(Genesis 1: 26-27)
Did Jesus Redeem Mankind?, Part 6
Because of this incident, I learnt in the morning that he had, in compliance with my advice, offered his prayers in the mosque and being under the influence of overpowering sleep had missed his own soft and comfortable shoes and started back with an old and tattered pair of shoes belonging to someone else. Now, it is evident that no Nawab has a mark of identity inscribed on his face. Suppose the owner of the shoes had turned up and seizing hold of the Nawab by the throat threatened to hand him over to police on charge of theft, he might have been punished but this error would not stand in the way of his salvation, for it had not been committed with intent to steal.
Let us take another instance. The two diseases syphilis and gonorrhoea are generally considered to be the harvest of sin. But it is possible that the sin was not committed by the patient and was committed by his father or grandfather. Take the case of a man who marries the widow of a syphilitic from whom she had contracted the malady. Now the second husband is definitely exposed to attack through contact with her and would thus land himself in trouble. His suffering is manifestly a punishment for adultery but he will not go to hell on account of this nor will his heart grow dark; on the contrary it is quite likely that it may become purer than ever on account of it. What darkens the heart is the internal aspect of sin. The harm accruing from its external aspect is a temporary phase and has no lasting ill-effects.
In the case of Adam (peace be on him) Allah says, “We did not find in him the element of pre-determination.” That is to say that his error was on account of a misunderstanding, as is clear from the Biblical quotations about Satan persuading him to believe that it would be a good thing on his part, if he ate of the fruit and that thereby he would gain insight to discriminate between good and evil. Adam thought over it and voted for its correctness and thus fell into error. His mistake was clearly the result of a misconception and not premeditated.
(11) Again, Allah the Supreme says in the Holy Qur’an:
i.e., On true repentence Allah doth indeed forgive all sins
The Bible may hold the view that sins are never forgiven. We are not concerned here whether the Biblical thesis is correct or the thesis in the Holy Qur’an. What we are concerned with here is the stand in the Holy Qur’an on the point. The Holy Qur’an holds that repentance is followed by forgiveness. Evidently, therefore, when sins have been forgiven, punishment is automatically waived.
(12)The Holy Qur’an further says:
i.e., Whoso has in his heart awe of the station of His Lord is awarded two heavens, one in this world and the other in the next (Ar-Rahman, 55: 47). Now it that heaven in this world does not comprise worldly goods. If mundane goods were meant to be the award, there has been many a good man of God in a much inferior position in worldly circumstance than many a disbeliever. Even the common labourer in Europe today wears better and eats better than did the Holy Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be on him). If heaven in this world stood for mundane gifts, then without the least question, the labourer of today’s Europe is in heaven and the great reformers and saints, God forbid, are out of it. Heaven, therefore, means in this context spiritual tranquillity and its award means the seeking of His nearness. The word of Allah:
مَقَامَ رَبِّهِۦ جَنَّتَانِ (whoso fears God is a favourite of Allah in
this world and would be granted near association with Him in the next), clearly signifies that the capacity to attain nearness to God, the Almighty inheres in every man. If sin were hereditary in man, he could have no means of attaining access to God.
(13) God similarly says:
i.e., whoso is blind in this world shall be blind in the next
(Bani Israil 17:73). It cannot really mean that one who is
physically blind in this world will be blind also in the hereafter. It is indeed a great tyranny to condemn to blindness in the next life one who is blind in this life. In fact, what the verse purports to impress is that it is with the spiritual eye that one sees God Almighty and blind are those who do not see Him. The verse:
thus, carries two imports, one negative and the other positive. There are some who are blind and there are others who are not. For, God says: the one who is blind in this life shall be blind also in the hereafter. It clearly means that some will be blind, while others will not be blind. This verse therefore, clearly points out that the Holy Qur’an holds that the hearts of some men can become pure. Allah the Supreme stresses here the point that whoso vitiated his heart here would forfeit the capacity to see Him in the hereafter. It shows that the hearts of the entire mankind would not be vitiated. (14) Similarly says the Hadith:
i.e., Every child is born with a pure nature then his parents through their teaching make him either a Jew or a Christian or a Magain (Bukhari, Kitab al-Janaiz). This indicates that man is born with a clear nature and that evil takes root in him through environmental influences.
(15) Yet another Hadith says that God, the Excellent has made the heart of man pure. In his worldly existence he does an act of virtue or commits an evil. When he does a good deed, a white point appears on his heart and when he commits a sin, a dark spot appears on his heart. And as he progresses in good deeds or evil, white or dark points begin increasing in due proportion, till the whole of his heart becomes either white or black, according to the character of his actions. If his entire heart becomes white, he becomes immune to the influence of evil. But if the whole of his heart becomes dark, he loses the capacity of virtue. (vide Tafsir Ibn-e-Jarir, verse:
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
This supports the thesis that man comes to this world with a pure constitution and for a long time his purity of nature remains in good shape. When the whole of his heart grows white and virtue takes firm hold of it, he attains to salvation without a vicarious atonement. But when the whole of his heart becomes dark and vice takes a firm grip on it, no vicarious atonement can be of any avail to him.
Contrary to this, Christianity claims that Adam (peace be on him) sinned and was punished on account of it. His sin was then transmitted through heredity to his generations. Now man cannot by himself escape evil, for it is his heritage. His salvation called for a vicarious atonement which the Messiah (peace be on him) offered; and he took the entire sin of mankind on himself. In other words, according to Christianity, man is born as a slave-boy of Satan and is rescued from his grip through faith in the vicarious atonement offered by the Messiah (peace be on him).