Footnote 2
The Descent of the Messiah
In this footnote, I have included an announcement by a Shiite gentleman that was printed at Sharifi Printers in Peshawar. It serves to demonstrate that the opinion expressed by Ali Hairi regarding Imam Hussain is not correct, not even in the eyes of his fellow Shiites. Could there be more potent evidence of his error than that his fellow Shiite rejects his opinion with strong arguments in the announcement provided below? It is a true blessing from God that, just as I was writing this book, I came across this announcement, which serves to fully expose the reality of Ali Hairi’s writing. The announcement is presented below:
I recently came across the book Wasīlatul-Mubtalā. Although I tried to restrain myself from interfering in such matters, I could not help but feel ashamed that our Imami scholars have not been utilising their God-given intelligence. They do not demonstrate any miracles of their learning and nobility. Are such responses lacking in argument sufficient to silence a claimant of Imamat? Can these dubious traditions silence the opponent? As a follower of the Imam, I say with complete honesty that these traditions and arguments that lie outside the Word of God are not enough to refute such a strong claimant. To insult someone and call them impure, vile, and misguided, and to decorate one’s writing with uncivil words from the lexicon is to bring disrepute to knowledge and civility.
Religious scholars are tasked with bolstering their opinions with evidence and logical reasoning and presenting them to open-minded individuals in a convincing manner. Ultimately, it is up to the readers to discern between truth and falsehood on their own. Now, I wish to say something to Maulawī sahib [i.e Ali Hairi].
Dear Sir: You are addressing someone who claims to be an Imam, although you consider him to be a liar and a pretender. Therefore, it is necessary to silence him through his own admissions. Presenting references from the commentary of Barghānī and Tabarani Abu Na‘im, etc. or presenting their unverified reports against a claimant of Imamat—who claims that he has come to the world as an Arbiter to establish the greatness of the Holy Qur’an and the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him—is nothing more than admitting one’s own ignorance. He is neither a Hanafite, Shafite, Malikite, Hanbalite, Ja‘farite, Muqallid, nor Ahl-e-Hadith. How then can you refute him by presenting the sayings of Hanafite, Shafite or Malikite scholars and commentators? If he were bound by these sayings, then he would not deserve the station of Imamat. He claims that he is the Hakam [Arbiter] of this age. Barghānī or Tabarani would only contain a trove of the commentators’ own opinions, nothing else. If you say that it is the commentary of the Holy Qur’an, then we will ask why so many differing commentaries, which number more than a thousand, have been published and why they differ at all. And is it not included in your beliefs that Hadrat Mahdi will appear to eliminate differences and make all religions one? Would the religion become one by itself at the arrival of the Imam Mahdi without any teaching or sermonising and bring about change and transformation? Would he not do some amendment or abrogation? After he appears, would he follow the verdict of the religious scholars of Karbala, or those of Najaf and Iran, or those of Lucknow and Lahore? Please tell me which Mujtahid will he follow and act upon his fatwas? No, I forget; he will certainly adhere to your fatwas. But unfortunately, you will not agree with this. In short, an Imam does not follow anyone but is himself the authority. It is not sensible to present Tafsir Burhani and Dala’il an-Nubuwwah against him.
His beliefs are based on the Holy Qur’an and the authentic Sunnah. I would have been very happy if, when you presented the verse of Surah Al-An‘ām, “O ye who believe!” you had shown from the Holy Qur’an itself that the word wasīlah in this verse refers to Hussain or his noble ancestors. You should also have presented a Hadith from Bukhārī or Muslim, which is accepted by the claimant to Imamat, to strengthen your claim. Or, setting aside your ire, you should have turned to your own commentaries as to what they say. From what I see in my interpretations, there are various opinions regarding the interpretation of this verse. One person refers to the opinion of Bayhaqi, Hakim, and Abu Na‘im, while another narrates a tradition or event. The second person, on the other hand, presents God’s Word by extracting it from the Holy Qur’an and presents the authentic Sunnah and Hadith as evidence for his claim. Whom should we believe and whom should we consider a scholar and one who acts according to the Holy Qur’an?
Then you say, “It is proven that Hussain and his ancestors have been declared by the Prophets and Messengers to be the medium between them and God, through whom their needs were fulfilled.” You base your claim on the statements of Mujahid, Tabarānī and Hākim, etc. and regard the verse,
[Urdu or Persian text in the original, see the original page]
your claim. It seems as if your statement was a summary which was already present in some heavenly book and the Holy Qur’an has explained it explicitly. Fie on such intelligence and wisdom! You taunt your opponent on the basis of this flimsy understanding. Please be fair and take a look at your own books to see whether the Imami scholars and commentators have relied only on these blessed names for the purpose of the commentary. At this moment, I have three commentaries of the Imams before me. These are Tafsīr ‘Umdatul-Bayān, Khulasatul-Minhaj and Majma‘ul-Bayān. They all contain many differing statements. Then look at the differing reports in Hayātul-Qulūb, Volume I, pages 56 to 57, and look at how the sayings have been copied. Regarding each one of them,
Allama Majlisi has written that the correct chain of narration for the Hadith of Imam Muhammad Baqir is through a single chain, and for another reliable Hadith, the chain of narration is different, and for the correct chain of narration for the Hadith of Imam Ja‘far Sadiq, the chain of narration is through another source, and so on.
Maulana! When there are so many different Ahadith in your own sect, how can you be so certain in interpreting the verse of
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
to mean the Five Pure Ones, and, on above this, assert that everyone agrees to this? In this matter, even the scholars and interpreters of the Imami school are not in agreement, let alone others. You then write, “It is proven from the agreed-upon Ahadith of the seventy-three sects that Noah, at the time of the flood, and Abraham [sought the intercession of Hadrat Imam Hussain]...” Regarding your claim of the consensus of Ahadith of seventy-three sects, would you be so kind as to provide one Hadith related to this subject from each sect? I will not even examine the Ahadith presented by you according to the rules of Hadith, even if they are weak. Just provide the name of the sect and the Arabic text of the Hadith, along with the reference to the book from which the Hadith has been copied.
Returning to the subject at hand, I would like to ask you the following regarding the line that you have written at the head of your book, which reads: In repudiation of the [writing], and the excellence of Imam Hussain over all Prophets, except the Holy Prophet Muhammad, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him. (1) In support of these words which verse of God have you cited wherein Allah the Almighty says that Imam Hussain (as) excels all
Prophets, in general or in specific, and mentions the name of each Prophet, peace be upon him, separately? (2) Is there a Hadith in which the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, has said that Hussain is superior to all the Prophets? (3) Did Imam Hussain (as) himself say that he was superior to all the Prophets, except the Holy Prophet? (4) Which of the other Imams of the Ahl-e-Biat has said that Imam Hussain (as) is superior to all previous Prophets, except the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him?
Now let us examine your so-called logical proof—where exactly have you established a syllogism with a minor and major premise, thereby offering a valid demonstration? Indeed a hint is sufficient for the wise!
Since all Prophets [you assert] have regarded Hadrat Hussain, may peace be upon him, and his ancestors as a wasīlah in their supplications—(Note: the burden of proving this still lies upon you)—and since it was through them that their prayers were accepted, therefore the one through whom intercession is sought, and by whose grace the prayers of the Prophets, peace be upon them, are accepted must necessarily be superior in the sight of God. For if he were not superior, the Prophets, peace be upon them, would not have adopted him as an intercessory means.