(Genesis 1: 26-27)

Did Jesus Redeem Mankind?, Part 10

Yet another question confronts us. It is said about Adam that he sinned though neither his father nor his mother had sinned.If a child can sin, notwithstanding the fact that his parents did not, then a child can likewise do an act of virtue, notwithstanding the fact that his parents did nothing of the sort. And if Adam (peace be on him) could act virtuously what is there to prevent other men from acting in like manner? Evidently the theory of heredity is not a fact in this. God, the Excellent has made man so, that he is capable of making progress and is likewise liable to fall. Adam’s father had not sinned. In fact, he had no father. But Adam sinned. This goes to prove that virtue and vice are products of given circumstances and unrelated to heredity. Vicarious atonement is clearly, therefore, an uncalled for device.

Another question that arises is: How was the sin of Adam forgiven? If it was forgiven on repentance, in a similar manner the sin of his generation could be written off and there is thus hardly any room for vicarious atonement to serve any purpose.

In short, the entire foundation on which the edifice of vicarious atonement has been raised, and on the basis of which Christianity claims that since man cannot save himselef, on his own, from sin, a belief in vicarious atonement is essential, is found to be unreal on the evidence both of the Old and of the New Testaments.

Again, it appears from the Bible that the whole of this incident relating to Adam takes the form of allegory and there is evidently no sense in basing a religious believe on its foundation. For, the Bible says that when Eve ate of the fruit and gave it to Adam:

“And the eyes of them both were opened,

and they knew that they were naked.”

(Genesis 3:7)

Becoming nude after partaking of the fruit of the forbidden tree is clear evidence of the fact that the incident is narrated in the form of an allegory. It is again averred:

“And they heard the voice of the Lord

God walking in the garden in the cool of

the day.” (Genesis 3: 7-8)

The above words further lend strength to the fact that the whole affair is treated in allegoric form. God is the Creator of cold and of heat and stands in no need of these. He has not to go out in cool weather to save Himself from heat as some men move to Quetta and Murree during summer. The Bible, however, says that seeing that the hour was cool and the sun had not yet risen, God took to strolling in the garden so that he may not be exposed to the inconvenience of warm weather. This is clearly an allegoric statement and couched in idiomatic language. Similarly, it is said:

“And the Lord God called unto Adam,

and said unto him, where art thou. And he

said, I heard thy voice in the garden, and I

was afraid, because I was naked; and I hid

This again is an allegoric description, for, nothing is hidden from God, the Supreme. The Holy Qur’an confirms that there is naught in the heavens nor in the earth hidden from Allah, the Mighty whether on the surface or under the subsoil all are in His knowledge.

But the Bible says that Adam and Eve hid themselves in the dense grove of the garden so that God the Excellent may not be able to see them. The very words underline its allegoric character.

Yet another statement only speaks of the limitation of the knowledge of God, the Great:

“And the Lord God called unto Adam and

said unto him, where art thou?”

(Genesis, 3:9)

In other words, the Lord who know ‘every particleof the earth and of the heavens, and whose knowledge comprehends everything, started shouting “Where art thou O Adam.” It is clear that this language is allegoric. For, God sees everything from His throne seat. If He does not, then how is He managing to superintend their affairs? The Bible, however, insists that when they hid themselves in the garden, God, the Almighty started hailing,

“Where be thou O Adam? And he said,

I heard thy voice in the garden, and I was

afraid, because I was naked, and I hid

myself.” (Genesis 3:10)

There is really no sense in Adam believing that as he had no clothes on, he could conceal himself from the eyes of God, the Almighty, by hiding himself in the garden.

In short, this reference clearly shows that here it is not meant to relate a real episode but that the subject has been treated in an allegoric form and described in idiomatic expression. All parables and allegoric descriptions are as a rule susceptible of interpretation. This is no exception to the rule, being in no way a factual incident.

We hold, therefore, that the language on which this belief has been based is entirely allegoric, as for instance, the assertion that Adam sinned and his heart became dark or that Allah the Supreme walked in the garden or His coming for a stroll in the cool hour, His not being able to see Adam and then His calling him by name. All this is clearly allegoric language and the rest of the incident is by the same token a parable. It is clearly foolish to base a religious belief on such foundation.

·

10 of 10 left today