(Luke 1:6)
Did Jesus Redeem Mankind?, Part 2
The family tree of the Messiah (peace be on him) detailed out in Matthew, (Ch. 1) and which is termed “the book of the generations of Jesus Christ son of David, the son of Abram,” ends up with the words:
“And Jacob begot Joseph the husband of
Mary, of whom was born Jesus, who is
Evidently the family tree of Jesus not traceable to Abram (peace be on him); it is the family tree of Joseph to whom Mary (Allah be pleased with her) was wedded that has been traced to Abram (peace be on him). As against this, the Holy Prophet Muhammad (peace and the blessings of Allah be on him) claimed that his father was Abdullah and his grandfather was Abdul Muttalib tracing his lineage directly to Abram (peace be upon him) and to be a direct descendant of Abram (peace be upon him) has clearly asserted that it was Joseph to whom his mother wedded and not he himself who was of the progeny of Abram. On the contrary, Muhammad the Prophet of Allah, (peace and the blessings of Allah be on him) who answers the prophecy, is a direct descendant of Abram (peace be on him) and there is hardly any ground to claim the prophecy in favour of the Messiah.
In so far as the Messiah’s claim that he is the saviour of mankind is concerned, a similar claim has been made by the Holy Prophet Muhammad (peace and the blessings of Allah be on him). Allah the Excellent commanded him:
i.e., Tell the people, if you seek to make such spiritual progress that you should become the favourites of Allah, then follow me and subscribe allegiance to me. This will lead to your salvation and will endear you to Allah the Supreme (Aal-e-Imran, 3:32).
In other words, belief in Muhammad the Prophet of Allah (peace and the blessings of Allah be on him) will not only save man but lead him to such spiritual development as would endear him to the Supreme Lord. Again, He says:
i.e., O ye believers, accept ye the commands of Allah and of the Prophet, because he is calling you to quicken you (Al-Anfal, 8:25). Here the claim has been made that Muhammad the Prophet of Allah (peace and the blessings of Allah be on him) infuses life in men. Since the New Testament asserts that death is the harvest of sin, these words characterise Muhammad the Prophet of Allah (peace and the blessing of Allah be on him) as the saviour of mankind, and it has been claimed that through allegiance to him mankind can save itself from death which is the crop of sin.
Another question that arises about the atonement is that with godhead being tripartite, why the Messiah was singled out for atonement? Granted that Adam had sinned, granted that the sin of Adam was transmitted through heredity to his children, even though it is a totally silly assumption. Also, granted that hereditary sin is susceptible of no remedy (another silly idea) and that it called for an external remedial measure. Further granted that the atonement is the only remedy that would wash off hereditary sin (yet another foolish idea); though such a remedy would fit in with the idiom in usage in our country, namely “hit the knee, burst the eye.” (Someone, it is said, was hit on the knee and started wailing that his eye had been hurt).
To say that sin could not be taken away from the world but the hanging of the Messiah by the Cross took it away, amounts to the same thing. The whole argument is unsound; its parts being in no way inter-related. But let us grant it and also grant the further argument that a person with Divine attributes alone would serve the purpose. But the question arises why God the Father did not offer Himself for this mission? After all, He has the attribute of mercy too. Or has He not? When God the Father is Merciful to the world beyond comprehension, why did He not offer Himself for atonement? Why did not God the Holy Ghost do so? Wherefore did God the Son alone come forward for the purpose? There can be only two answers to these questions. It will have to be admitted that either the death of God the Father, or that of God the Holy Ghost would have ended in the dissolution of the world and, therefore, God the Son offered to be sacrificed. It will have to be simultaneously admitted in that case that God the Son is an imperfect God and that his death could not, therefore, end in the end of the world and, therefore, it was He who was offered for the job and not God the Father, for, His death would have meant the end of the world.
Yet another explanation is that God the Father and God the Holy Ghost did not love mankind as much as did God the Son. But this would condemn both God the Father and God the Holy Ghost as imperfect and would be inconsistent with the New Testament which declares “God is love”(Corinthians II, 13: 11). In short, either God the Son appears to be imperfect and a surplus being whose death could not affect the world as against God the Father whose death would be catastrophic for the universe, or if God the Son had perfect love for mankind, God the Father and God the Holy Ghost would have to be judged as imperfect. In any case, either of the three members of Trinity would have to be considered as imperfect, and all religions are agreed in the stand that an imperfect being cannot be God.
Yet another question presents itself: Does Judaism regard atonement to be an imperative doctrine? In our opinion the Bible does not regard it as necessary, for the simple reason that atonement would be called for only when sin was unforgivable. The Bible, however, declares that sins are forgiven; the entire text of the Bible is permeated with teachings about forgiveness and it is replete with teachings about sacrifices that are accepted by the Lord God. In fact, the Bible lists people who were born after Adam (peace be on him) and whose sacrifices were pleasing to God and He granted them the favour of His nearness. It says:
“And in process of time it came to pass, that
Cain brought of the fruit of the ground an
offering unto the Lord. And Abel, he also
brought of the firstlings of his flock and of the fat thereof, And the Lord had respect
unto Abel and to his offering:
But unto Cain and to his offering he had
no respect. And Cain was very wroth, and
his countenance fell. And the Lord said
unto Cain, Why art thou wroth? and why
is thy countenance fallen? If thou doest