(Luke 1:6)
Did Jesus Redeem Mankind?, Part 3
well, shalt thou not be accepted? and if
thou doest not well, sin lieth at the door.
And unto thee shall be his desire, and thou
shalt rule over him.” (Genesis, 4:3-7)
The above references show that (l) notwithstanding the sin of Adam (peace be on him), sacrificial offerings of some of his sons were accepted; as for instance, the offering of Abel was. He became the favoured one of God, the Almighty, it is said. It is clear that acceptance of him by God would not mean that God made him His favoured one and took his offering as a living sacrifice which spirals a man’s excellence to greater heights. For, acceptance of the offering has no meaning other than this that his reward from God had become a continued reality. Abel and Cain were both sons of Adam (peace be on him) and born after the incident of his sin. Both should have inherited the father’s sin. But in spite of the fact that both were born with sin, when they made the offering, it was accepted of one as against that of the other which was not. Had they inherited sin, they would not make the offering and if they did, it should have been rejected of both.
(2) The above reference carries the following words:
“If thou doest well, shalt thou not be
accepted?”
It means that “if thou cared to become righteous, would not the Father make thee His favoured one?” The clear corollary of the above statement is that “if thou carest to become righteous thou canst and the gate to virtue is ever open to thee if thou wouldst but wish to enter it.” And similarly the words would mean: “ The opportunity to become a favourite of Lord God and His elect is there only if thou wouldst avail of it.”
This is indeed much further than where salvation takes. It is evident that men were accepted by God, the Almighty till that period through their deeds and not through atonement and man could win Divine approbation through repentance after he had sinned. The two conclusions point out that every individual can become righteous and every man can become a favourite of God the Great. If it were not so, there would be no point in addressing Cain in the words: “If thou doest well, shalt thou not be accepted. And if thou doest not well, sin lieth at the door.”
(3) It is further said, “And if thou doest not, sin lieth at the door.” Christianity says that the seed of sin was sown in the heart of man after Adam committed sin. This in fact, makes sin hereditary. But the Bible avers that sin did not enter the heart of man but that it “lieth at the door” of his house. It means it does not inhere in the heart of man but invades it from outside. The Bible thus does not hold that the seed of sin was sown in the heart of man after Adam sinned, but that it “lieth” at the door of every man. In other words, sin is an external thing and not a hereditary element forming part of the constitution of man.
(4) It is again said: “and thou shalt rule over him.” It is addressed to Cain. When God bids him to do a certain thing, it is evident that it is a practical possibility. We do not ask a small child in an affectionate manner, unless we are joking frivolously, to go and carry back the car or to take hold of an elephant. We would ask him to do only what is within his capacity. If an officer were to order a peon in his office to bring him the railway engine bound for Jacobabad, one may well anticipate his reaction. The first thing he would do is to make off on some pretext and with his face drained of all colour he would tell others that the boss had gone out of his mind for his having required of him to do something beyond human capacity. [If sin could not be conquered, why did then God tell Cain that he could overcome it?]
There is no doubt about it that God rejected his offering, saying that since he had not offered the sacrifice in the spirit of sincerity and in good faith which alone made it deserving of acceptance, He, therefore, would not accept it of him. At the same time, He told him that the offering once rejected by Him was not rejected for good and that it was still open to him to overcome sin and attain His favour. Clearly, man could conquer sin through personal effort and application.
Leaving alone the sin of Adam, Allah the Supreme went as far as to say with regard to Cain’s sin, that it was not something that could not be overcome and that if he cared to strive, he could conquer sin and exhorted him to overcome it.
The above-quoted reference further shows that Christians follow Cain while the Muslims follow Abel. For, Christians believe in forgiveness through atonement and are hostile to the Holy Prophet Muhammad (peace and the blessings of Allah be on him) and to Muslims because their own offering was not accepted like that of Cain. They are, therefore, bent on avenging it on Muhammad the Prophet of Allah (peace and the blessings of Allah be on him) and his followers. In the Christian world of today we find the words of God the
Almighty addressed to Cain: “And if thou doest not well, sinn lieth at the door. And unto thee shall be his desire” coming true. There is no end to sin in which the Christian world abounds.
To come to the point, according to the Bible, man could become righteous even after the sin of Adam and that the seed of sin had not been sown in his heart; on the contrary, even in that age it invaded from outside and in the event of his sinning, the door to repentance stood ajar and he had the chance to conquer sin; in fact, he could go one further— he could become the favourite of God, the Supreme. The contingency, which, the Christians say, calls for atonement, does not arise according to the Bible.
Yet another question arises about the theory of vicarious atonement. Suppose there was no virtue left in the world and vicarious atonement became imperative, would there be the need of the Son of God for such atonement? The other question that arises is: Was Messiah the Son of God?
In order to examine the question—Was atonement imperative?—we should turn to the book of the Messiah.
The Bible agrees that prophets of God have been showing various miracles. According to it the Prophets used to quicken the dead, cure the sick, increase the scanty meals and show miracles of different types. But the Christians say (I have used the word Christians purposely for they say many things on their own which find no confirmation in the New Testament, even in its existing distorted version) that forgiveness of sins is beyond human power and that prophets no doubt quickened the dead as is said of Elijah and Isaiah (Kings 1, 17:22 and Kings II, 4:35) but that forgiving of sin was not in the range of possibility. Now let us see whether the New Testament supports this view.
The New Testament relates that a cripple was once brought on his bed to the Messiah. The Messiah gave him a look and said,
“Son, be of good cheer; thy sins be forgiven
thee.” (Matthew 9:2)
This amazed the people and they wondered that he forgave sins. Christianity says the same thing in this age. How can man forgive sin, it asks. But the New Testament says: