celebrated the * resurrection. R. Eisenman and M. Wise while describing the background of Ebionites in their book The Dead Sea Scrolls Uncovered (1992) say that James (the ‘Zaddik’ or ‘Zadok’, meaning Righteous) was the leader of the Jerusalem Church in the middle of the first century (40–60 AD approx.). The branch was retrospectively called Jewish Christianity in Palestine. The Ebionites developed from this branch.• The Community who followed James were known as ‘the Poor’, (Galatians 2:10, James 2:3–5) a designation mentioned both in the Sermon on the Mount and in the Dead Sea Scrolls. In many ways, Eisenman feels that the Ebionites were similar to the authors of the Dead Sea Scrolls. They honoured James the Right- as eous, and believed Jesus to be their mortal Messiah, while Paul had become an Apostate for the Law. They observed the Law and

·

10 of 10 left today