(Genesis 1: 26-27)

Did Jesus Redeem Mankind?, Part 11

Again, as I have explained above, since Adam could sin while he had neither a father nor a mother, it shows that both virtue and vice owe their origin to given environmental conditions and are similarly, liable to elimination. If virtue cannot invade from outside, neither can sin. If sin could invade the heart of Adam while he had no parents virtue cap likewise the heart of his descendances. The same rules shall apply to both.

Again, it is clear from the Bible that Adam remained pure in spite of his sin. Why it so happened, say the Christians, because his sin was forgiven. So, could the sin of his generation be forgiven, is our contention, without the necessity of a vicarious atonement. In order to fortify the theory of vicarious atonement or to prove that the mind of man had become vitiated beyond reform, it is necessary to establish that after the fall of Adam, man became so degenerated that he could not have recourse to virute. If the evidence of the Bible leads to the conclusion that man really could not take to virtuous life after Adam had committed, sin, then as the Bible holds forth, various atonement must necessarily be accepted as admissible. But if the Bible itself supports the stand that man did not become degenerate after the sin of Adam and did not lose hold of virtue, the very foundation of the atonement theory is knocked out. (It should be clearly noted that the Holy Qur’an does not characterize Adam’s incident as an act of sin)— If man could remain virtuous without an atonement and also abstain from sin, nothing extraneous seem to be called for his salvation.

We quote below from the Bible in this respect:

“Nevertheless death reigned from Adam

to Moses, even over them that had not

sinned after the similitude of Adam’s

transgression who is the figure of him that

was to come.” (Romans 5:14)

Here “that was to come” stands for Messiah (peace be on him) and his ‘like’ means Adam. It is averred that death laid its hand on all from Adam to Moses who had not sinned like Adam (the like of Messiah). In other words, Paul admits that there had been many from Adam to Moses who had not sinned. This clearly establishes that man can shun sin. The Bible is very clear on the point that there had been born many men after Adam who did not sin. It is strange, however, that since this theory was made in utter consternation, at the spur of the moment, to meet criticism following the crucifixion of Christ, apostles have been found to be in considerable confusion about it and have, therefore, made different statements on different occasions. As for instance the above quotation clearly shows that there, had been a lot of men after Adam who did not indulge in sin which, in other words, means that, notwithstanding the fact that Adam committed sin, sin was not transmitted to his generations through heredity. But in the same chapter

(Romans 5:12) of the same book, it is said:

“Wherefore as by one man sin entered

into the world, and death by sin: and so

death passed upon all men, for that all

have sinned.”

That is to say that Adam’s sin was punished with death and because of Adam, death became the lot of all men, for, they all had sinned.

“For until the law sin was in the world: but

sin is not imputed when there is no law.”

(Romans, 5:13)

This means that Paul was blowing hot and cold in the same breath when in the same chapter he wrote that since all had sinned, death became the lot of mankind (the Christians believe that death is the harvest of sin). But in the following verse (14) of the chapter under reference, he says; “Nevertheless, death reigned from Adam to Moses, even over them that had not sinned after the similitude of Adam’s transgression who is the figure of him that was to come.”

Here another difficulty was encountered, namely that according to Christian belief, rule of the law started with Moses and did not exist before him. And when there was no law in force what was the place of sin? The question has been met with the answer:

“For until the law sin was in the world

but sin is not imputed when there is no

Evidently, according to them, law and sin are two separate things. Quite so. We are in complete agreement with them in this view. The law forbids a particular, thing in so many words, as otherwise, men will have incurred the displeasure of Allah the Supreme. And it is a sinful act on the part of person to do what men have been clearly forbidden. Sin is thus not accountable before the enforcement of law. So far the position is tenable. But whether the law is there or not, a bad act is bad, in any case. For instance, when the Holy Qur’an was revealed, it forbade injustice, rating it as an enormous sin. We, therefore, accepted the position that injustice was not a desirable thing. But if this command had not been given by the Holy Qur’an, still an unjust person would be guilty of a wrong. The same applies to other wrongs. Even if the law had not been revealed, wrongs would be wrongs, with the only possible difference that some would denounce a wrong act as wrong and others would not. A section might describe a particular act as virtuous while others might not share their view. The sense of wrong and the sense of right are not related to law but inhere in human nature. Paul expressed the same view when he said that there was sin in the world but it was not accountable, because the law was not in force and thus the idea of sin did not exist. We hold the same view. Where the law is not in force, a wrong would be a wrong, but it would not be an accountable sin in terms of Shariat (Law).

For example, the law of Shariat does not exist in a certain place and people naturally do not offer the currently prescribed prayer. Suppose those living in jungles or on distant mountains do not know of the heavenly appointment of the Holy Prophet Muhammad (peace and the blessings of Allah be on him). Allah the Excellent will not require of them why they did not observe the prayers prescribed by Islam nor would He require of them why they did not observe the fast prescribed by Islam, for the obvious reason that they did not know of this particular prayer and this form, of fasting. The Ahadith (Traditions) are very clear on the point and say that four types of people will be exempt from legal account-rendering on the day of Judgement (1) the born deaf, (2) the demented, (3) the senile and (4) all those to whom the message of Islam did not reach. For the test of such people another prophet will be commissioned to them and in the event of their accepting him, they will be saved, and in case they rejected him they would be punished (Ruhalmaani, Vol. IV, under the verse 17:16 –

Apart from this, the Promised Messiah (peace be on him) has adduced supporting evidence from the Holy Qur’an to the effect that such people shall be judged in the light of the natural human instincts and not in terms of the laws laid down in the Holy Qur’an. They will be judged by the sense of values implanted in the nature of every man. Human nature in itself judges some acts as sinful independently of the light of guidance the Shariat (Law) proffers to man. A well- known incident related by Khalifa-tul-Masih I (may Allah be pleased with him) is an apt illustration. A thief came to him for medical advice. He exhorted him to desist from eating unlawful property as looting other people’s goods was a wicked thing. Hearing this he said back that his advice was nothing better than priestly tall talk; that none earned his bread the harder way than men of his calling; that he (the Khalifatul-Masih I) was making easy money by way of fees earned through a simple pulse-examination, while the thieves shivered in cold and risked their very necks in the job: that on the one hand they were in constant fear of the police and on the other of being apprehended at every step and yet they faced all these hardships and earned their money by literally exposing themselves to death. Could there be a better-earned income, the thief asked? The Khalifa-tul Masih I (Allah be pleased with him) changing the topic soon engaged him in talk on some other subject. Then after a while he asked him how they used to plan a burglary. He replied that some seven to eight persons usually took part in the operation. One remained on the look-out of the house and gave information as to its property-contents. Another was an expert wall breaker. One stood guard outside. Two men stood sentry at the two ends of the lane. One was at hand to enter the premises. A well-dressed person stood far away from the scene of theft and all loot was brought over to him, so that if someone chanced to see him with the goods, far from being suspected, he should be liable to be taken for the owner of goods. All the rest had their bodies well-oiled and wore only a short light loin-cloth and did their assigned duties. Ornaments were passed on to a goldsmith who melted the gold and handed it back to the gang and it was then divided among all the members.

Thereupon the Khalifatul Masih I (peace be on him) asked him that if the goldsmith ate up all the ornaments what they could do. He unconsciously ejaculated “will he be so, dishonest as to gorge up the property of others?” The Khalifat-ul-Masih I (Allah be pleased with him) then told him that it appeared there was some distinction between honesty and dishonesty even in his mind and that even his conscience felt what was virtue and what was a wrongful act. The Promised Messiah (peace and the blessings be on him) says in effect the same thing when he observes that such people will be tested by their natures. Allah the Excellent will not require of them why they did not offer the prayers prescribed by the Holy Prophet Muhammad (peace and the blessings of Allah be on him). He will require of them whether they had done the duty of worship in accordance with their nature’s urge of dutiful worship of a deity. The same applies to acts like perjury, theft and brigandage. One may indulge in misappropriating other people’s property taking it as a normal thing but when another person lifts his property, he calls him a crook. This goes to show that, in his heart of hearts, he knows that misappropriation is an act of dis honesty. It is true that such a one cannot be called a sinner in terms of the Shariat law, but, he will be guilty in terms of natural impulses and will meet his deserts. But the point is, if this is a correct stand, where does then the need for atonement arise?

If the New Testament had asserted that human nature was a curse in itself, this would be a tenable theory. But it says, the law is curse (Galatians, Ch, 3:13). In other words, the New Testament does not find fault with the judgment of human nature condemning a particular act as sinful; but it says that law is a curse, in that it bears such commands as people do not find practicable, and it claims that Jesus, therefore, scrapped it. But the question here arises that the law was in abeyance even before the advent of Moses (peace be on him) and man needed no atonement for salvation; he could either attain salvation by acting according to his nature or incur punishment by acting against it. Where is the need then for a vicarious atonement under the circumstances?

·

10 of 10 left today