(Matthew 5:9)

Did Jesus Redeem Mankind?, Part 7

The Christians can very well point out here that we (Muslims) too hold that Jesus was born without a father with the result that the enemy is given a chance to level the calender that he was born out of wedlock, and that while we did not believe in his vicarious atonement and rejected at the same time the Christian viewpoint, wherefore then do we hold that the Messiah was born without a father? The answer is that according to us, the reason for the Messiah being born without a father is that God the Almighty had made a promise to Abram (peace be on him) that there would rise prophets in future from among his progeny and that the kingdom of God would remain with them till the heaven and the earth lasted. This promise was repeated through Prophets successively. This promise came to be fulfilled for centuries, so much so, that the people of the Mosaic dispensation became bold and came to believe that in no case would God forsake the children of Abram and that prophethood and dominion could not go out of the Mosaic dispensation. The result was that the warnings of the Divine prophets began to be disregarded. Prophets would come and proffer their teachings but the Jews would only ridicule them, as for instance, Jeremiah and others came and the Jews rejected them outright, laughing them off and taking for granted that God had given them the bliss for good. Then God gave them through some prophets the tiding that a virgin would give birth to a son, meaning that the promised one would be only half-Israelite and half non-Israelite. This was a warning pointing out that if the Jews persisted in turning a deaf ear to the teachings of the prophets, then in future another prophet would rise who would neither be an Israelite from his father’s side nor from his mother’s side.

The promise was fulfilled in the person of Jesus—he was born without a father, and since the generation is carried forward from the father’s side, it served as a notice to the Jews that half the prophethood had been taken away from them. They were thus told that the prophet sent at the time was not of the Jews from the father’s side, and if they did not benefit by the admonition, the next prophet would be a non-Israelite, though of the stock of Abram. And so, it came to pass. Since Allah had made many promises to Abram (peace be on him) and would not brook depriving Jews of the benefits of these promises, without sufficient cause, He first sent prophets in succession. When Prophets came to the Jews one after the other and they became entrenched in the belief that prophethood would not pass on to non-Israelites, God the Almighty administered warnings through Prophets in such a manner that the Jews, given a small modicum of faith, could have come to their senses and to a realization that something was impending on account of their wickedness. But they did not mend their ways and persisted in mischief-mongering. At last the Almighty God created the Messiah without a father, as He had fore-warned and gave the Jews to understand, that half the prophethood had been taken away from them and that if they desisted not from their ways, the remaining half would also be taken away from them by way of punishment; that the prophet who had been sent at the time was a Jew from his mother’s side and was not so from his father’s side, but that in future a Prophet would be raised who, though of Abram’s stock, would be a non- Israelite.

Accordingly, after that Allah sent Muhammad the Prophet (peace and the blessings be on him), who was an Ishmalite, and chain of prophethood was cut off for ever from the Israelites. Therefore, our belief in the Messiah being without a father is noto pen to any criticism. According to us, a deep philosophy underlies it. But the theory they advance in this behalf has been turned down by us, our stand being that it does not make the Messiah sinless and that, on the contrary, it shows him to be a greater sinner than others and nullifies vicarious atonement.

Another point which deserves consideration in respect of the theory of vicarious atonement is whether the death of Jesus on the Cross could redeem the world. The answer is that even if we accept the New Testament version of the incident of crucifixion of Jesus, it is an event a study of which does not convince us that the Messiah made any sacrifice at all. For, according to the New Testament, the Messiah remained in the tomb for a day and a half; his crucifixion happened on Friday in the afternoon and on Sunday morning he was up and about. (St. Mark, Ch. 16)

From Friday night to Saturday evening, it would be a period of 24 hours and from Saturday evening to Sunday morning another 12 hours. It would thus mean that, in the light of the New Testament account, the Messiah stayed in the tomb for a total period of 36 hours. Suppose, the Christian belief that Jesus stayed in hell for a day and a half was correct, the question that still remains is how the Messiah’s one-and-a-half day long stay in the tomb could atone for the sins of the world. According to Christian belief, hell is eternal and whoso of men is consigned to it shall stay there for ever. But we hold that Allah will forgive after a while even the inmates of hell. Allah says in the Holy Qur’an:

i.e., hell is like the mother’s womb as a child is delivered of it after a period, so, shall the inmates of hell be discharged from it after staying in it for a time, and that Allah will admit them into paradise (Al-Qari’ah, 101:10). The Christian belief, on the contrary, is that hell is eternal and whoso enters hell shall never be able to get out of it. Now, there are, in the contemporary world, crores of men who believe in the Messiah. In this age there are some 60 to 70 crore Christians, perhaps more. If this 70 crore were to go to hell and stay there put forever, to what length of period would it work out, if we were to compute it by multiplying this number with eternity, and this just represents the number of present day Christians. If we compute the total number of the people who have believed in the Messiah from his own day, taking the average age of a generation at 30 years, and the average of the Christian population at ten crores—for, they were few before and then grew into a lakh, then too Iakhs, then seventy to eighty lakhs and later their numbers ran into crores till they were as many as 70 to 80 crores at a single point of time and taking ten crores as an average of this and with three generations in a l00 years period, there having passed thus 57 generations of Christians up to the present time fifty-seven multiplied by 10 crore would make a total figure of 570 crore. Now let us multiply the punishment of this 570 crore men with eternity and see the result. In other words, if the Messiah would not offer atonement, these 570 crore men would have remained in hell eternally and it makes such a colossal period that it is beyond computation in terms of figures. But the Almighty Lord, by consigning His son to hell for a day and a half, accepted atonement in return for eternal punishment. It is claimed that the Messiah was crucified so that the justice of God remains without a blemish. In other words, if other people were to enter hell, they would have been kept there eternally, but when His own son was concerned, he was kept for a day and a half, and it was said that all had been redeemed thereby.

It has a likeness to a village story. It is said that some naughty boys of a village while playing outside, espied a dead donkey. They counselled among themselves to cook it and eat it up, as dead or alive, it was but flesh. Accordingly, they cooked the donkey meat and ate it. Village folk extremely dislike such things. As they came to know of it, they lost no time in going to their Mullah and telling him that a terrible thing had happened—the boys had cooked and ate up a dead donkey and they feared lest some visitation from God overtake them. The Mullah said that a great sin had been committed and that atonement should be made forthwith as otherwise the wrath of Allah will be upon them. They were out of their wits already, the Mullah frightened them still more. Thereupon they asked the Mullah to find a way out of the predicament lest they should all be destroyed. The Mullah agreed and promised to tell them the remedy after consulting the books. Accordingly, he remained engrossed in consulting books of law throughout the day and informed the village folk in the evening that he had found the answer.

“It is written in the books that the atonement of this sin can be made by piling up loaves of bread around a perpendicularly placed beam till it covered its top-end and then giving away of these loaves in the name of God.” In other words, he wanted them to give away the loaves to him, as whatever is given in the name of God, is made over to the Mullah. He thought he would have loaves free for a few days and whatever were saved, he could sell away. It was a small village and the people were poor. As they heard this, they were in a panic and pleaded to the Mullah that they could not afford to offer that much atonement. He warned them that if they would not, they would all land in hell and that the law was clear on the point that that was the only way to atone for the sin. They again consulted among themselves as to what they should do next. A boy spoke out saying that the Mullah’s own son Noor Jamal was also in it. They asked him if he was really speaking the truth. The other boys confirmed that he was with them. After mutual consultation, they decided to enquire of the Mullah again, hoping that he might modify the shape of the problem. Accordingly, they again called on the Mullah and told him that his son Noor Jamal was also in the party. On hearing this, the Mullah feared that he too would have to make atonement. He told them that he will again consult the books. After consulting the books, he announced that there was the alternate solution that if they could not afford that much, then the beam may be laid on the ground and covered with loaves and these few loaves could be given away as alms.

This is like the Noor Jamal episode. If 570 crore men have to be punished, they would suffer eternal punishment, but when it comes to His own son, it is said “We are doing Justice. By keeping him in hell for a day and a half, we take it that he has atoned for the sins of the whole world.”

The world still goes on and if it continued for another 500 or 1,000 years and though by the grace of God, because of Ahmadiyya, Christianity will decline day by day and make no progress, still by the time we multiply, it will have added up another 300 to 400 crore to its numbers—but when the question of the atonement for the sins of such a vast number of men came up, it was said that by keeping the Son in hell for a day and a half, the sins of all had been redeemed and that the dictates of God’s justice and equity had been satisfied. There could be no bigger joke than sentencing 570 crore men to eternal punishment and laying it down that they would never be delivered from hell but deciding in respect of His own son that since he lived in hell for a day and a half, the sins of all had been forgiven. Put this proposal before anybody without mentioning the Messiah and God. Just say this much that there was a person who owed people some 1,50,000 rupees. People demanded that he pay up but he could not. The matter was at last referred to the Court. He petitioned that the debt be written off. The Judge told him that he could not write it off as that would be against justice; that he could not commit the injustice of letting him off scot free while rupees one lakh and a half were outstanding against him. But later he called his son and asked him to pay one rupee and a half in recompense for the debt of rupees one lakh and a half and when he had paid rupee one and a half, he said that all the debt had been redeemed. Will any person who has his senses about him treat this judgment as reasonable? Everybody would condemn the judge not only as dishonest but also as cunning and foxy for his having written off the public debt of Rs. 1,50,000 on receipt of a payment of Rupees l½ from his son. Similarly, the version of atonement that is put forward, far from mitigating the blame on God, only enhances it and such tricks hardly prove Him to be just; on the contrary He is proved to be unjust besides being a cunning trickster. If that was all He had intended doing, why keep him in hell even for a day and a half?

Taking for granted all the claims of Christians that redemption was a possibility and that Messiah was the Son of God, the question that engages our attention is whether it has been proved that Messiah did really offer the sacrifice which could be called adequate for purposes of redemption. Messiah’s coming down the Cross alive is a concept which carries in it the death of Christianity. If the Messiah came down the Cross alive, Christianity is finished totally and if the Messiah died a natural death after the incident of the Cross, then all the wrong beliefs that are current among non-Ahmadis would die out. In other words, the Messiah’s coming down the Cross alive puts an end to Christianity and his natural death closes the chapter of innovation in Islam. If Christianity fades out, it would mean life for Islam and if innovation dies, then too there is life for Islam.

The Promised Messiah (peace be on him and salutations) has accomplished both these achievements. By saving him from death on the Cross, he saved the Messiah on the one hand from an accursed death and on the other, gave a death blow to Christianity, and again saved Islam from innovation by establishing that the Messiah died a natural death. For, it is derogatory both to Islam and to the Holy Prophet Muhammad (peace and the blessings of Allah be on him) that a prophet who neither profited by his faith nor partook of the fruit of his garden, should come to revive the religion of Islam; in fact, it finishes the whole of his mission. The Promised Messiah, through a dual attack, made short work both of Christianity and of innovation. Once he finished Christianity by showing up the Messiah as alive and again he finished innovation in Islam by showing up that he died a natural death. Both these are monumental achievements which shall be remembered as long as the world lasts. It is, however, a matter of regret that our community has not paid much heed to these achievements nor has it grasped their full import. The facts relating to the Messiah’s whereabouts after the incident of the Cross are second line arguments which the Promised Messiah (peace and salutations be on him) has put forward. The crux of the matter is the Messiah’s coming down the Cross alive. If he came off the Cross alive, Christianity is finished. Christians are coming to realize this. Mr. Criltondon, Secretary General of Inter-fellowship, University of London, observed in the course of a speech in the London Mosque on March 11, 1956, that if the Ahmadiyya viewpoint about the death of Jesus was correct, Christianity would be no more and that if the Messiah did not really die on the Cross, the entire foundation of the Church is demolished and the whole of its edifice must come down to earth.

·

10 of 10 left today