The Transmigration of Souls Refuted and a Comparison between the Vedas & the Holy Qur’an

Early Writings, Part 3

And, the final form of this inference which logically develops on account of the minor and major premise is that we understand it to be an established fact that nothing can come into being except through the agency of a Self-Existing being. And, if this is not true, its opposite, i.e. everything can come into being without the agency of a Self-Existing being, would have to be true. And, the proposition that any possible existent coming into being is impossible without the help of a Self-Existing being, has already been proved to be valid in light of the five parts of the preceding argument I have cited above.

In short, if the conclusion that nothing can come into existence without the agency of a Self-Existing being is invalid, we will have to conclude that the existence of all things is established by the five impossibilities mentioned above. However, the existence of all things through the five impossibilities aforementioned is itself an impossibility. Hence, the conclusion is that the existence of all things without the agency of a Self-Existent being is a sheer impossibility. Quod erat demonstrandum.

The Fourth Argument: The Holy Qur’an also puts forth argumentation by way of conjunctive syllogism. One ought to know that syllogism is the first of the three kinds of argumentation. And, conjunctive syllogism is a kind of syllogism wherein the conclusion or its contradictory is not explicitly stated in the premise, rather it is implied. This type of syllogism is called conjunctive in the sense that its terms, i.e. the minor, middle and major, are connected. Generally, syllogism is the best and foremost of all kinds of argumentation, for it helps a person reach conclusions about a specific part of an object by studying various parts of the object as a whole, thus the study becomes coherent and comprehensive and leads to perfect certainty.

In short, the kind of syllogism that has been spoken of above has been employed by the following verse testifying that God is the Creator. The verse is from Surah al-Hashr, part 28:

God is the Creator, i.e. He brought everything into existence. He is the Maker, i.e. He is the One Who brought the souls and bodies into existence from nothingness. He is the Fashioner, i.e. He is the One who granted everything a form in terms of the physical and in kind because all good qualities are proven to exist in His person, that is to say, all perfect attributes which wisdom can propose for Him based on His perfect powers are found in His being. He, therefore, has the power to bring things into being from nothingness, for to create a thing out of nothing is a great merit indeed among the excellences of the All-Powerful. Hence, the logical sequence of the premises in the first figure of this syllogism, would be that we say that to bring something into being or grant it existence based on one’s own power is an excellence, and that all excellences are possessed by the Perfect and Necessary Being. The conclusion, therefore, is that God also possesses the excellence of bringing into existence. Proof of the validity of the minor premise, i.e. that it is an excellence to create something based on one’s own power, is that if its opposite were true, i.e. to be unable to create anything by one’s own power until and unless some foreign substance comes to one’s aid and support, would prove to be an extreme defect. For, if we were to suppose for a moment that the available substance had all been exhausted on one thing or another, we also have to suppose that God was now absolutely unable to create anything further. To ascribe such a flaw to the Infinite and All-Powerful God would be tantamount to the very denial of His divinity.

In addition, it has been proved with ample evidence in theology that in order for the Self-Existent being to be established as God, it is necessary for Him to comprehend all excellences. In other words, no excellence that the mind can fathom or conceive can be absent from the perfect being of God. Hence, reason demands that the excellence of God’s divinity lies in the excellence of every creation culminating in His being and this excellence not being undermined by the so-called eternity of created beings or the division of the One True Being into various partners.

Moreover, aside from all these arguments and proofs, any pureminded person can understand that any work that is superior in nature requires greater excellence to perform as opposed to work of lesser significance. So, while the joining of all the components of the universe together proves the excellence of God Almighty, how great an excellence it would be to create the universe without having relied upon any means—for this proves that God possesses infinitely greater power and omnipotence. So this proves the validity of the minor premise in this figure of the syllogism.

Evidence of the major premise, i.e. the proposition that the being of God is possessed of all excellences is that if He is not possessed of certain excellences, one may ask whether He is devoid of those excellences on account of His own will or because someone else has forced Him to be so. If it is said that He is devoid of these excellences out of His own volition, this would be false because no one willingly agrees to keep oneself devoid of an excellence. Secondly, if this shortcoming is found in Him from the very beginning, there remains no question of His pleasure or displeasure. As such, if one says that He was compelled to be in this condition, then one must acknowledge the existence of a coercer, who forced Him and prevented Him from enforcing the writ of His divinity. Or even if we suppose that it is His own weakness and helplessness that forced Him to be so and that there is no external coercer, we would still be forced to conclude that He is helpless and powerless. Hence, under these circumstances, such a being is not worthy of being God. This necessarily proves that God is pure and free from the blemish of compulsion or powerlessness as this renders His divinity false and that He is possessed of the perfect attribute of being capable to create a thing out of nothingness. Quod erat demonstrandum.

The Fifth Argument: In the Holy Qur’an evidence of God Almighty being the Creator is established also by way of exceptive syllogism. Exceptive syllogism is a form of logical reasoning wherein either the conclusion (quaesitum) or its contradictory are stated explicitly in the premises. This argument is composed of two types of premises, i.e. conditional and exceptive. As such, a verse of the Holy Qur’an that is based on this manner of reasoning is found in Surah az-Zumar, part 23, as follows:

That is, He creates you in the wombs of your mothers under the darkness of three veils, and the perfect wisdom working behind this is that He bestows upon you one kind of creation and then bestows upon you another kind of creation. In other words, He gives every organ a different shape and bestows upon it different qualities and capabilities. Then, He blows life into a lifeless object. Neither does darkness stop Him from accomplishing His task, nor is it difficult for Him to create different kinds of organs with diverse capabilities, nor does He face any difficulty or incur a loss in eternally continuing the process of creation. This is why He says,

In other words, it is He who eternally keeps this system of nature in function; hence He is God your Lord. In other words, this Perfect Omnipotence proves that He is the Perfect Lord who can create a thing out of nothingness and bring it into existence and then guide it from mere existence to a level of perfection. For if He were not the Lord of all things and if he were not the Perfect Lord and if He acted only like a carpenter or some other craftsman who for the sake of his work collects materials from one place or another, He surely could not be the Perfect Lord and would not always be successful at all times. In such a case, he would definitely be prone to face failure on one occasion or other and thus become unable to create. In a nutshell, the verse proves that He whose actions do not spring from perfect providence, i.e. he who is personally unable to create, can never possess perfect omnipotence either. God, however, is indeed the Omnipotent Lord, and the reason for this is that to create things of diverse nature and to go on creating them one after the other and to continue this process without fail is surely a clear sign of absolute omnipotence. This proves that God is the All-Powerful Lord, that in reality, He is the Lord of everything and not merely a carpenter or builder. Had this not been the case, the workings of the universe could not have continued to function without interruption since its inception and would have met its end long ago. For he who cannot act out of absolute choice, can never be capable of creating a thing at all times and in an infinite number.

The logical sequence of this argument as presented in the Holy Qur’an in the verse quoted above is as follows: If a person whose action of creating an object emanates from perfect omnipotence, then he must also possess the attribute of perfect providence, that is, he must be able to bring into existence a thing out of nothingness; but since God’s action of creating a diverse range of things requires Him to be possessed of perfect omnipotence, therefore, He must also possess the attribute of perfect providence.

The minor premise of this argument states that a creator for whom it is necessary to possess perfect omnipotence must also possess the characteristic of divine providence. This premise is validated by the fact that reason necessarily requires that a creator about whom we have accepted that he faces no difficulty in creating a thing and that when he decides to create a thing, he has available to him all the necessary means to do so, should also have those means available to him at all times and in any number that he requires. Now, this kind of perfect authority cannot be fully establishes unless the creator of an object is also able to create all the required parts of an object. The reason for this is because the availability of those required parts at all times and in any number that is required—in the case of a creator who does not have absolute power to secure those parts—would be a potentiality which may not occur. As such, no philosophical argument can be built on a proposition that may not occur in certain circumstances. And if this manner of argumentation can be constructed, then someone ought to show us an example. The reason for this is obvious. To say that X does not possess perfect command over the creation of an object is synonymous with saying that it is possible that there may be a time when he is simply unable to create that object at all.

·

10 of 10 left today