The Conclusive Argument
In the name of Allah, the
Gracious, the Merciful.
All praise belongs to Allah, who establishes His argument in every age, revives His Faith at all times, and sends a Reformer at the time of every disorder. Guides for people come from Him, one after another.
He bestows benevolence upon His servants by showing them the straight path and paves the way for eager souls. Through His Book, He leads people to His secrets, but reason is not permitted to unravel His mysteries. He bestows His revelation upon whomsoever He pleases from among His servants and opens the doors of His guidance for whomsoever He pleases. Hence, no filth can adhere to such a person nor can any peer compete with him. God admits him among the pure ones. He grants acceptance to whomsoever He pleases and rejects whomsoever He wishes. He frustrates the plans of whomsoever He desires and grants His magnificent bounties to whomsoever He pleases. He places His message where He wills, and He knows best who is the most entitled to, and worthy of it. All people are astray except those whom He guides and all are dead except those whom He gives life. All are blind except those to whom He grants sight; all are starved except those whom He nourishes; and all are thirsty except those to whom He brings water. One who is not guided by Him cannot be from among the guided.
Peace and blessings be upon His Messenger and His chosen one, Muhammad, Khairur-Rusul [the Best of the Messengers] and Khatamun-Nabiyyin [the Seal of the Prophets]. He brought shining light and saved creation from the destructive darkness. He delivered the wayfarers from the hardships of the path and supplied them with abundant provisions. He bestowed pure scriptures analogous to a pure tree, whose fresh fruit nourishes every seeker after truth. All who had sound natures inclined towards acquiring its blessings, and nobody remained deprived [of these fortunes] except the eternally unfortunate and hapless one.
And peace be upon his pure progeny, whose light illumined the entire earth and whose advent manifested the truth. Indeed, they were the full moons of imamat [the office of an Imam] and mountains of the paths of steadfastness. Nobody bears them enmity except those who are accursed and misguided. May Allah shower mercy upon the one who combines the love of them with the love of all Companions. And peace be upon his Companions and his pure devotees who followed him even more faithfully than his shadow and were more obedient to him than his shoes.
Having witnessed his rubies, they forsook the glory and splendour of this world. They committed themselves to obey every command with sincere submission and natural goodness. Notwithstanding the adverse circumstances, they strove in the way of Allah and did not sit back idly. They chose to completely devote themselves to Allah, accumulating the treasures of the hereafter while taking nothing whatsoever from the wealth of the world. They did not incline to amass worldly provisions. They spent their lives in the propagation of the Faith and followed in the footsteps of the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, so much so that their [independent] selves died.
They sold their souls to win the pleasure of their Benevolent Lord and for His sake they were content to part with their households and dear friends. They turned their eyes away from the world and its affairs and were pulled by a mighty attraction that drew them towards Allah, Rabbul- ‘alamin [the Lord of all the worlds].
To proceed, know that Islamic brotherhood demands sincere advice and truthfulness. A person who is bestowed with some knowledge and then conceals it like a closely guarded secret is a traitor. There is no end to the subtleties of knowledge, and its verities are countless. There is no hindrance to their disclosure, nor are there dark nights for their full moons. There are many fields of knowledge left for the people of the Latter Days. The truth is that my Lord has taught me many a mystery and granted me knowledge about the unseen. He has commissioned me as the Mujaddid [Reformer] of this century and chosen me to receive liberally and abundantly of His knowledge and made me an heir to His Messengers.
It is by the grace of His teaching and through the gift of understanding bestowed by Him that [I have learned that] the Messiah, Jesus son of Mary, died a natural death and passed away just as his other fellow Messengers passed away. Allah gave me glad tidings and said:
‘The Promised Messiah whom they are looking forward to and the blessed Mahdi whom they are awaiting, is none other than you. We do whatever We please. Be not, therefore, of those who doubt.’
He also said: ‘We made you the Messiah, son of Mary.’ Thus He broke the seal of His secret and informed me of the mysteries of this matter. These revelations occurred with such frequency and these glad tidings were given so regularly that I became fully convinced. Then I chose the path of care and discretion and turned my attention towards the Book of Allah that guards the pathways of peace, and discovered it to be the first witness to this. And what could be clearer than His statement:
cause you to die’]? So, reflect! May Allah guide you before you die and make you among those endowed with insight.
God Almighty confirmed [the death of Jesus] with His statement:
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
[‘When You caused me ( Jesus) to die’]. So ponder over it O ye who harasses me and counts me among the disbelievers! This is a definitive verse, which no opponent can deny by appealing to any tradition [hadith] nor can it be targeted by any opponent’s arrow. No one can reject it except the transgressors. The people whose milk of thought has been exhausted and whose vision is weak and shortsighted fail to ponder over the Book of Allah and its explicit arguments. They wander about like the one who follows his own ignorance, and they talk like mad men. They say that the word التوفّي [at-tawaffi—cause to die] was not employed for any particular meaning; rather, it has general connotations with no solid foundations. Thus, they deceive like the impostors. And when they are informed that wherever this word occurs throughout the Holy Qur’an—the Book of Allah the Gracious—it only means the causing of death and the seizing of souls which are bound to return [to Allah]—not of physical bodies—how, then, do they insist upon meanings that are not supported by the Book of Allah or by statements from Khairul-Mursalin [the Best of Messengers], peace and blessings of Allah be upon him? In reply to this they say that they found their forefathers upon this belief and they will never forsake it.
When they are told that Khatamun-Nabiyyin [the Seal of the Prophets s (as) ] and the Most Truthful of the Exegetes interpreted the word التوفّي [at-tawaffi—cause to die] in the same sense in explaining this verse—i.e. ْيِنَتْيَّفَوَت —as it is not hidden from men of knowledge; and that Ibn Abbas followed him in order to dispel such doubts, saying thatَكْيِّفَوَتُم [mutawaffika—will cause you to die] means َ مُمِیْتُك [mumituka—give you death], then why do they abandon the meanings established by the most infallible of Prophets and his paternal cousin who was among those who hold correct beliefs and are rightly guided? They reply, ‘How can we accept it when our forefathers did not hold this belief ?’ What they say is nothing but transgression, falsehood, and deception. They did not encompass the views of the predecessors of the ummah, except those of the misguided people who were close to them. They followed
only those who had already gone astray from among Faij A‘waj 1 and were among the deprived ones, and they continued to follow their sayings until the truth became manifest so that some of them repented in remorse. But