Cover Page

Christianity - A Journey from Facts to Fiction, Part 8

Alas, as the Christian story unveils itself, the prayers and be- as seeching of neither Jesus nor his disciples were accepted by God the Father and willy-nilly, despite his strong protestations, he was at last crucified. Was he the same person, the same prince of === PDF-Seite 71 === Sin and Atonement 43

innocence and paragon of sacrifice who so bravely volunteered himself to take the burden of all of mankind’s sins on his shoul- ders, or was it a different person? His conduct, both at the hour of the Crucifixion and during the Crucifixion itself, strongly casts as shadow of doubt, either on the identity of Jesus Christ or on the truth of the myth spun around his person. But of that later. Let us now return to our critical examination where we left it off. Some other questions which arise from the last cry of agony by as Jesus Christ are as follows: Who uttered those deeply pathetic as as and touching words? Was it Jesus the man or was it Jesus the ‘Son’? as If it was Jesus the man who was abandoned, by whom he was abandoned and why? If we accept this option, it would also have as to be taken for granted that till the last, Jesus the man retained a single independent identity which could think and feel freely and individually. Did he die at the moment of the parting of the soul as of Jesus the ‘Son of God’ from the body of the man he had occupied? If so, why and how? If it was so and it was the body of the man which died after the soul of God deserted it, then the question would arise as to who got revived from the dead when the soul of God revisited the same body later on. Again, this option would lead us to believe that it was not Je- as as sus the ‘Son’ who was suffering but the person of Jesus the man who cried out in such agony and he was the one who suffered as while Jesus the ‘Son’ looked on in a state of total indifference and apathy. Then how can he justify the claim that it was he, the ‘Son,’ who suffered for the sake of humanity and not the man in him? === PDF-Seite 72 === 44 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction

as The other option is that we presume it was Jesus the ‘Son’ who cried out, while the man in him, perhaps hopeful to begin a new life for himself, watched on in the uncertain expectation that as as along with the sacrifice of Jesus the ‘Son’, he, Jesus the man, whether he liked it or not, would also be slaughtered on the altar of his innocent cohabiter. What sense of justice ever motivated God to kill two birds with the same stone is perhaps another mystery. as If it was Jesus the ‘Son’, and it was him indeed according to the general consensus of Christian churches, then the second question arising out of the answer of the first would be about the as identity of the second party involved in that monologue of Jesus (Matt 26:39,42). We have two options open to us: One, that the ‘Son’ was addressing the Father, complaining that he was abandoned in the hour of need. This inescapably leads us to believe that they were two different persons who did not coexist in a single mutually merged personality, equally sharing all attributes and putting them into play simultaneously with equal share. One appears to be the supreme arbiter, the all powerful possessor of the ultimate faculty of taking decisions. The other, the poor ‘Son,’ seems to be entirely deprived or maybe temporar- ily dispossessed of all the domineering characters which his Father enjoys. The central point which must be kept in focus is the fact that their opposite wills and wishes nowhere seem more at odds and at variance with each other than they do during the last act of the Crucifixion drama. The second question is, would these two distinct persons, with individual thoughts, individual values and individual capacities, === PDF-Seite 73 === Sin and Atonement 45

feel pain and agony if they were ‘two in one’ and ‘one in two?’ So another question would require many a long dialogue between theologians regarding the possibility of God being able to suffer pain and punishment. Even if He were able to do so, only half of God would suffer while the other half would be incapable of doing so either by design or by the compulsion of His nature. As we proceed further in the shadowy world of this twisted philosophy, light begins to get dimmer and dimmer and we find confusion heaped upon confusion. Another problem is, whom as was Christ addressing if he was God himself? When he addressed his father, he himself was an inseparable part of the Father, so we are told. So what was he saying and to whom? This question must be answered with a free conscience, without resorting to dogma. It becomes a dogma only when it cannot be explained in human as terms. According to the Biblical statement, when Jesus was about to give up the ghost, he cried addressing God the Father: "why hast thou forsaken me?" (Matt 27:46) Who had forsaken whom? Had God forsaken God?

Who Was Sacrificed? The other problem we have to take note of is that the man in as Jesus was not punished, nor by any logic should he have been punished, because he had never opted to carry the load of human- ity’s sin. This new element, entering into the debate, leads us to a very peculiar situation which we have not considered before. One is compelled to wonder about the relationship of the man in as Jesus with the inherited propensity to commit sin, common to all === PDF-Seite 74 === 46 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction

the progeny of Adam and Eve. At best one can bring oneself to believe that in the duality of the ‘Divine Son’ and the man occupying the same body, it was only the ‘Divine Son’ who was innocent. But what about the man living alongside him? Was he also born out of genes and character provided by God? If so, then as he should behave like the divine in Jesus and no excuse would be acceptable if he went remiss in this or that, with the plea that he only did so because he was a man. If there was nothing of God in as him, that is, in the man in Jesus , then we must concede that he was simply an ordinary human being, perhaps half a human being. as Yet that human person, amalgamated with Jesus , has to be human enough to inherit the disposition to sin. If not, why not? Obviously there is no gain in saying that being a man distinctly separate from his divine partner, he must have sinned independ- ently with the entire responsibility of sin upon his human shoul- as ders. This scenario will not be complete without presenting Jesus the ‘Son of God’ dying, not so unselfishly after all, for the sake of humanity, but his prime concern might have been for his half brother, the man in him. All this is extremely difficult, if not impossible, to digest intel- lectually. But our point of view presents no such problems. It was as the innocent person Jesus the man, without there being any duality in him, who uttered this cry of astonishment and agony.

The Dilemma of Jesus as Let me once again make it clear that I do not disbelieve in Jesus but have profound respect for him as a messenger of God with === PDF-Seite 75 === Sin and Atonement 47

as exceptional sacrifices to his credit. I understand Jesus to be a holy man, going through a period of great trial. But as the narration of the act of Crucifixion begins to unfold and comes to a close we as are left with no choice but to believe that Jesus did not volunteer himself for death upon the cross. The night before the day his enemies attempted to murder him by crucifixion we hear him praying all night, along with his disciples, because the truth of his claim was at stake. It is said in the Old Testament that an impos- tor, who attributes things to God which He had never said, would hang on a tree and die upon it an accursed death.

But the prophet who presumes to speak a word in my name which I have not commanded him to speak, or who speaks in the name of other gods, that same prophet shall die. (Deuteronomy 18:20)

And if a man has committed a crime punishable by death and he is put to death, and you hang him on a tree, his body shall not remain all night upon the tree, but you shall bury him the same day, for a hanged man is accursed by God;… (Deuteronomy 21:22–23) as Jesus knew that if this happened, the Jews would celebrate with ecstasy and proclaim him to be an impostor whose falsehood had finally been proved beyond a shadow of doubt on the author- ity of the Divine Scriptures. This was the reason why he was so anxious to escape the bitter cup of death; not out of cowardice, but out of fear that his people would be misled and would fail to recognise his truth if he died upon the cross. All night he prayed so piteously and helplessly that to read the account of his agony and misery is heart rending. But as this real life drama proceeds to === PDF-Seite 76 === 48 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction

a close, the climax of his emotional distress, dejection and hope- lessness is fully displayed in his last cry: "Eli, Eli, la´ma sabach- tha´ni?" that is, "My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?" (Matt 27:46) One must notice that it was not agony alone expressed in that cry but obviously there was mingled with it an element of sur- prise, bordering on horror. After he was brought back to consciousness, with the help of some of his dedicated disciples who applied to his wounds an ointment they had prepared before Crucifixion and which con- tained all the ingredients needed for mitigating pain and healing wounds, he must have been so wonderfully and happily surprised and his faith in a loving true God would have been reinstated and revitalised in a manner seldom experienced by man in its intensity and boundlessness. The fact that the ointment had been prepared in advance con- as stitutes a strong proof that Jesus’ disciples were indeed expecting him to be delivered from the cross alive, very much in need of medicinal treatment. From the above, it becomes comfortingly clear that the con- cepts of Inherited Sin and of Crucifixion are based only on the conjecture and wishful thinking of Christian theologians at a later date. It is quite likely that they were born out of some pre- Christian myths of a similar nature, which, when applied to the as circumstances of Jesus Christ , tempted them to read close simi- larities between the two and create a similar myth. However, whatever the mystery or paradox, as we see it, there is no evi- dence whatsoever that the Christian philosophy of Sin and === PDF-Seite 77 === Sin and Atonement 49

as Atonement was based on anything which Jesus might have said or done or taught. He could never have preached anything so contrary, and so diametrically opposed, to human intellect.

Did God the Father Suffer as Well? Coming to the nature of the ‘Son’, we cannot believe that he was thrown into Hell Fire, as that would mean an internal contradic- tion with himself. Returning to the basic concept of Christianity we see that it is said that God and the ‘Son’ are two persons but of the same nature and substance. It is impossible for one to go through an experience while the other does not share in it. How can we believe that one aspect of God, the ‘Son’, was being tormented, while God the Father remained unscathed? If He did not suffer, it would be tantamount to breaking the Unity of God. Three persons in one becomes even more inconceivable because the experiences of each constituent of Trinity have turned out to be so different and remote from each other that it appears impos- sible for one God to be in the raging fire of hell, and at the same time the other to remain perfectly aloof and untouched. There is no other choice for the Christians of today but either to sacrifice the Unity of God and believe in three different Gods, like the pagans of pre-Christianity such as the Romans and the Greeks, or to remain true to themselves and believe that God is one and as such, two aspects of God cannot undergo contradictory states. When a child suffers, it is impossible for the mother to remain calm and peaceful. She must suffer as well, sometimes more than the child. What was happening to God the Father when He made === PDF-Seite 78 === 50 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction

His ‘Son’ suffer the agony of three days in hell? What was hap- pening to God the ‘Son’? Was he divided into two persons, with two forms and substances? One form suffering in hell and the other completely outside, not suffering at all? If God the Father was suffering then what was the need of creating the Son, when He himself could have suffered? So this is a very direct question. Why did He not just suffer Himself? Why draw out such a difficult plan to resolve the problem of forgiveness?

The Punishment of Fire Here, the question of hell to which, according to the Christian as doctrine, Jesus was confined, should be examined more closely. What sort of hell was it, Was it the same hell we read about in the New Testament, which says:

·

10 of 10 left today