Cover Page

Christianity - A Journey from Facts to Fiction, Part 7

concept of Sin and Atonement and the crimes committed daily. However much they may be removed from Christian values in their practice, at least this much goes to their credit that they do believe in the Christian doctrine of Sin and Redemption and also as in Christ as their saviour, but alas, to what avail. The majority of the criminals in America, of course, are so-called Christians. Though Muslims and others are no exception. Just because of all such criminals who belong to Christianity and believe in the as reported voluntary sacrifice of Jesus Christ for the sake of the believing sinners, will they all be pardoned by God? If so, in what way? Ultimately, a sizeable percentage from among them may get caught and get punished by the law of the land, but still a large number would either remain unapprehended or may only be punished for a part of the crimes which they may have committed over many years. What would Christianity offer to those who are punished by law and what would it promise those who remain unapprehended here on earth? Will both be punished to varying degrees, or will they be punished indiscriminately? Another dilemma relating to a criminal’s redemption because of as his belief in Jesus Christ arises out of a less clear and undefined situation. If, for instance, a Christian commits a crime against an innocent non-Christian victim, he would be forgiven of course as because of the blessings of his faith in Jesus . The punishment of as his crime will then be transferred to the account of Jesus instead. But what would be the profit and loss statement of the poor as innocent non-Christian victim? Poor Jesus and the poor victim, both being punished for a crime they did not commit. === PDF-Seite 62 === 34 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction

Our faculties are confounded if we try to imagine the enormity of all the crimes ever committed by humanity since the dawn of Christianity till the time when the sun of existence sets on human life. Have all these crimes been transferred to the account of Jesus as Christ , peace and blessing of Allah be upon him? Have all these sins been accounted for in the small space of the three days and as three nights that Jesus is supposed to have suffered? Still one keeps on wondering, how could the vast sea of criminals so intensely embittered by the deadly poison of crime be sweetened and cleansed entirely of the effects of their crimes by the mere act as of their believing in Jesus . Again, one’s thoughts are carried back to the remote past, when poor Adam and Eve so naively commit- ted their first crime only because they were very cunningly duped and ensnared by Satan. Why was their sin not also washed clean? Did they not have faith in God? Was it a minor act of goodness to have faith in God the Father and was it their fault anyway that they had never been told of a ‘Son’ living eternally with God the Father? Why did not the ‘Divine Son’ take pity on them and beseech God the Father to punish him for their crimes instead? How one wishes that that had happened, since it might have been so much easier to be punished only for that one single faltering moment on the part of Adam and Eve. The entire story of hu- manity would certainly have been rewritten in the book of fate. A heavenly earth would have been created instead and Adam and Eve would not have been banished eternally from heaven along as with the untold number of their unhappy progeny. Jesus alone would have been banished from heaven merely for three days and three nights and that would have been that. Sadly, neither God === PDF-Seite 63 === Sin and Atonement 35

as as the Father nor Jesus thought of this. Look how Jesus’ holy, lovable reality is unfortunately transformed into a bizarre and unbelievable myth.

Justice and Forgiveness The Christian philosophy of Crime and Punishment is not only utterly confusing for simple unprejudiced human intellect, but also raises many other relevant questions which are no less per- plexing. The philosophy of relationship between justice and forgiveness, as maintained by the Christian philosophy of Atone- ment, attempts to explain why God Himself could not forgive. It is dependant entirely on an erroneous and arbitrary concept of justice, which takes it for granted that justice and forgiveness can never go hand in hand. That being so, why does the New Testa- ment place so much emphasis on forgiveness when the question of human relationships is discussed? I have never read in any divine scriptures of any world religion a teaching that leans more one sidedly, and more overly emphasises the role of forgiveness. What a fantastic contrast with the traditional emphasis on justice found in Judaic teachings. An eye for an eye; a tooth for a tooth. That is justice—pure, simple and unattenuated. What a dramatic departure from this to the Christian teaching of turning the other cheek if slapped on one. Who gave the latter teaching which is against the earlier teachings of the Torah? Was the first teaching of the Torah, one is left wondering, a teaching by God the Father as against the diametrically opposed teaching of the New Testa- as ment, a teaching by Christ the ‘Divine Son’? If so, why did the === PDF-Seite 64 === 36 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction

‘Divine Son’ differ so drastically from his Father? Should such a conflict be taken as a genetical defect or an evolutionary change or was this Christian attitude of absolute forgiveness, as diametri- cally opposed to the Judaic emphasis on revenge, an example of a change on the part of God the Father? He seems to have dearly as repented of what He had taught Moses and the people of the Book and seems to have wanted very much to redress His own wrong. As Muslims, we observe this fundamental shift in emphasis and see no contradiction because we believe in a God who combines in Him both the attributes of justice and forgiveness, without there being any inner conflict between the two attributes. We understand the transfer from Judaic teachings to those of Jesus as Christ , not as a corrective measure of the original teachings but of their misapplication by the Jews. According to our belief, God is not only Just but is also Forgiving, Merciful and Beneficent. If He so desires, He does not stand in need of any outside help to forgive the sinful. But from the Christian point of view the problem acquires gigantic proportions. It appears that the God of the Torah was a God who knew only justice and had no sense of compassion or mercy. Apparently He was unable to forgive, however much He may have desired to do so. Lo, then came to His help ‘God the Son’ and extricated Him from His infernal dilemma. It seems that the ‘Son’ was ‘All-Compassionate’ as against the ‘All-Vengefulness’ of his Father. It is not just the apparent absurdity of this vision of the ‘Son’ which disturbs the human conscience. It also raises the question once again of the === PDF-Seite 65 === Sin and Atonement 37

as contradiction in their characters. Jesus does not appear to be a true son of his Father, a genetic error again perhaps. Another important area of inquiry is the attitude of other relig- ions of the world towards sin and its consequences. Christianity is of course not the only religion to be a revealed religion. Numeri- cally, non-Christians largely exceed Christians. Thousands of years as of the known history of man, before Jesus Christ , saw many religions born and take root in different human soils in various parts of the world. Do these religions ever speak of a philosophy of forgiveness even remotely related to the Christian dogma of Atonement? What is their concept of God, or gods if they have now begun to believe in many? What is their concept of God’s attitude towards sinful humanity? Among the community of religions, the nearest to Christianity is perhaps Hinduism in this regard, but it is only partially so. Hindus also believe in an Absolute Just God, whose sense of justice demands that He must punish somehow every perpetrator of sin. But the resemblance ends there. No mention of a ‘Divine Son’ taking the entire consequences of the whole world of sinners upon his shoulders is even remotely indicated. On the contrary, we are told of an endless chain of crime and punishment in an endless number of reincarnations of the soul into animal flesh. Atonement only becomes accessible after the many times reincar- nated soul has incurred punishment exactly the sum total of the crimes it committed during all its fateful experiences of reincarna- tion. To some it may sound weird and bizarre indeed, but there is certainly some inherent justice in this philosophy. There is a === PDF-Seite 66 === 38 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction

balance and symmetry in this view which is in perfect harmony with the concept of absolute justice. Leaving aside Hinduism and other religions who advocate the philosophy of reincarnation with all its complexities of cause and effect, what is the role of forgiveness on the part of God in the remaining major or minor religions of the world? All such relig- ions, and over a billion adherents of religions such as Hinduism, seem to be totally ignorant and uninformed of the myth of Atonement. This is very perplexing indeed. Who was in com- munion with mankind elsewhere in the history of religions? If it was not God the Father as in Christian doctrine, was the entire as religious leadership of the world, except Jesus Christ , a pupil of the Devil himself? And where was God the Father? Why did He not come to the rescue when the rest of mankind was being led astray by the Devil in His name? Or were they, the rest of the humanity, a creation of a being other than the so-called God the Father? Again, why were they treated in such a step-fatherly way and abandoned to the cruel sway of the Devil? Let us now turn our attention to this issue with reference to common human experience. It can be shown that forgiveness and justice are balanced and can coexist and do not always contradict each other. Sometimes justice demands that forgiveness must be extended, and sometimes it demands that forgiveness should be withheld. If a child is forgiven and is encouraged to commit more crime, then forgiveness is itself bordering on a crime and is against the sense of justice. If a criminal is forgiven, only to perpetrate more acts of crime and create suffering all around him because he is forgiven and encouraged, that would also be against the dictates === PDF-Seite 67 === Sin and Atonement 39

of justice and would be tantamount to an act of cruelty to other innocent citizens. There are countless criminals of this type who as are covered by the atonement of Jesus . That in itself is contrary to justice. But if a child repents, for instance, and the mother is convinced that the same crime will not be repeated, then to punish the child would be counter to the sense of justice. When a repentant person suffers, that in itself is a punishment which may in some cases far exceed a punishment imposed from outside. People with a living conscience always suffer after committing a sin. As a consequence, the cumulative effect of the repeated pangs of conscience reaches a point where it may result in God taking pity on such a weak, oft-faltering, oft-repenting servant of His. This is the lesson in the relationship of justice to forgiveness, which people of high intellect and even people of ordinary understanding draw alike from a universal human experience. It is high time that Christians woke up from their dormant state of accepting Christian dogma without ever questioning its wisdom. If they re-examine Christian doctrine in the light of common sense and reasoning, they may still remain good practising Chris- tians, but of a different and more realistic type. They would then believe even more, and with greater love and dedication in the as as human reality of Christ as compared to the Christ who is a mere figment of their imagination and no more real than fiction. The as greatness of Jesus lies not in his legend but in the supreme as sacrifice of Jesus the man and messenger. His was a sacrifice which moves the heart far more powerfully and profoundly than the myth of his death upon a cross and his revival from the dead after spending a few ghastly hours in hell. === PDF-Seite 68 === 40 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction

Jesus Cannot Possibly Atone as Last but not least, how could Jesus be born innocent when he had a human mother? If the sin of Adam and Eve had polluted the entire progeny of this unfortunate couple, then as a natural consequence, all male and female children must inherit the same genetic propensity to sin. Females were perhaps more likely to, because it was Eve who, as the instrument of Satan, enticed Adam. Therefore, the responsibility of sin falls squarely on the shoulders of Eve rather than of Adam. In the case of the birth of as Christ , obviously it was a daughter of Eve who contributed the major share. The question that very forcefully arises is whether as Jesus inherited any gene bearing chromosomes from his human mother or not. If he did, then it was impossible for him to escape the inevitable inherited sin. If he did not inherit any chromo- somes from his mother or from God the Father, then indeed his birth would be doubly miraculous. Only a miracle can produce a son who neither belongs to his father nor to his mother. What remains incomprehensible is why those chromosomes, provided by Eve, did not carry the innate tendency to sin to the child as as Jesus . Suppose it happened somehow, and Jesus had that inno- cence needed to carry the sins of mankind, on the condition that they believed in him and not otherwise, then another problem would arise: what happened, one may ask, to the progeny of Adam and Eve that died before the dawn of Christianity? How many billions of them might have got scattered throughout the world over five continents generation after generation. They must have lived and died without hope or even the possibility of ever === PDF-Seite 69 === Sin and Atonement 41

as hearing about the Christ their Saviour who was not yet born. In as fact, the entire humanity between Adam and Christ seemed certainly to be doomed forever. Why were they never given even a remote chance to be forgiven? Would they be forgiven retro- as spectively, by Jesus Christ ? If so, why? In other parts of the world, much larger by comparison to the tiny land of Judea, where people had never heard of Christianity as even during the lifetime of Jesus Christ , what happens to them? They never did, nor ever could, believe in the ‘Sonship’ of Jesus as Christ . Will their sins go unpunished or will they be punished? If they go unpunished, for what reason? If they are punished, again by what logic? What chance did they have anyway? They were totally helpless. What a distorted sense of absolute justice!

Unwilling Sacrifice Now let us turn to the act of Crucifixion itself. Here we are as confronted with another insoluble dilemma. Jesus , as we are so insistently told, offered himself voluntarily to God the Father and was made the scapegoat for the sins of all humanity, provided, of course, they believed in him. But when the time of the accep- tance of his wish approaches nigh and at last the glimmer of hope for sinful humanity is beginning to appear like the dawn of a new as day, as we turn to Jesus expecting to observe his joy, his happi- ness and his ecstasy at this most eventful moment of human history, how profoundly disappointed and manifestly disillusioned as we are. Instead of finding a Jesus impatiently awaiting the hour as of jubilation what we see instead is a Jesus weeping and crying === PDF-Seite 70 === 42 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction

and praying and beseeching God the Father to take away the bitter cup of death from him. He severely reproached one of his disciples when he caught him in the act of dozing off after spend- ing such a fateful long day and suffering through a dark gloomy night which bade ill for him and his holy master. The Biblical account of this incident goes as follows:

Then Jesus went with them to a place called Gethsem´ane, and he said to his disciples, "Sit here, while I go yonder and pray." And taking with him Peter and the two sons of Zeb´edee, he began to be sorrowful and troubled. Then he said to them, "My soul is very sorrowful, even to death; remain here, and watch with me." And going a little farther he fell on his face and prayed, "My father, if it be possible, let this cup pass from me; nevertheless, not as I will, but as thou wilt." And he came to the disciples and found them sleeping; and he said to Peter, "So, could you not watch with me one hour? Watch and pray that you may not enter into temptation; the spirit indeed is willing, but the flesh is weak." Again, for the second time, he went away and prayed, "My Father, if this cannot pass unless I drink it, thy will be done." And again he came and found them sleeping, for their eyes were heavy. So, leaving them again, he went away and prayed for the third time, saying the same words. (Matt 26:36–44)

·

10 of 10 left today