Footnote 2

The Descent of the Messiah, Part 2

This, then, is your peculiar logic and your decaying scholastic theology.

To illustrate: if a physician tells a patient, “Use this remedy, and you will be cured and your illness will be removed,” and it so happens that the patient does indeed recover—would any rational person conclude from this that the remedy is superior to the patient?

How strange that while you rebuke your opponent for considering himself superior to Hussain, you yourself have succumbed to the same error by trying to prove the superiority of Hussain over all the Prophets. Again, the claim is so tall and yet without evidence. You should have written the stations of excellence that establish his superiority, just as the Imami scholars have done in trying to prove the superiority of Hadrat Ali (ra) compared to the other Companions. You should have written (for example) that Hadrat Imam Hussain (as) (the oppressed one) was a devout person and that Prophet Adam or Noah were less than him in terms of their devoutness. Or, that Hadrat Hussain was patient and grateful, compared to which such and such prophets had less patience and gratitude, and you should have weighed the deficiency in the scales that you have with you, and so on. Had you stated all such standards and principles of excellence, which in your eyes are the basis for excellence, and compared them to all the Prophets, peace be upon them, and further strengthened them by citing authentic and consistent texts and the continuous practice of the Ummah, it would have become clear to the people of truth that Imam Hussain was indeed the most excellent among the Prophets. What use is the dry logic that since earlier Prophets had considered Hussain to be an intercessor between God for the acceptance of their prayers, he is, therefore, superior to them?

Firstly, you should prove from the Holy Qur’an that Prophet Adam (as) named Imam Hussain as his intercessor. Where was the name Hussain written at such time? Where is it mentioned in the Holy Qur’an that Prophet Adam saw the names of the Five Holy Ones written on some tree in heaven? Where is it written that Adam recognised these names as belonging to the Five Holy Ones who would be born six thousand years later? Who put this in his heart and where is the mention of such inspiration in the Holy Qur’an? The Holy Qur’an is very clear and contains wisdom. Observe! Where Allah the Almighty mentions the names, He says very clearly:

At another place, concerning the story of Adam, the Holy Qur’an has explained the meaning of the word Kalimāt as:

Now, when something has been explicitly stated by the Holy Qur’an—not merely by implication or allusion, but in clear and unambiguous words, leaving no room for doubt or ambiguity—then what rational person would abandon such a sound argument in the Holy Qur’an and instead follow their own conjecture or that of Barghānī?

(Miyan) Sayyed Ali Hamdhani and Tabarani have written in their books: “O claimant to knowledge and research! Were these men infallible that whatever they wrote must be accepted without question? Or did revelation descend upon them? Or perhaps Adam came to them in a dream and informed them that these were the names he invoked during his time of trial? Were you witnesses, or do you fabricate against Allah?”

Living centuries after the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, they transmit Hadith saying that the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, said such and such, and they record these narrations—of which they had no reliable standard of verification—in their books.

Hearken! The Messenger of God has also said that a number of impostors would appear after him and attribute false Ahadith to him, and it will be incumbent upon people to subordinate the Hadith to the Holy Qur’an, to accept the Hadith if it conforms to the Holy Qur’an, and to reject it otherwise. Then how can we regard any Hadith as authentic without applying this very standard, when the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, himself has laid down this criterion for verifying Hadith? The Maulana himself has cited this Hadith in one of his books. In short, it is no longer established that any Hadith that has been written in any book is in fact the saying of the Messengers (as). See Usūl Kāfī in Kitābul-‘Ilm wherein Imam Ja‘far says:

Just observe the preface of Usūl Kāfī and see what our Sheikhul-Muhaddithīn writes about the Hadith of the Shiites. It is surprising that you disavow the scholars whose narrations you have presented. How can you then cite an argument from them? There are only two possibilities: either you are completely uninformed about the principles of Mirza Sahib, or you are deceiving the public. Now, listen to the final verdict. Look at Ghāyatul-Maqsud, part 1, page 10, line 9. The Maulana has himself admitted that prophethood is absolutely superior to Im- āmat. Imam Hussain was an Imam and no exception has been mentioned in his case. How then can it be claimed that Imam Hussain (as) is superior to all prophets except the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him?

This Humble One, Nazar Ali of Peshawar, 1902

10 of 10 left today