(Matthew 5:9)

Did Jesus Redeem Mankind?, Part 4

In short, this quotation makes it clear that the word ‘Son’ is a metaphoric expression used by the Messiah; it did not carry the sense that he was a partner with God. It was, on the contrary, an expression the like of which people are wont to use in respect of their sons, as, for instance, they would call them the apples of their eyes. As men have a right to use terms of endearment, so has God the right to use terms of endearment, in respect of His servants. It happens very often that one is tempted to call a friend’s child son. It never happens that later on he files claim of inheritance citing witnesses that he had been accepted as son in their presence. It is recognized on all hands that such terms are expressive of affection. In the same way, a mother uses similar terms in respect of her child, as, for instance, she would call him the apple of her eyes. Now it never happens that a live child is required to be buried with the mother, should she happen to die, because he was no more a child but that he was the apple of the deceased’s eyes. None is known to have done such a stupid thing in the world. It is common knowledge that all such epithets are expressions of endearment and affection. Like words are sometime employed by God the Almighty in respect of His favoured servants; He sometimes calls them His children as he called the Messiah (peace be on him), or, for that matter, he used the term in respect of several other prophets. The naming of a particular person as son would not therefore mean that the Only God had henceforth ceased to be or that henceforward there shall be two or three gods.

Briefly speaking, the above quotation indicates that according to the Messiah (peace be on him), God is a different person, other than the Messiah. That is why the Only God has been spoken of as distinct from the Messiah. If the latter were God, he need not have been mentioned separately. The only God would have included God the Father, God the Son and God the Holy Ghost. But he has been mentioned apart from the Only God; it means, therefore, that he is not a part of the person of the Only God. These quotations thus establish that the term “Son of God” was not used in the literal sense, in respect of the Messiah but that it was employed only as metaphoric expression.

The Christians also believe that the Messiah has no body as God has no form and that when he came into the world, he took a physical form for the sake of mankind; that in reality the son has no form as the Father has none, even as the Holy Ghost has none. When he came into the world to offer himself up on the Cross for the sons of men he took a bodily form. In other words, taking of a physical body was for the sole purpose of hanging by the Cross to atone for the sins of mankind, so that he may suffer death once, as death is the crop of sin, and that since he took up the sins of others, death had become inevitable. But when death had come upon him, the scheme adopted to save mankind had found its implementation. If, therefore, the Christian claim is a sound one, it was necessary that the Messiah should have no physical body when he rose again, for, the purpose of God had been fulfilled, the sins of mankind had been remitted, and now the son stood no more in need of a body as he had become perfect like God the Father. But it appears from the New Testament that even after the incident of the Cross, when, according to them the Messiah rose from the dead, he had his physical body and ascended the heaven or, according to other versions, disappeared from the summit of the mountain with the same body. In other words, as the New Testament would have us believe, the Messiah not only rose from the sepulchre with his physical body but that he ascended into heavens with the same while his physical form had no significance any more. So long as he had not come into the world, he had no body. He assumed a physical form as a temporary measure for the sole purpose of taking upon himself the sins of mankind. Once the object was served there was logically no need to support the body any further.

But the New Testament holds that he rose from the dead with his physical body and went to heaven with it. Thus the entire edifice of his divinity topples to the ground, and the fact emerges that the Messiah whom the Christians believe to be the equal of God the Father, is still imprisoned in his physical human form in the heavens. Again, the New Testament does not say when he will part with this body; in fact it says that he will be coming with it when he makes his second advent; as it is mentioned that when he will come next “And then shall they see the Son of man coming in clouds with great power and glory.” (Mark 13: 26), (i.e., his claim will not be readily accepted; that there will arise many doubts and misgivings).

The New Testament thus clearly says that people will see the Messiah the second time also in the same body.

It is evident that he cannot suffer death a second time, for death came upon him the first time for purposes of atonement. Once atonement has been offered, there is no room any more for death which means that either Christians must concede the position that Jesus will eternally remain imprisoned in his physical body, without the hope of release from it, or, that they should agree that the theory about the assumption by him of physical body was ill-founded; for, if it were a tenable proposition, he should have been free of the bodily encumbrance after the incident of the Cross. On the contrary, instead of being free of it, according to the New Testament, he rose again with the same body and ascended into the heavens with it.

Apropos the Christian claim that the Messiah offered atonement, it is necessary to ascertain whether the Messiah (peace be on him) was a willing party to the act. The whole crux of the matter is that God would not remit the sins of men, and since He could not, He accepted the atonement of their sins through inflicting punishment on Jesus. Their argument is that if Zaid is in debt and Bakr comes forward to meet the former’s liability, the debit account of Zaid is written off; that men have become indebted to God the Almighty through their sins; and because He is just, He cannot forgive, for, according to their view, justice demands that the sinner should incur punishment; He, therefore, remedied the situation by realizing the outstandings from His son! Suppose it was a correct stand, though a money debt is in no manner comparable to sin—on the contrary, the case in point is really akin to the instance of a victim of cancer; if in respect of him ten thousand persons would assert that it is they and not he who suffered from cancer and that they would readily bear his trouble, they could not. There are many other similar predicaments so frequently occurring in the world which are not susceptible of vicarious recompense, and sin is certainly one of these. But let us for the sake of argument accept the Christian viewpoint that sin is susceptible of vicarious atonement. The question that would still remain to be answered is whether it is lawful to take away forcibly the money of A to square up the account of B? It is quite evident that it would be permissible for A to pay off the debts of B, if he so wished of his own free will. But if we refuse to write off the debt B owes us and force the sum out of A’s pocket to square the account, not only do we fail in doing justice, but we commit a grave wrong. Failure of justice arose out of our not realizing the arrears from the debtor; an act of grievous wrong was done when the amount was forcibly realized from an unconcerned person. Therefore, if the

Messiah (peace be on him) was agreeable to redeem the debt of men and the other premises are also proven, we have no choice left but to concede that his atonement stands validated.

But even if Christianity proves the other premises which we have exploded in the foregoing dissertation and fails to establish that the Messiah (peace be on him) took upon himself the sins of mankind of his free will, the whole fabric of the atonement theory comes down with a crash, for the simple reason that the major actor in the atonement drama was an unwilling scapegoat.

We now turn to the New Testament to find out what it has to say in this behalf. It is mentioned in St. Mark

“And they came to a place which was

named Gethsemane: and he saith to his

disciples, Sit ye here, while I shall pray.

And he taketh with him Peter and James

and John, and began to be sore amazed,

and to be very heavy; And saith unto them,

My soul is exceeding sorrowful unto death:

pray in seclusion.

tarry ye here, and watch. And he went forward a little, and fell on the ground, and prayed that, if it were possible, the hour might pass from him. And he said, Abba, Father, all things are possible unto thee; take away this cup from me: nevertheless not what

I will, but what thou wilt. And he cometh, and findeth them sleeping, and saith unto

of them to accompany him and later, fearing that their presence would stifle the free expression of wailing and moaning, he told them to stay behind and keep awake.

should not put him to the Cross—the means whereby he was to carry the sins of all mankind.

on the Cross against his free will and was not agreeable to the assignment;

atonement, but thou hast willed it so and I am being dragged to it against my will.

It sounds like the case of a Banker realizing forcibly arrears outstanding against A from B—an unconcerned party and then writing off the debtor’s debit account. Messiah says in unambiguous language: “Nevertheless not what I will, but what thou wilt.” In other words, he meant to say that he had no wish at

·

10 of 10 left today