(Genesis 1: 26-27)

Did Jesus Redeem Mankind?, Part 8

“But of the tree of the knowledge of good

and evil, thou shalt not eat of it, for in the

day that thou eatest thereof, thou shalt

surely die.” (Genesis 2:17)

In other words, it says God made a misstatement to

Adam (peace be on him). It was the tree of life and of knowledge, but God the Excellent warned that the day he ate of it; he would die. Dying may stand for physical demise or for spiritual extinction. In both the cases, this statement of God, the Almighty is proven baseless. If it means spiritual death, it is an untruth. For, the gift of knowing good from evil is a means of sustaining spiritual life and not the cause of spiritual death. If it means physical death, this is again wrong. For, it was the tree of life eating whereof would not cause death. In short, the God of the Bible deceived Adam when he told him not to eat of the tree which was the life-giving tree and the tree of wisdom. Eve also testified that God the Supreme had warned:

“And the woman, said to the serpent,

we may eat of the fruit of the tree of the

garden. But of the fruit of the tree which is

in the midst of the garden God hath said,

ye shall not eat of it nor shall ye touch it,

It is evident that God Almighty made a misstatement and deceived Adam. (Allah protect us against such views). As against this when Satan said to Adam:

“For God doth know that in the day you

eat thereof, then your eyes shall be opened, and you shall be as gods, knowing good

and evil.” (Genesis 3:5)

There was nothing false about it. The tree had both the properties; it was the tree of life as well as of knowledge. That is, partaking of it gave life and also it gave the power to discriminate between good and evil. Thus Satan did not mislead Adam. It was God, as Bible would have us believe, who deceived him. Do we, on going further into this question, see that after eating, of the fruit of that tree, Adam and Eve died? They did not die. On the contrary they lived and the word of Satan “you will not die” came true and the word of God that “the day thou ate of it thou wouldst die” did not come true. Again, as the Bible says, after eating of the tree they began to know good and evil. According to the Bible, therefore, no fault lay with Adam, nor any blame attached to the Satan; God Himself was responsible for misleading them. Adam (peace be upon him) tried to discriminate between good and evil and to become a man. No one under the heavens would call it a sin. Adam tried to cultivate virtue and Satan warned him that God was misleading him when He had said that by partaking of the fruit of the tree of knowledge he would die, while he (Satan) pleaded Adam would not die but live and have the power to know good from evil on partaking of the fruit of the tree of knowledge. The Bible confirms that after eating of the fruit of the forbidden tree they grew wise and began to know evil from good.

None sinned therefore, at any rate, neither Adam nor even Satan. God of the Bible alone sinned Who by calling the tree of life, the tree of death, misled Adam into believing that he would die after eating of its fruit. This death either could be physical or spiritual. He was wrong on both scores. They could not incur physical death, for it was the tree of life, and they could not die spiritually either, as it was the tree of knowledge, that is, it was a source of a new spiritual life for man.

Here Christianity cannot claim that God the Father made the misstatement and God the Son did not. For, God, in Christian terminology, stands for the Tripartite godhead. God the Father is not distinct from God the Son nor is the latter distinct from the Holy Ghost. If, therefore, God the Father made a misleading statement, it means that the other two, the Son and the Holy Ghost shared the blame. If therefore, sin was transmitted through heredity, then on the authority of the Bible, we are led to the conclusion that Adam did not sin, but God sinned, and, in other words, Jesus sinned in that he made a misleading statement for which he should take the entire blame.

In final analysis, God, the Supreme has been portrayed in such nasty colours by the Bible as make His picture a repulsive and regrettable sight. In the face of these texts Jesus cannot lay claim to the title of saviour. How can one, who makes misleading observations and indulges in deception, be a redeemer?

Another argument that extenuates the sin of Adam is that he made it on account of mis-judgment. The Holy Qur’an stresses this very point. Even if we place our reliance on the Biblical version, we find that Adam erred in good faith:

“So, God created man in his own image,

in the image of God created He him, male

and female created He them.” (Genesis 1:27)

Man whom God made in His own image includes both the male and female of the species. Both man, the male and his female—the woman—have been created in the image of God. This cannot mean that God has nose, ears, and eyes and other limbs as human beings have. All that it signifies is that the attributes of the Supreme Creator were incorporated in Adam (peace be on him). Thus when God, the Almighty made man according to His own image and told him that he had been created to radiate His attributes, it could not but happen that Adam would imbibe the attribute of discriminating between good and evil.

What Satan told Adam, therefore, was in effect: “God has made you the radiator of His attributes. One of the Divine attributes is His Power of discriminating between good and evil. As God knows good from evil, so, should you know good from evil. And the only way to do so, is that you should partake of the fruit of knowledge. And if you would not eat of it, you will have no means of knowing good from bad. And through lack of knowledge of good and evil, you will not become the perfect manifestation of Divine attributes. It is, therefore, imperative that you should partake of its fruit; in other words, become like God by eating its fruit or, in still better language, if you will eat of the fruit of this tree, you will have attained the object of your existence for which God made you.” Suppose it all happened in this manner; if Adam was thus led to an error of judgment, would any blame attach to him? A person walks up to Adam and says: “Look, you know you have been made in the image of God and you know that all that this means is that you should become a mirror of Divine attributes and you also are well aware that knowledge of good and evil is one of His attributes. If you will eat of the fruit of the tree of knowledge, you will have achieved the purpose of your existence and become the mirror of the attributes of the Supreme Creator.”

It was such a forceful argument that Adam wilted under its weight and made an error of judgement taking the entire story in good faith. I will go to the extent of saying that even today, notwithstanding the trick imposed on Adam, many people will fall prey to a similar deception, if they are approached in the above manner, in the belief that God had willed that they should eat of the fruit of the tree and had never meant to forbid it. The Bible, thus, supports the view that there was the possibility of Adam being led to an error of judgement. Even according to the Bible, knowledge of good and evil is a Divine attribute:

·

10 of 10 left today