The Transmigration of Souls Refuted and a Comparison between the Vedas & the Holy Qur’an

Early Writings, Part 4

Hence, this proves that a perfect maker cannot create anything unless he also has absolute power over everything. This is why no worldly artisan can claim that they are perfect makers. Instead, it is always witnessed in the case of all such craftsmen that when a person makes repeated visits to their workshops and presses them to immediately make a thing, they ultimately become frustrated by these demands and are compelled to retort by saying that they are not God who can create a thing by a mere command and that they will make the required item only when they are able to procure the necessary materials.

In short, everyone knows that to be the Perfect Maker, one must possess absolute omnipotence and providence. The Perfect Maker need not wait for X to die before bestowing a child upon Y. Nor is He compelled to wait for X to expire before He blows life into the foetus of Y who is in a womb. Hence, this establishes the validity of the minor premise.

The validity of the major premise that God must possess perfect omnipotence if He is to be the Creator of all forms of creation is established by the minor premise itself.

Further, it is evident that if God does not possess the absolute power that is necessary over everything, His omnipotence would depend merely on the occurrence of certain coincidences; and as I have stated, it is simple for reason to grasp that in such a case there is a possibility that such things whose availability depends on chance may not be available to Him at a particular time, for they are incidental and not necessarily acquirable at all times, whereas it is essential for the soul to be connected to the foetus at a specific time during the stages of its development. Hence, this proves that if God is to act at the right time, it is necessary for Him to possess the perfect omnipotence.

This argument also proves that God must be All-Powerful because we can, for instance, in view of the established rules of philosophy, suppose that for a certain period of time all existing souls remain attached to their respective bodies for as long as they must. This supposition, however, would also make it necessary for us to believe that until this time passes, no soul can enter those other foetuses which have developed in the wombs of mothers at present. Yet it would be evidently false in terms of rationality to believe that a foetus can remain idle and detached from its soul in this manner. Hence, when the necessary result that follows from a certain proposition is proven false, the proposition itself is also established as false. Hence, in light of the fact that both premises have been established to be valid, it is proven that God is the possessor of perfect providence. Quod erat demonstrandum. The Sixth Argument: The Holy Qur’an presents another argument also by way of compound syllogism. A compound syllogism is constructed with such premises the conclusion of which does not necessarily prove a point to be valid; however, the point can be established if the conclusion is put together with another premise to form a new syllogistic argument. Hence, the required result might be obtained either from the second syllogism developed, or by constructing other syllogisms by linking premises in this manner, to arrive at a final conclusion. In both cases, this type of syllogism is called a compound syllogism.

The verse which is comprised of this kind of argument is the one in Surah al-Baqarah, part 3:

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

That is, God, in His person, is ever worthy of being worshipped by all creation, and there is no partner to Him. This is based on the categorical argument that He is the Living God who is Eternal and that it is due to Him that all things exist, i.e. the existence and survival of everything depends upon His existence and presence. He alone continues to support the existence of all things. He does not suffer slumber, nor sleep. In other words, He is never negligent regarding the protection of His creation. Hence, when the survival of everything depends upon His existence, this proves that it is He who is the Creator and Lord of all things in the heavens and in the earth.

The logical sequence of this argument, as put forth in this verse of the Holy Qur’an, is (the first part of the compound syllogism and the minor premise) that God has the right to be worshipped eternally by all creation without any partner and (the major premise is that) He who deserves to be worshipped eternally by all creation is the one who is Ever-Living and Eternal, and is the Source of subsistence for all things; therefore (the conclusion is that) God is Ever-Living, Eternal and Provider of subsistence to all things.

In the second part of the compound syllogism the conclusion of the first part of the syllogism has been put forth as the minor premise; (and the minor premise is that) God is Eternal and Provider of subsistence to all things, whereas (the major premise is that) He who is Eternal and provides subsistence to all things is necessarily the Creator of all things, therefore (the conclusion is that) God is the Creator of all things.

The minor premise of the first part of the compound syllogism—the proposition that God, without having any partner, deserves to be eternally worshipped by all creation—is valid because even the other party accepts this fact. Hence, there is no need to further establish this argument.

The major premise of the first part of this compound syllogism, i.e. the proposition that he who eternally deserves to be worshipped by all things is the one who is Ever-Living, Eternal and Provider of subsistence to all things, stands proven in the sense that if God is not Eternal and Ever-Living, then one must presume that He came into existence at some time in the past, or that He will no longer remain at some time in the future. In both cases, it would be false to state that He is the Eternal being who is worthy of worship. The reason for this is that when He does not exist anymore, He cannot be worshipped either. For the worship of a thing which does not exist is futile; therefore, when God does not exist and is no longer present as the Eternal being that is worthy of worship, the proposition that God has the right to be worshipped eternally is also rendered false, whereas it has just been proved that the proposition mentioned above is valid and credible. Hence, it must be accepted that he who has the right to be eternally worshipped by all things is the Eternal and the Ever-Living.

Further, if God is not the Provider of subsistence for everything, that is, if the life and survival of all other things does not depend upon His life and existence, His presence will not be necessary for the survival of any kind of creation. In such a case, His role will essentially become ineffective. He will not be the real, essential cause for the survival of other things, for an ineffective being is one whose being and existence is not a necessary condition for the survival and existence of a thing under its influence. For example, if person A throws a stone and then dies immediately after throwing the stone, it will invariably continue to move for some time even after the person would have died. Hence, if, as the people of the Arya Samaj suggest, we should believe God to be nothing more than an ineffective being this would necessitate, God forbid, that even if we suppose Parameshvara to be dead, this would not adversely affect the souls and particles. The statement of Pundit Dayanand which he has recorded in Satyarth Prakash has completely ruined the concept of divine Unity and Pundit Kharak Singh, has followed him without having properly pondered over his statement. According to them it is written in the Vedas that all souls are completely independent of Parameshvara for their survival and life, and that their relationship with Parameshvara is like the relationship of a carpenter to a wooden chair or of a potter to a clay pitcher. In other words, the handicapped Parameshvara runs his business by merely joining things together, and He is not the Sustainer of creations. However, every wise person knows that by believing this to be the case, the being of Parameshvara has only as much significance as ordinary potters and carpenters, inasmuch as things made by them do not rely upon them for their survival. In other words, as is the case with potters and carpenters, when they have died, the pitchers and chairs that they have created will continue to exist; and so, in the same way, even in the case that Parameshvara died, the existence of things will remain unaffected.

This shows that the proposition of Pundit Sahib that in his role as the creator Parameshvara may be likened to a potter or a carpenter, is a false analogy. If only the Pundit had believed God to be the Provider of subsistence to things and had not considered Him to be like ordinary carpenters, he would not have felt compelled to state that even if Parameshvara was presumed dead, this would not cause any harm to the souls. However, this is what the Veda probably states as well; otherwise, personally I find it difficult to believe that Pundit Sahib could doubt the most manifest fact that God is Self-Subsisting and All-Sustaining. And, if Pundit Sahib truly believes Parameshvara to be the Provider of sustenance to everything, then what kind of a good act it is on his part to reduce Him to the likes of potters and carpenters, and what argument is advanced by the Veda in this respect?

One can see that the Holy Qur’an, at a number of places, has proved that God is Self-Subsisting and All-Sustaining, as He states it once again in the following verse:

Meaning, God is the light of the heavens and the earth. It is due to Him that the lower and higher realms are illuminated with the light of life and sustenance. Hence, this discourse proves the validity of part one of the aforementioned compound syllogism. The minor premise of part two of the said compound syllogism is the conclusion of part one of the said syllogism, and the validity of part one of this compound syllogism has just been established. Hence, the conclusion has also been proved.

·

10 of 10 left today