(Genesis 1: 26-27)
Did Jesus Redeem Mankind?, Part 7
As I have explained above, the Holy Qur’an rejects the entire thesis of Christianity in this context. According to the Exalted Qur’an, sin is not hereditary nor is man sinful by birth, nor does he need any vicarious atonement; human nature has been made pure and it is endowed with capacity to make progress so much so that he can become the favourite of the Supreme Maker; and if he commits a sin, his repentance has a chance of acceptance. Now that we find that the Holy Qur’an has rejected this Christian thesis and if the Bible likewise does not lend it any support, there is then little ground left for Christians to subscribe to it. On pondering the subject, we are confronted with four questions:
(1) Man inherited sin. (2) Since man inherited sin, he cannot be pure. (3) Man could not be pure but since God Almighty is Compassionate and Merciful therefore, His mercy and compassion called for a sacrifice. (4) That man truly became pure through this sacrifice.
These four questions come up when we consider this problem and it is incumbent on us to seek answers to them.
The first point is that since Adam (peace be on him) sinned, therefore, the entire generation of man was tainted with sin, for, it inherited sin from Adam (peace be on him). Now let us see whether Adam really committed sin and whether the Old and the New Testaments support this theory. If, however, the Bible does not find Adam (peace be on him) guilty of sin, the entire theory is knocked out.
So far as I can understand, the Bible has clear evidence to prove that Adam (peace be on him) did not sin. From the Bible, I am led to the conclusion that even the Satan did not sin. My study of the Bible shows further that neither Adam nor the Satan sinned; it was no other than God Himself, who sinned, (may Allah keep us from entertaining such thoughts). I propose to adduce the necessary evidence below:
The incident of Adam (peace be on him) is narrated in the Genesis. [It should be remembered in this connection that the Bible is the collection of books beginning with the story of Moses (peace be on him) to that of Jesus (peace be on him) and ending up with the Apostles. From Moses (peace be on him) to Prophet Malachi the entire collection is termed the Old Testament. According to Jews only the Old Testament forms the Scripture. According to Christians both the Old and the New Testaments comprise the Scripture. The Old Testament consists of five books of Moses (peace be on him). Of these, the first is the Genesis which also makes mention of Adam (peace be on him)]. Says the Genesis:
“And the Lord God planted a Garden
eastward in Eden; and there he put the
man whom he had formed. And out of the
ground made the Lord God to grow every
tree that is pleasant to the sight, and good
for food; the tree of life also in the midst
of the garden, and the tree of knowledge
of good and evil.” (Chapter 2, Verses 8 & 9)
Here the Bible asserts that after the birth of Adam (peace be on him), God, the Excellent planted a garden in Eden wherein He grew all kinds of trees and in the middle of the garden He planted the tree of life and of discrimination between good and evil. I will elaborate it elsewhere whether the tree of life was a different one from the tree of discrimination between good and evil or the two are really one and the same tree. I think the two trees were not separate but a single and identical plant. But the Bible is very hesitant and undecided on the point, showing the two sometimes as one and at others as two distinct trees.
Further, it says:
“And the Lord God commanded the man,
saying, of every tree of the garden thou
mayst freely eat; but of the tree of the
knowledge of good and evil, thou shalt
not eat of it; for in the day that thou eatest
thereof thou shalt surely die.”
In other words, God planted in the garden of Eden all kinds of trees, with the tree of knowledge in its midcentre and told Adam (peace be on him) to partake of the fruits thereof except that he was forbidden the tree of knowledge and that if he partook of it, he would die instantly. Continuing, the Bible mentions Eve having said:
“But of the fruit of the tree which is in the
midst of the garden, God hath said, Ye
shall not eat of it neither shall ye touch it,
lest ye die.” (Genesis 3:3)
In short, firstly the statement of the Bible says that God warned Adam against eating of the fruit of the tree of knowledge as otherwise he should die instantly. This is further supported by Eve who confirms that Allah had in fact, forbidden them the fruit of that tree and even forbidden their going near it as they would die if they did so.
Now the Satan (the Bible has used the word serpent for Satan) approaches Adam (peace be on him) and says, in the words of the Bible,
“For God doth know that in the day you
eat thereof, then your eyes will be opened,
and ye shall be as gods, knowing good and
evil.” (Genesis 3:5)
An examination of these verses shows that the fault lay neither with Adam (peace be on him) nor with the Satan but entirely with God, (we seek the protection of Allah against such views). These verses show that the tree under reference was the tree of life and of knowledge i.e., it was a tree that was life-giving and it was a tree that gave one the power to discriminate between good and evil. But the Bible says that God told Adam (peace be on him):