(Genesis 1: 26-27)
Did Jesus Redeem Mankind?, Part 12
On recapitulation, the true position turns out to be that by enforcing the Shariat law through Moses (peace be on him), Allah put men to hardship. But vicarious atonement was not the remedy of the situation. The true remedy lay in scrapping the law. This may be a very foolish step but so far as the remedy was concerned, this alone was appropriate. For, according to Romans we are led to believe that there was no law before Moses (peace be on him) and the people could not be judged as sinners in terms of law, and since they were not sinners in the aforesaid sense, the law could not punish them. Further, according to the same source, there were people who did not sin, that is they were not guilty of offending nature.
All the above-quoted references show that the whole trouble arose not on account of the sin of Adam (peace be on him) but on account of the Divine mistake (Allah save us from such beliefs) of sending a law through Moses (peace be on him): when people could not act according to its commands and the question of their punishment came up, Allah sent the Messiah and abolished the law for good through him.
There was hardly any need for sending out Messiah for the purpose. The God Who gave the law to Moses (peace be on him), could very well declare through Joshua (peace be on him) its abrogation on the ground of its impracticability.
Another question arises here. If sin is committed but is not accountable, where is the justice of God? Justice is the second pillar of the theory of vicarious atonement, and it is asserted that if God did not punish men for their sins, he would not be just. The point here is that the mere change of label does not change the reality of a thing. A person commits theft, but we say, there would be no punishment for him, as the law of Moses is not there yet. As against him there is another person guilty of the same offence. We declare him to be an inmate of eternal hell, for the simple reason that the law of Moses finds him guilty. The nature of the act is the same; this one lifted property as did the other. We do not declare the act of the first as an offence, as the law of Moses (peace be on him) is not there yet, but we condemn the other, for the simple reason that the law of Moses (peace be on him) is in force. We leave alone the one and arraign the other while both have committed the same act. Where lies the justice and whence the equity that permits this?
Let us take another instance, that of lying or of oppressing others. If we do not forbid these acts or do not condemn a person for lying or oppressing others, how can one who commits these acts be a righteous and clean-minded person? How can a thief, a liar and a wrong-doer become righteous minded, for the simple reason that we did not restrain them, or that we did not condemn them? And if one is not guilty but the other is, on account of the same acts that both have committed, justice obviously loses its foothold.
So far I have dealt with the subject in terms of principles in a philosophical strain. Now I propose to show that in the world of actualities too, as the Bible points out, there have been appearing men of virtue from time to time in the world. It is said of Enoch, great-grandson of Adam (peace be on him) and great-grand-father of Noah:
“And Enoch walked, with God after he
begat Methuselah three hundred years,
and begat sons and daughters. And all the
days of Enoch were three hundred sixty
and five years. And Enoch walked with
God and he was not; for God took him.”
The above-quoted reference shows that Enoch walked with the Lord. It does not mean that Enoch and God went out to travel together as people generally do on trips to America or other countries. He would not thus be said to have been doing sight-seeing with God, the
Almighty for some three hundred years. This in fact, is an idiomatic way of Biblical expression meaning that Enoch was a virtuous man and had imbibed the attributes of God. That is to say that his acts were patterned according to the works of God; he was exceedingly compassionate, generous in treatment, affectionate and loving to mankind, was just and equitable and took care of the poor. Similarly, he had in him the other attributes of God—Cherisher, Beneficent, Merciful, Master and Forgiving. And, next, that he was taken to the heavens—that is he completely resembled the Messiah and held the position that the Messiah enjoyed. In fact, the Messiah was vouchsafed only thirty years of life, but Enoch lived as long as 365 years, living a good and righteous life.
It shows that Enoch, the great-grandson of Adam (peace be on him) and great-grand-father of Noah (peace be on him), was so good that he was, so to speak, like God and that he was ultimately taken to heaven. When read together with the Messiah’s observation:
“And no man hath ascended up to heaven,
but he that came down from heaven, even
the son of man which is in heaven.”
The status of Enoch is further illuminated and we are led to the conclusion that Enoch had come from heaven and had, therefore, gone up to heaven. In fact, it means that only those people go to heaven whom Allah takes under His care from their childhood, keeping them under His protection and control. Enoch was one of those who are brought up under the shadow of the grace and mercy of God the Great and who in the words of the Bible, are taken up to heaven.
In far grander terms even than Enoch has been related the story of Melchisedec. The New Testament also confirms it. According to the Bible, when Abram (peace be on him) was persecuted in Iraq and his cousins put him to torment, God, the Almighty commanded him to migrate to Palestine. So far only Lot (peace be on him) had believed in him. He took Lot (peace be on him) along. His wife also accompanied him. On the way, travelling through Egypt where he married Hagar (Allah be pleased with her), Abram (peace be on him) reached Palestine. He had been foretold that he would find asylum there and would have a following. When he settled down in Palestine and the neighbouring kings found him gaining popularity among the masses, they went to war with him. Abram (peace be on him) sallied forth in defence and put them to defeat. After defeating them, as he was returning, king Melchisedec met him. He was considered to be highly virtuous, pious and saintly man of his time. Abram (peace be on him) offered him a tenth part of the booty. Melchisedec declined to accept the offer saying that he was in no need of money but asked Abram (peace be on him) to hand over to him the captives of war. But Abram (peace be on him) insisted on giving him the war booty lest people should say that he owed his wealth to Melchisedec. It is evident that Abraham (peace be on him) owed allegiance to Melchisedec (Genesis, 14:18-24): “And Melchisedec, king of Salem brought forth bread and wine; and he was the priest of the most high God, possessor of heaven and earth. And he blessed him, and said, blessed be Abraham of the most high God, possessor of heaven and earth. And blessed be the most high God, which hath delivered thine enemies into thy hand. And he gave him tithes of all. And the king of Sodom said to Abram, give me the persons, and take the goods to thyself.