(Luke 1:6)

Did Jesus Redeem Mankind?

Further, the angels said to Zacharias (peace be on him) in respect of John:

“For he shall be great in the sight of the

Lord; and he shall be filled with the Holy

Ghost, even from his mother’s womb.”

(Luke, 1:15)

Evidently, therefore, it meant that the Holy Spirit will not descend on John after his mother had delivered him but that it would descend on him and will take hold of him while he was yet in his mother’s womb. There is no gainsaying the fact that sinfulness begins after one is delivered of his mother’s womb but one who is taken hold of the Holy Ghost when he is yet in his mother’s womb, can never fall a prey to sin.

In short, even John was free from sin and vice as the New Testament says. In fact, the Messiah (peace be on him)

went so far as to declare:

“Verily I say unto you; Among them that

are born of women there hath not risen a

greater than John the Baptist.”

(Matthew 11: 11-12)

He thus showed that John was far superior to him, for, Messiah was also born of a woman as was John.

The above references show that both Zacharias (peace be on him) and his wife, were, according to the Bible, pure and flawless and observed the ordinances of God the Supreme.

Similarly, John was filled with the Holy Spirit while yet in his mother’s womb and was perfect, without a blemish. Now when John, Zacharias and his wife could be free from sin, by the same rule, why the other people could not be similarly, free from sin? When practically there have been before the Messiah and before his vicarious atonement took place, such people as were virtuous, pious and flawless and observant of the ordinances, the inference is clear that the righteous existed in the world even without atonement. And when righteousness could be sustained in the world without atonement once, it could continue to abide in a future period of time as well, and there remained therefore, no necessity for any redemption.

The question, how some of the preceding generations were saved, and how it was that there had been pious people in the past, is sometime met by the Christian clergy with the answer that they had become righteous and worthy of salvation through faith in the vicarious atonement offered by the Messiah. This answer is on the very face of it a clear stunt. They base their argument on the premises that the advent of the Messiah (peace be on him) had been foretold by Abram, David and some other prophets (peace be on them), but there is no trace of a reference to Messiah in the prophecies made by Abram (peace be on him). This stand is totally fictitious. All that Abram (peace be on him) said was that his progeny will be blessed and that through them God, the Almighty would manifest His holiness. Evidently this prophecy relates to Abram’s (peace be on him) progeny and is not specifically related to one person. The prophecy holds true in the case of Ishmael (peace be on him), an exalted prophet of God. It holds good also in the case of Isaac (peace be on him), another exalted prophet of God. It equally applies to Jacob, Joseph, Moses, David and Zacharias (peace be on them). Prophecies of some other prophets no doubt speak of a Messiah but there is a world of difference between a prophecy about the advent of a person and a prophecy about the appearance of a Son of God who would atone for the sins of others but through whom there would be no salvation. The advent of almost all coming prophets has been foretold by the predecessor-prophets. The advent of John had been foretold and so had been the coming of David and similarly, of Jesus (peace be on them). But this hardly argues in favour of the suggestion that their advent was foretold in the terms that salvation was contingent on faith in their atonement.

However, even if it is conceded that the prophecy made by Abram (peace be on him) about his progeny implied that there would be a son born to him in the distant future who would be the cause of the salvation of man, it would not apply to the Messiah (peace be on him), for his whole claim rests on the assertion that he is the Son of God. Christianity condemns the generation of Adam as sinful and one sinner cannot carry the burden of the other. It is, therefore, necessary to find someone outside the generation of Adam (peace be on him). It, therefore, puts forth the claim that God, the Almighty sent Jesus Messiah, His only Son, so that he may atone for the sins of mankind. If Messiah was the Son of God, he could not be the son of Abram (peace be on him). If he was a son of Abram (peace be on him) he could not be the medium of atonement, for he was not the Son of God. An attempt to relate the prophecy of Abram (peace be on him) to Messiah knocks down the whole edifice of the theory of atonement.

I well remember, I was yet a boy, about seventeen years old when I went to Lahore and felt tempted to have an exchange of views with some Christian clergy. I went to see the Bishop of Lahore who was later appointed Principal of the Saharanpur Mission College. I asked him how people of the preceding generations attained to salvation? He said that they believed in Jesus and through their faith in him were saved. I said, “If I were to assert that they were saved through faith in me what would he suggest for an answer?” He replied back that such a claim called for a prophecy to support it. I conceded his point but wanted to know which prophecy was related to the Messiah. He cited the prophecy made by Abram (peace be on him). I said he could have before him all the prophecies made by Abram (peace be on him). If, on the one hand, they speak of blessings in the generation of Isaac (peace be on him), they, on the other, say the same thing about the progeny of Ishmael (peace be on him). “If you feel entitled to apply the prophecy to Messiah (peace be on him), why should we not apply it to the Holy Prophet Muhammad (peace and the blessings of Allah be on him) for he was of the progeny of Ishmael (peace be on him).” Then I asked him to first answer the question whether the theory of atonement rested on the basis that Messiah was the Son of God. But, I added, if he were a son of Abram, there could be no point in favour of the said theory. He was an aged man, some 55 to 60 years old but my question caused him no ordinary headache. In the end, after an hour’s argument, he apologetically said that according to a Greek proverb every fool could put a question but it needed a wise man to answer. In other words, he told me that I was a fool and that he himself was not wise enough to answer every question. I was young in those days and hardly in a mood to take it quietly. I retorted back that I regretted very much that I had come to him taking him for a wise man.

The substance of the whole argument is that if the Messiah was a son of Abram (peace be on him), the atonement theory becomes untenable. But if he was the son of God, the prophecy of Abram (peace be on him) does not relate to him. In either case the objection is there; either the Messiah cannot be a factor of atonement, or the prophecy of Abram (peace be on him) does not apply to him.

There is yet another aspect of the matter. If Abram (peace be on him) has foretold the advent of someone, we have to determine his identity. Abram (peace be on him) foretold the appearance of one from among his progeny. It has been held by the progeny of Abram (peace be on him) that he had foretold the advent of a great man from among them.

Now we find two persons in the world each of whom claims to be answering to the prophecy. Of the two, we ask one his credentials. He says that his father was so and so and that his grandfather was so and so and his great grandfather was so and so and that his great greatgrandfather was so and so and that he was begotten of Abram. We next turn to the other and call for his credentials to establish his Abramic lineage. He says that his mother was so and so, she was married to so and so and that her husband was the son of so and so and he was the grandson of so and so and that he was begotten of Abram (peace be on him). Will any sensible man admit the latter’s claim to Abram’s lineage?

One of the two claimed that his father was begotten of so and so, his grandfather of so and so and his greatgrandfather of so and so, tracing his lineage finally to Abram (peace be on him). The other one rests his claim on his mother wedding so and so and that the latter was a descendant of Abram (peace be on him). The claim of the one who traces his line age on his father’s side to Abram (peace be on him) will be accepted on all hands while that of the other who bases it on his mother’s marriage with one of Abram’s descendants would not be entertained. This is precisely the case of Messiah (peace be on him) as against that of the Holy Prophet (peace and the blessings of Allah be on him).

10 of 10 left today