(Matthew 5:9)
Did Jesus Redeem Mankind?, Part 5
Peter, Simon, sleepest thou? couldest not thou watch one hour? Watch ye and pray, lest ye enter into temptation. The spirit truly is ready, but the flesh is weak. And again he went away, and prayed, and spake the same words. And when he returned, he found them asleep again, (for their eyes were heavy,) neither wist they what to answer him. And he cometh the third time, and saith unto them, Sleep on now, and take your rest; it is enough, the hour is come; behold, the Son of man is betrayed into the hands of sinners. Rise up, let us go; lo, he that betrayeth me is at hand.”
This quotation shows that the Messiah (peace be on him)
all to hang on the Cross but he was prepared if God had so willed.
Peter which means ‘rock’—meaning that he would one day serve as a rock for Christianity.
strong enough for the ordeal but that his body, because of human weakness, was unprepared.
will but what thou wilt.”
agitation to see if the disciples shared his grief and stood by him in his misfortune but he would every time find them asleep.
did not offer atonement of his own free will which, in fact, was all for the cup to pass from him and had voted against crucifixion. Whatever, therefore, took place was through coercion.
In this respect the second testimony is offered by St. Luke. It is said: “And he came out, and went, as was his wont, to the mount of Olives; and his disciples also followed him. And when he was at the place he said unto them, pray that ye enter not into temptation. And he was withdrawn from them about a stone’s cast, and kneeled down, and prayed. Saying, Father, if thou be willing, remove this cup from me; nevertheless, not my will, but thine, be done.” (In other words, the New Testament agrees that the Messiah said that it was not his wish but that if the Lord had willed it so, he was agreeable to be hanged; so to speak, he said he was not willing to pay up the debt of others but if God had so willed, he could very well have His way.)
“And there appeared an angel unto him from heaven, strengthening him” (i.e., an angel strengthened and heartened God. It is like a rat or something meaner still heartening an horse.)
“And being in an agony he prayed more earnestly.” (In other words, even the ministration of the angel failed and the Messiah devoted himself to prayer so that death on the Cross be averted from him).
“And his sweat was as it were great drops of blood falling down to the ground.” Though it was severe cold at the time, it being the month of December, the Messiah lived in the northern part and was at a mountain at the time. His agony was so great that while praying in such severely cold season, his sweat started falling in drops. After this prayer he came over to his disciples. Since it is hard for a person to reveal his own shortcomings, lest the enemy should taunt him, here St. Luke puts a strange construction, though St. Marks makes no bones about it that the Messiah (peace be on him) time and again returned to the disciples exhorting them to wake up and pray but that they would not stir; St. Luke, however, seems to have felt that people would at once point out that the Messiah had a strange set of disciples who would not budge an inch, in spite of repeated reminders by the Messiah to be up and praying. In order, therefore, to counteract that impression, St. Luke says:
“And when he rose up from prayer, and was come to his disciples he found them sleeping for sorrow;” (i.e., they were so much overwhelmed with grief that they went to sleep). “And said unto them, why sleep ye? rise and pray, lest ye enter into temptation.”
(According to St. Luke, it would mean that they were so much grief-stricken that they had fallen asleep on account of it. In other words, one in the grip of overwhelming grief is prone to slumber and when he has no sorrow he prays. It clearly shows that St. Luke wanted to counteract the reader’s impression that the Messiah’s disciples were not very much concerned about the Master even in his hour of misfortune and remained fast asleep. Therefore, he inserted the words, “he found them sleeping for sorrow” and the Messiah said unto them: “Rise and pray, lest ye enter into temptation” (St. Luke 22: 45-46).
This quotation also bears out that the Messiah (peace be on him) was not willing to suffer death on the Cross. The entire basis of the doctrine of Atonement rests on the assumption that Jesus willingly suffered crucifixion to atone for the sins of mankind. But since he did not, of his own free choice hang on the Cross, there has therefore been no atonement. Christians generally advance the plea that there was no question of compulsion when Jesus himself said: “Nevertheless, not what I will but what thou wilt.” We agree that it was so, as we expect no prophet to resist the will of God. When Jesus saw that God had willed that he should hang on the Cross, he submitted to the Lord God saying: “Thy will be done.” But that at least proves the fact that Jesus did not offer atonement of his own free will, and there is certainly no atonement at the instance of God; it is valid only when the person offering it does so of his own volition. The Messiah very clearly asserts that it is not his desire to offer atonement. It is quite another thing that he agreed under pressure. It sounds exactly like a man handing out his cash with a smiling countenance to burglars holding him up in a forest; he knows that one word of protest from him, and they would kill him then and there. It does not at all mean that he is giving them his money with a willing heart. The question, therefore, is not that God made him agreeable to it by force. The question is whether Jesus was agreeable to it of his own volition and free will. If Jesus had offered it of his own free choice, he will be deemed to have made the redemption and not otherwise. The above-quoted references make it evident that the Messiah (peace be on him) made it clear that he was not willing, to be crucified. Whatever, therefore, took place was due to a compelling factor and this totally nullifies the theory of redemption.
Some Christians are wont to characterize the Messiah’s unwillingness as a temporary state of his mind which, they said, later underwent a change. In order to determine this point, we now turn to the mental attitude of Jesus at the time of crucifixion. There is only one Hebrew sentence preserved intact in the entire text of the New Testament, which the Messiah uttered on the occasion. It is “Eli Eli lama sabachthani” (St. Matthew 27:46). When the Messiah (peace be on him) was put on the Cross and his hands and feet were nailed, in extreme agony, he prayed to the Lord God saying, “O my Lord! O my Lord! why hast thou forsaken me?” In other words, “For what fault didst thou abandon me and turn away from me thy merciful gaze?” This prayer also confirms the fact that the Messiah was not agreeable to be crucified of his own free will. On the contrary, he was under the impression in his last moments, that God had forsaken him, leaving him in that misfortune. In other words, the Messiah was not agreeable at heart to be crucified and when he was not agreeable to it at any time, either before the fact or after crucifixion, his crucifixion cannot, therefore, be properly termed as an act of redemption.
Another question which comes up for examination simultaneously is whether the Messiah (peace be on him) was free from the sin of Adam to be worthy of offering atonement. The theory of vicarious atonement is based on the premises that man cannot be pure, for, he is begotten of Adam who had sinned and since the progeny inherits, the parent, the children of Adam inherited sin and have no escape from it and, therefore, they cannot attain to salvation. As no sinner can atone for another sinner, it became imperative that there should be one who had not sinned and could of his own free choice, take up the sins of m n and offer to suffer for them, so that they could be redeemed. And this person was Jesus of Nazareth who was Son of God. He bore the sins of mankind and redeemed them by vicarious atonement through hanging on the Cross. This, in a nutshell, is the theory of vicarious atonement.
Now, if it is established that Jesus is not free from sin, the entire theory of atonement collapses; since if he was not sinless, he was not fit to offer atonement. Christians usually advance the argument that because prophets were not free from sin, they could not therefore, atone for others, neither Abram, nor Moses, nor David; they were all sinful and no sinner would atone for another sinner. But we understand from the New Testament that Jesus too was not free from sin. Naturally, therefore, when he was not sinless, he could not bear the sins of others.