Further Review of Maulawi Rusul Baba Amritsari’s Hayatul-Masih

The Conclusive Argument, Part 3

It seems that he, too, is convinced in his heart that his book has no substance. That is why, in order to hide this fact, he says at the end of the book that it will not be understood unless someone learns it from him by taking regular lessons. Why did he say so? Only because he knew that his book was empty noise, devoid of conclusive arguments, and those who possess any sense will surely come to know that it has no merit. So, by way of imposing an impossible condition, he said that the arguments he wrote are so hidden that not everyone can appreciate them and his tongue alone will remain the key to them. Unless someone stays at his residence for a period of time and learns this collection of rubbish in regular lessons from him as a disciple, it is not possible to gain anything worthwhile from these confused pages. O loudmouthed Maulawi! If your arguments are so hidden and concealed in darkness that they cannot demonstrate their existence like a living proof in your book, then why compose a book of such rubbish and absurdity at all? Since you knew that your arguments were so worthless and incoherent that they made no sense without your verbal gibberish, it was no use writing such a book. In fact, to call them arguments is inappropriate, shameful, and plain nonsense.

Although a thousand varieties of deceit take place in this treacherous world, rarely will anyone have heard of the deception employed by this Maulawi Rusul Baba; namely, that he established the condition that one must become his disciple and learn the book directly from him through regular lessons in order to understand his arguments. He must have felt certain within his heart that no wise man would ever accept the discipleship of an ignorant, stupid man and learn his satanic book in regular lessons from him in the hopes of understanding the arguments of the Messiah being alive, which are so deeply concealed within his book that the whole world could not see them nor discover them even after reading the book a thousand or a million times! They can be discerned only with the guidance of the writer, or else there is no hope of finding them until the Day of Judgement.

Readers! Have you ever heard of such a book whose arguments remain in the mind of the writer even after having been set down in the book? Unfortunately, such absurd trickery is found in our maulawis nowadays as affords the enemies [of Islam] the opportunity to mock and ridicule it. It is because of this that the scholars, divines, and true men of knowledge are turning their backs on these short-sighted and ignorant people, and coming to me. As far as the so-called maulawis are concerned, they cannot even write Urdu properly and are ignorant of the Holy Qur’an and the Hadith. Because of their blind following of their ancestors, they have become my bitter opponents, as if I killed one of their forefathers. They engage ceaselessly in abusing, ridiculing, and declaring me an infidel as if they are never going to die or be held accountable as to why they labelled Muslims as infidels. They are fighting God Almighty and are not backing away from opposition. However, it was necessary that the prophecy of the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, should also be fulfilled; namely, that when the Mahdi of the age—that is, the Promised Messiah—appears, the maulawis of the time will write edicts of disbelief against him. The Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, also says that those who write such edicts will be the most wicked ones in the world and there will be no wrongdoer like them on the face of the earth. They will never accept but with hypocrisy. Alas, these naive people do not understand this: how can someone be a disbeliever while speaking according to the words of God and His Messenger? Can anyone accept the assertion that the entirety of those thousands of divines and men of God—who for 1,300 years, i.e. up to these days, believed in the death of Jesus—are infidels? God forbid!—Imam Malik, may Allah be pleased with him, who taught millions of his followers this very teaching, would be an infidel, too. And—God forbid!—Imam Bukhari, who reserved a special chapter on the death of Jesus in his Sahih, would also be a disbeliever. Ibn Qayyim, too—who counted Jesus among the dead like Moses—would be a disbeliever. Moreover, all those who consider them Muslims would similarly become infidels. And the Mu‘tazilah, too, in their entirety would be infidels since they have all along believed that Jesus has, in fact, died.

O maulawis who have some sense of goodness, are you not going to die one day? In your pride and arrogance, you have declared the whole world to be infidels. God Almighty says that whoever greets you with as-salamu ‘alaikum [‘Peace be upon you’], do not say to him لَسۡتَ مُؤۡمِنٗا meaning that, do not consider him a disbeliever; he is a Muslim. Yet you have declared those who share all your religious beliefs as disbelievers. They follow the same qiblah and are averse to shirk [associating partners with God]. They regard obedience to the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, as the sole basis of salvation. They believe that those who turn their back upon him are accursed, damned, and the inmates of hell. O mischievous maulawis! Once you die you will know what fruit this wicked impetuosity of yours brings you. Have you torn open our heart to see whether it contains disbelief and not faith; that it is dark and not enlightened? Be patient, this world will not last long.

In your opinion, only certain mischievous maulawis, who are a disgrace for Islam, are Muslims while the rest of the world is kafir. Alas! How hard-hearted they have become! What veils have covered their hearts! O Lord, have mercy on this ummah and protect them from the evil of these maulawis; guide them if they are worthy of being guided or else wipe them off the face of the earth so that evil does not spread. In fact, they are not even maulawis; that is why I addressed their leader, the chief mischief-maker and mentor, Sheikh Muhammad Husain Batalavi, in my book Nurul-Haqq and challenged him to present the like of that book if he had any proficiency in Arabic, and obtain the prize money of 5,000 rupees. But the Sheikh paid no attention to it despite the fact that he is like a mentor to all these people and it is at his instigations that these lifeless corpses start moving.

I reiterate emphatically that the Sheikh and all his followers are just ignorant, foolish, and have no knowledge of the Arabic sciences. I wrote a commentary on Surah al-Fatihah in order to test these people. Although the book Nurul-Haqq was written with a view to testing the scholarship of the Christians, some of these [Muslim] opponents, namely, Sheikh Muhammad Husain Batalavi, and those who follow in his footsteps, like Miyań Rusul Baba etc.—who denounce me as an infidel, and who are slanderers and foul-mouthed—are not exempt from this address. It is evident from the revelation [that I have received] that no one from among the disbelievers and those who denounce me as a kafir will be able to write a rejoinder to the book Nurul-Haqq, for they are liars, impostors, fabricators, ignorant, and foolish.

If they do not regard my revelation as revelation and, due to their inner wickedness, consider it forgery or satanic suggestion on my part, then they must write a reply to my book Nurul-Haqq within the appointed time frame. If they are unable to do so, then my revelation stands proved. So, those who vindicated my revelation by demonstrating their inability and lack of knowledge have, in a way, accepted my claim. After this, their hostile gibberish is not worth listening to. I invite all Christian priests as well as Sheikh Muhammad Husain Batalavi, Maulawi Rusul Baba Amritsari, and all their companions to this contest and I have given them the time to accept this challenge until the end of June 1894. As for publishing a rejoinder, they will have three months from the day of accepting the challenge.

Then, if they make no request by the end of June 1894, no such request will be accepted after that. Their ignorance will stand established forever and the title of maulawiyyat [religious scholarship] will be taken away from them. However, if they submit a request to write a rejoinder by June 1894, the requests of all applicants will be counted as one, and only 5,000 rupees will be deposited, not more. Those considered successful in composing a rejoinder—be they Christians or these enemies of truth, the so-called maulawis, or both—would divide those 5,000 rupees among themselves. Of course they will be free to compose a book collectively, perhaps it will be convenient for them, but their final outcome will inevitably be: خرۃ وسواد الوجہ فی الدارین

الخسر الدنیا وا [disgrace in this world and the hereafter and humiliation in both worlds].

And if I fail to deposit the 5,000 rupees in a bank within three weeks of their submitting the request—which must be attested to by at least ten renowned chiefs and sent to me via registry after being published in a newspaper—then I will be deemed a liar and my entire claim will be considered false, for verbally promising a prize is nothing; any dishonest liar can do that. Truthful is the one who honours his word, or else علی الكاذبین هللا لعنۃ [God’s curse be upon the liars]. But if I deposit the money and these duplicitous people run away from accepting the challenge, then all the expenses that I would have to bear due to their breach of promise, will be demanded from them directly or through the court. The same holds if they are unable to write a reply; their request should also include this commitment.

Now I will speak of the 1,000-rupee prize offered by Maulawi Rusul Baba. I have already mentioned that Maulawi Rusul Baba published his book Hayatul-Masih wherein he announced a prize of 1,000 rupees for anyone who would refute his arguments; yet, in the same book, he states that those arguments are hidden therein like a mystery or a riddle so that they cannot be known to anyone until they learn the book from him word for word. The wise must have realized what fear prompted him to say such things, and what heartfelt anxiety made him resort to such deceptive wiles. I immediately got to the bottom of the issue as I heard these things and understood the reason behind this clamour, and realized what apprehension must have driven him to refer the understanding of [his] arguments to his own mind.

I admonish him through this book to deposit 1,000 rupees by the end of June 1894 with Khwaja Yusuf Shah, Sheikh Ghulam Hasan, and Mir Mahmud Shah—that is, with these three collectively—and inform me by way of their handwritten receipt wherein they declare that they have received 1,000 rupees and announce that if Mirza Ghulam Ahmad—i.e. the author—proves victorious, this amount will be handed to him without delay and Rusul Baba will have nothing to do with it. This written statement is necessary so that I am fully satisfied that the money has been deposited with the arbitrators; thereafter, I can engage myself in refutation of Maulawi Rusul Baba’s book. I am even willing to accept, to settle the matter once and for all, that Sheikh Muhammad Husain Batalavi, or any other malicious person, is appointed to pass the verdict on this issue. To deliver the verdict, this alone will suffice that Sheikh Batalavi read Maulawi Rusul Baba’s book as well as mine from start to finish and swear an oath in a public gathering. The content of the oath shall be: ‘Audience! I have seen both the books from start to end and I swear by Allah Almighty that, in fact, Maulawi Rusul Baba’s book definitively and conclusively proves the life of Jesus and the answers offered by the opponent in his book fail to demolish his [Rusul Baba’s] arguments. If I have lied or concealed in my heart anything contrary to this statement, then I pray that I may suffer from leprosy within one year, or become blind, or die of some evil affliction.’ At this, all those present should say out loud three times: amin, amin, amin. Thereupon, the gathering shall conclude.

Then, if the one who takes such an oath remains safe from these afflictions for one year, the appointed committee will respectfully return the 1,000 rupees to Maulawi Rusul Baba. For my part, I will also publish the declaration that Maulawi Rusul Baba has, in fact, proved the life of the Messiah, peace be on him. However, the prize money must remain with the committee for one year. And if Maulawi Rusul Baba does not deposit 1,000 rupees within two weeks after the publication of this book, his falsehood and lies will stand established. Everyone should then seek refuge with Almighty Allah from the evil of such liars and keep away from them. It should be clear that the opposing party has greatly hurt us and there is no scorn, insult, or abuse which they have not hurled at us. When they could not harm us through takfir [accusation of disbelief ] and abuse, they turned to praying against us and started cursing us day and night. But how can the unjust curses of these miserly, dark-hearted people be accepted by Him who knows the secrets of the hearts? Ultimately, when their curses were of no avail, they despaired of God Almighty and turned towards the British Government, providing it with false information and writing slanderous books to the effect that my person represents a risk of sedition and Jihad. But this wise, shrewd, and perceptive Government is not so foolish as to be deceived by these cunning, spiteful people. The Government is fully aware that these are the people who themselves hold such beliefs and who have been saying for centuries that Islam should be spread through Jihad. Not only this, they also claim that when their imaginary Mahdi will appear or emerge from a cave, their supposed Jesus, too, will descend at the same time from heaven, carrying with him some sharp weapon to kill the disbelievers. Then, together, the two will kill all the disbelievers throughout the world and whoever refuses to accept Islam—be they Jews or Christians—will be put to the sword. Such are the beliefs that these people hold fast to! In case of doubt, let any maulawi declare his beliefs under oath in court so that the court may come to know whether such indeed are their beliefs, or whether I have erred in my statement.

·

10 of 10 left today