(Matthew 5:9)
Did Jesus Redeem Mankind?, Part 8
If, therefore, the Messiah died a natural death, the innovation among Muslims meets a short shrift and their entire gossamer is torn to bits and the erroneous beliefs they have long been involved in are falsified. For, if the Messiah died his natural death, the coming Messiah must rise from among the Muhammadan people, and for Islam and Muslims a great objective is at once reared up. The nations, whose hopes are dead, die out. But nations, whose hopes live, can never perish.
If, it is said that the difference between man and God is unlimited and since the condition of man is different from that of God, therefore, the punishment that man could undergo eternally was equal to the Son of God remaining in hell for a day and a half and, therefore, the one-and-a-half-day visit of the Son of God to hell should not be a matter of surprise, in comparison with the eternal punishment to the entire mankind; that the torment they would suffer through eternity, the Messiah had suffered in a day and a half, then the answer to this is as follows:
When there is a limitless difference between God and man which even Christians admit, considering this very infinity of difference, it is not within human power to comprehend the extent of disparity between God and men. Something that, is limitless is beyond human comprehension. Only a limited quantity which is within the reach of ken, is susceptible of comprehension. Now when this incomprehensible disparity is kept in view against the belief that the collective punishment of 570 crore was made up by God going to hell for a day and a half and redeeming mankind thereby, it means, in other words, that they have computed the measure of the period it takes God to suffer the punishment that mankind should undergo. When the disparity between God and man is incomprehensible, how is it that they could estimate that all that cumulative suffering had been undergone by God in the course of a day and a half. In that case, it was not proper to keep him in hell even for a minute, nay, even, one thousandth of a second should more than suffice in His case. For, here the comparison lay between man of limited powers and God of infinite powers, and it is a senseless thing indeed to make an estimation of God of unlimited powers in terms of the limited capacities of man. Even the periodlimit of a second cannot be justified in His case. In fact, because of the incomprehensibility of the difference, even suffering for as long as the twinkling of the eye, should be impossible for God. How could they, under the circumstances, compute it at a day and a half and comprehend, with their limited capacities, in respect of God, the possessor of unlimited powers, that He bore in a day and a half the punishment that mankind would suffer for aeons and aeons of time.
Again, the question is: who went to hell, the son of man or the Son of God? If the Son of man went, then it is understandable enough, since human soul originates from human body and is attached to it, it was his soul therefore, that, went to hell. But there was no other soul— the body was no doubt human, but there was the Son of God in it. And if the Son of God is delivered of the body, he at once becomes God. He is son of man so long as he is imprisoned in the human frame. When he is delivered of the human frame, he automatically becomes the Son of God, and when he becomes the son of God, he becomes like God and when he becomes like God, there is no sense in his going to hell. Is God subject to cold and heat or does he feel comforted by cold and tormented by heat? If human soul goes to hell, it will feel the heat. If it is kept in a cold place, it will feel the cold. But the Son of God who is God is above heat and cold. Hell is as much His creation as is heaven. Hell can do him no harm nor would paradise give him any comfort. It occurs in the Ahadith (sayings of the Holy Prophet) that when God would put his foot in hell, hell would become cold, for, hell is no hell for God. If the Messiah, therefore, was son of man and possessed human soul, then it was not God who entered hell, but it was man who entered it. But if he carried the soul of the Son of God, then as soon as it was delivered of the body, it at once became Godlike, and as it became like God, even if it be taken to hell, it would suffer no torment. After all the Messiah did not have two souls that it could be said that one was human and the other was divine. He had only one soul and that of the Son of God and as it was delivered of the body, hell was no longer hell for it. Even if it is then taken to hell, it has no torment for it, for, it is above physical feelings, neither paradise has any effect on it nor has hell.
Christians, sometimes in dismay, say that all this narrative is allegoric and we have no reason to treat it as factual. Our contention is that if all this is allegoric, novel theories cannot be deduced from allegories. In this case too the theory of redemption falls flat. For, when you are not making a factual statement but talking in allegory, there is no justification for you to deduce novel concepts from it and to invite people to believe in them. As, for instance, if we say in respect of somebody that he is a lion in the true sense of the word and when somebody wants us to point out his tail and his paws and we answer back that we were talking only allegorically and he was wrong in mistaking him for an actual lion, it will not be fair on our part to go on calling it a lion in the true sense of the word. If, therefore, this is an allegoric description, Christians must agree that the Messiah was described as the Son of God only allegorically, and if he was the Son of God allegorically, he could not bear the sins of mankind nor could he stay in hell for a day and a half. All these statements then become false and unreal.
Whenever they decline, their hopes sustain them and create in them a new awakening and alertness and they know that they have little ground for despair and that there are in wait great opportunities for them to achieve higher levels. But once the hopes of a people are killed, it perishes for ever. The Promised Messiah (peace and salutations be on him) has thus to his credit two outstanding achievements. On the one hand, he put an end to Christianity by showing up that the Messiah was alive after he came off the Cross and, on the other hand, he saved Islam from erroneous belief, by pointing out, that in the light of the verses in the Holy Qur’an, the Messiah died a natural death. How much poetic beauty underlies this dissertation? He quickened the Messiah and made short work of Christianity, and he put an end to the Messiah’s life and quickened Islam. Since the Church is founded on the basis that the Messiah died on the Cross, if it is proved that the Messiah did not die on the Cross, but came off it alive, the redemption theory is demolished at once.
In short, the question that confronts us is whether the Messiah died on the Cross and whether he offered the sacrifice which could be adequate atonement. A study of the Bible gives the answer in the negative. Neither the Messiah died on the Cross, nor did he offer the sacrifice which could be termed as adequate atonement. If we carefully study the New Testament, it becomes evident that the real miracle of the Messiah on which Christianity prides itself and which finds so much prominence in the early stages of Christianity, was the miracle of the Prophet Jonas. Christians were a negligible quantity for a long time after the incident of the Cross. They would escape to one country to seek shelter and then to another. Mostly they lived in hiding. For, whenever the people would get a scent of them, they would subject them to various kinds of tyrannies. Barring the early hardships they suffered at the hands of Jews in Palestine, they were persecuted mostly by pagan races, particularly the Romans. A Christian could not help asserting that the Messiah was the king of the world. But no sooner would he say this than the Romans would flare up and start tyrannizing them. The Jewish attack had slackened in those days; in fact, according to some evidence, it appears that whenever Christians would go in hiding, Jews would follow suit. For, their religions had much in common, and the Jews had not yet been so much alienated with the Mosaic Law as they are at present but were in fact given to observing it. As we offer prayers and so do the non-Ahmadis and we fast and the non-Ahmadis also fast and we go to the Haj pilgrimage and so the non-Ahmadis go to the Haj and we believe in the Holy Qur’an and so do the non-Ahmadis. If one were to see the form, without going into the difference in beliefs, he would conclude that there was no difference between the Ahmadis and the non-Ahmadis.
Similarly, the Jews believed in the Torah as much as did the Christians, and, the Jews were as much given to alms-giving as were the Christians, and, as the Christians considered the teachings of the Torah of practical significance so did the Jews and, since the entire teaching appeared to be common to both, therefore whenever the Romans would get inflamed against Christians and start oppressing them, they would oppress the Jews as well taking them as part of them. No doubt the Jews were first responsible for their persecution, but the position changed later and whenever the Romans oppressed, they oppressed both the Christians and the Jews, making no distinction between the two. Therefore, whenever Christians sought for shelter, the Jews also would go into hiding with them. Some ruins found in Rome confirm this.
I think the Christians showed great courage in the face of bitter opposition in Rome and the cruel hardships which the Government inflicted on them in concentrating heavily on preaching there. They had powerful missions in Rome. There, people used to oppose them on account of their missionary activity, oppress them and take over their properties. But tyranny does not last long. They used to beat them up at first but would leave them alone later as Hindus lose their temper in contemporary India at certain places and start Muslim-baiting but after a time conditions become calm. The tyranny raises its head in another area and after some time calm settles down there.
Their first main centre was in Rome, another in Antioch and the third centre was in Alexandria. In all the three centres, Christian missionaries used to be assaulted and the enemy would either kill them or hurt them. Because of these recurring attacks, Christians would take to hiding in their houses or run away to suburban villages or make hide-outs underground. In those days some people used to make their sepulchres underground and would excavate stones for the purpose from the earth. Christians would clear up the cavities that were made after excavating stones and make their quarters there. There are many such places in Rome where Christians took refuge for a long time. These are called catacombs. There are still extant many pictures which they drew to keep their religious zeal or the memory of their martyrs alive. Similarly, there are tomb stones giving the identity of the person and the incidents leading to his martyrdom. I have seen a part of these catacombs. I could not see the whole of the area. It is spread over seventy miles. In brief, a view of the catacombs gives an idea of the ancient history of Christianity; for, the catacombs put into perspective the picture of tyrannies that preceded the expansion of Christianity and the inscriptions on tablets and the drawings reveal the beliefs of the Christians of the age. In the third century of the Christian era, the Emperor of Rome had embraced Christianity and Christianity gained strength henceforward.
An idea of the conditions pertaining to the earlier period is gained through a visit to the catacombs. In these catacombs, we generally come across three drawings, one of the Noah’s ark, the other of a shepherd with a flock of sheep around him and the third of a fish swallowing up the Prophet Jonas. It shows that the foundation of Christianity in early history was laid on only three things, or, in other words, three concepts which were symbolic for Christianity. The portrait of the shepherd hinted that the Messiah had come to gather the lost sheep or Jews; the Noah’s ark signified that the Messiah was their saviour and the picture of the prophet Jonas signified the miracle which will be discussed in the following pages. In short, it was hinted through these drawings that Christianity was based on three fundamentals: (l) the Messiah came to gather his lost sheep. (2) The Messiah is the saviour and (3) the Messiah was give the sign that the Prophet Jonas was given.
The Christian church is evidently based on this miracle, nay, Christianity claims it to be the only miracle, and all the drawings and paintings of the early period which are found in Christian literature point to this— the picture of the shepherd who has been shown with the flock of his sheep, the drawing of the Noah’s ark, and the picture portraying the entry or the Prophet Jonas in the belly of the fish. It shows that this was the real miracle of Christianity, The Messiah himself characterizes it as his singular and real miracle. The New Testament says, the Messiah (peace be on him) said in the course of a sermon, “Then certain of the scribes and of the Pharisees answered, saying, Master, we would see a sign from thee. But he answered and said unto them, “An evil and adulterous generation seeketh after a sign; and there shall no sign be given to it, but the sign of the Prophet Jonas; For as Jonas was three days and three nights in the whale’s belly; so shall the son of man be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth.” (Matthew 12:38-40)