The Conclusive Argument
Part 5
the ulema, and have goodwill for the well-wishers.
However, you will not demand a single penny except after the testimony of the arbitrators. And as for the verdict, it will be passed by two arbitrators after submitting the amount. I entrust this matter to you and grant you complete authority over its particulars. Even if you appoint two dishonest arbitrators, I will accept them wholeheartedly and will overlook their falsehood and lies. However, I will put both arbitrators under God Almighty’s oath, requiring them to swear in public that they have spoken the truth. Then I will grant them respite for one year. During that period, I will engage in offering supplications before God, the All-Aware, the All-Knowing. And if during this period a manifest Sign of the acceptance of prayer is not shown, then God Almighty is my Witness that I will, without any doubt or misgiving, admit your truthfulness and count you among the truthful.
I wonder why you took to writing this book and what novel and extraordinary things you have written in it. [The truth is that] you have merely collected the refuse of worthless people and replicated the follies of the ignorant. Everything that you have said had been said before you and was tarnished by ignorance even greater than yours. You have not said anything from yourself; you have only plagiarized the works of the ignorant. I find such expressions in your book that smell like rotten fish and stink like a putrid carcass, and I find them to be full of petty and hollow artificialities and the laughing stock of people. You have done all this just to snatch loaves of bread from mosques and to achieve the approbation of the people like the one overpowered by his passions, and not for the sake of God, the Lord of the worlds. O ye who abandoned the truth and lied! You have cast aside the Holy Qur’an; you know nothing but mad ravings and walk like the blind, and you know nothing except walking the paths of falsehood and running wild in the streets of mischief.
You fear not the claws of the lion and wander like the blind and the one-eyed. I have exposed your darkness and torn your writing to shreds, and you will soon realize it. Do you, like the ignorant and shameless, believe that Jesus is alive, and consider him to be exempt from the dead? You have not offered any evidence from the bayyinat [clear and perspicuous verses in the Holy Qur’an] and muhkamat [explicit and decisive verses] nor from any ahadith of the Best of Creation which possess numerous uninterrupted chains. And so—O ye whose speech is in vain!—you lied in order to establish your claim and deviated from the fundamentals of Islamic law. O reckless ignoramus! O reproached miscreant! Pause and think seriously with reason. You have not advanced any argument in favour of your claim regarding Jesus’ life. You have simply followed conjectures—nay, rather, superstitions. The conclusion of a problem cannot exceed its premises. When two premises are hypothetical, their conclusion will also be speculative, as is not hidden from those who possess sight. If you cannot comprehend these profundities and are not cognizant of their truths, then ask those who possess profound wisdom and deep insight. If you cannot see your conduct with your eyes, then see it through the eyes of others; if you are deprived of rain, then seek it from the clouds of others. O wretched one! Do you not realize that your words contradict the manifest arguments of the Holy Qur’an and are against its muhkamat? The meaning of التوفّي [at-tawaffi—cause to die] has been expounded clearly by the Chief of All Men and Prophet of All Jinn [the Holy Prophet s (as)], and by his wise and insightful Companions. Then what value can be accorded to the meanings used by the common folk when compared to the one defined explicitly by the Best of Creation ? Who can deny these meanings except the sinful?
Repent for the disregard you have shown towards Allah and His bayyinat. You have followed the mutashabihat [verses in the Holy Qur’an susceptible to different interpretations] and have neglected the muhkamat. You attacked like one unbridled and have abandoned the truth like the idolaters. I reviewed your book from time to time and found it dancing like a chanteuse; by God, this book is devoid of truth and full of the deceptions of Dajjal [the Antichrist]. Therefore, you must immediately pay this amount in cash so that I may expose to you your falsehood and teach you a lesson. It is also incumbent upon you to submit money to a trustworthy person who is a reliable guarantor. Or else, how can I believe that I will get your prize money after having disproved your claim and demonstrated your wretchedness? O poverty-stricken one! You are not among the wealthy but among the helpless, ignorant ones. So, give up your insolent nature and deposit the said amount and keep away from the paths of deception and abandon excuses. If you are truthful and a seeker of truth, well and good, but if you turn away from it, and are a cheat, then shame on you! I have conveyed this admonition to the fullest degree, and have enquired like one who seeks a wise guide and reveals the straight paths. I have perfectly conveyed the message for the sake of Allah the One. Now I will see whether you submit the prize money and abide by your promise and faith, or betray your word and follow Satan, like the corrupt.
I swear by God, who causes rain to fall from the clouds and brings forth fruit from calyces, that I have come forward to take up the challenge not in hope of any reward, but only to humiliate the miscreants so that the truth may be revealed and the path of the guilty be exposed.
Verily, Allah the Almighty is with the righteous, and God, who endowed man with reason and intellect, is my Witness, that you have perpetrated an abominable deed and left a bad name behind you. I already published an announcement before this in which I solemnly promised a prize for those who would respond to it, but not a single one of them came forward to answer it. They were speechless like beasts and animals. Dumbfounded and stunned, their muscles were quivering incessantly with fear and they fell on their faces in shame.
Do you know more than all those people, or are you insane? They were far cleverer in discourse than you; you are a mere novice by comparison. Ultimately, their end was humiliation, disgrace, and the wrath of the Lord of the worlds. When Allah decides to humiliate a people, they begin to harbour enmity towards His Auliya’
[Friends], hurt His loved ones, and curse His chosen ones. Then
God comes forward to confront them for war and turns their faces away with a single blow and renders them helpless. Do you not ponder over their fate?
Surely God sends me every kind
of help and He is visiting the land, reducing it from its outlying borders. He protects me with His gracious hands and shields me in the blankets of His support so that no plot of the wicked can harm me. He knows
who belongs to Him and who does not. He keeps watch over the movement of every one who walks. He does not guide transgressors and destroys the sinful people and erases the names of the liars from the face of the
earth. He is Most Jealous for
His honour and is the Avenger.
He is aware of the acts of mischievous evildoers and quickly apprehends the liars. And He sends down His chastisement faster than the blink of an eye.
O horde of the enemy! Repent like those who fear the wrath of God the Gracious and turn to Him before the day of loss, and who transform themselves in order to seek God’s pleasure. Seek [His] mercy because He is the Most Merciful of those who show mercy. O deluded one! Be ashamed of your ignorance and ask forgiveness for your transgressions. Ponder over your loss, your moral degradation, and your being exposed, and reproach yourself like those who fear.